Archives for October 23, 2026

Why Numbing Behaviors Keep Showing Up in Your Relationship

Key Takeaways

Why food, alcohol and scrolling keep showing up when your relationship gets hard.

Numbing behaviors like overeating, drinking, endless scrolling and gaming are often the work of one protective part that Internal Family Systems (IFS) therapy calls a firefighter. Cutting off one behavior usually moves the problem somewhere else, because the pain the firefighter is putting out is still there. Lasting change comes from turning toward the wounded part underneath, so the firefighter no longer has a job to do.

Most people who come to me about a drinking habit, late-night eating or a phone they can’t put down believe they have a willpower problem. They usually don’t. If you step back far enough, you start to notice that these numbing behaviors show up at the same emotional moment every time. Right after a fight with your partner. Right when loneliness hits. Right when the workday ends and it’s time to slow down and be with the person you love.

The substance or the screen changes. The timing doesn’t.

In this article I’ll show you what’s actually happening inside you in those moments, using the IFS idea of the firefighter part. You’ll see why quitting one behavior so often starts another, and what helps the behavior settle down for good, so you can be present with your partner again.

What a Firefighter Part Is and Why It Reaches for Food, Wine or Your Phone

Food, alcohol and scrolling look like separate problems, and very often they are one part of you doing one job. In Internal Family Systems therapy, a firefighter is a protective part of the mind that rushes in when emotional pain starts to rise and puts that fire out fast, usually by pulling your attention away from the feeling altogether.

We all have firefighters. They’re doing what a real firefighter does. Something is burning, and they want it out right now.

Think of it like this. One firefighter reaches for the wine. Another opens the fridge. Another picks up the phone and scrolls for two hours without blinking, or fires up a video game. Another starts a brand-new argument just to send the emotional energy somewhere else. I’m not listing every tool a firefighter can use. There are many.

I want to be clear about one thing. I have nothing against video games. A lot of people love them. The trouble starts when someone, unconsciously and without meaning to, is using the game to get away from something.

I worked with a man whose wife was unhappy because he was never available in the evenings. He’d come home and disappear into his phone, into social media or a video game. From the outside, it looked like a phone problem. From the inside, a firefighter was on duty, and it was doing its best to keep him from feeling something he didn’t know how to feel.

That shift in view matters. When you see the behavior as a protector rather than a flaw, you stop fighting yourself and start getting curious. There are no bad parts here. There’s a part working very hard, for a reason.

Why the Timing of Numbing Behaviors Tells You More Than the Behavior

If you want to understand a numbing behavior, stop staring at the substance or the screen and look at the moment it arrives. It comes right after conflict. It comes when loneliness hits, or when it’s finally quiet enough to connect, or when shame starts creeping in.

Here’s what’s going on underneath. In IFS, the wounded part of you is called an exile. We don’t exile it on purpose. Pushing that hurt part out of awareness is a survival strategy, often learned early in life, and the exile is still carrying the pain from the past. When something in the present touches that old pain, it starts to rise.

That rising pain is the alarm. Your firefighter hears it and answers fast, because the system needs relief now.

So the behaviors look different on the outside. On the inside, every single one of them is answering the same alarm. The exile is surfacing, and something needs to make it stop.

For the man with the video games, the moment was walking through the front door after work. That was exactly when he’d need to be present with his wife, and exactly when the game came out. The timing was the clue that pointed us toward what he was protecting.

Your own pattern is worth tracking. If the urge shows up right after an argument, notice that. If it shows up in the quiet of an evening together, when nothing is wrong and it’s time to be close, notice that too. Each moment is a doorway to the part that’s hurting, and it tells you far more than how much you ate, drank or scrolled.

Why Quitting One Numbing Behavior Often Starts Another

Cutting off one behavior without understanding the part behind it usually shifts the problem rather than solving it. I’ve had clients who stopped drinking and then started vaping. It happens many times.

Maybe you quit drinking and suddenly you can’t stop eating. Maybe you put the phone down and the anxiety becomes unbearable. If that has happened to you, you’re not weak and you’re not going crazy. You’re human.

The firefighter lost its tool, but the exile’s pain is still there, and your system will find another way to manage it. That’s what protective parts do. They don’t give up their job because one tool got taken away. They go looking for a new one.

So I don’t think the real question was ever “How do I stop the behavior?” The real question is “What is the exile carrying that makes the firefighter’s job feel so necessary?”

This matters a great deal for couples. A partner who watches the drinking stop and the snacking or scrolling start can easily decide the other person isn’t trying. Usually they are trying. They’re trying with willpower, against a part of them that believes it’s keeping them safe. Willpower against a protector is a hard fight to win, and even when it wins, the protector tends to pick up something else.

When both partners understand this, the conversation changes. Instead of “Why can’t you just stop?” it becomes “What’s hurting underneath this?” That second question is the one that opens the door to healing, for the person with the behavior and for the relationship.

How Healing the Exile Lets the Firefighter Stand Down

The behavior settles when you turn toward the wounded part underneath all the firefighters and let your Self be with it. In IFS, Self with a capital S is the part of you that has the capacity to be loving, present, compassionate and curious, and to connect. Everyone has it. When your Self can be with the exile, something shifts that no amount of willpower could produce. I’ve seen it over and over again with clients, and in my own life.

Back to the man with the video games. His parents fought all the time, and eventually they divorced. At the beginning of his marriage, everything was great. That’s common. Once you make that deeper attachment, old fears from what you witnessed as a child can come back.

So he’d come home from work afraid that if he said the wrong thing or didn’t please his wife, she’d be disappointed, there’d be an argument, there’d be yelling, and like his parents’ marriage, it would fail. What does he do? He goes where he’s successful. He’s pretty good at video games. He wins some and loses some, but he definitely wins.

His exile was a younger part of him that watched his parents fight and couldn’t do anything about it. It carried helplessness, fear and anticipatory anxiety. We helped him be with that part so it could feel the presence of his Self and wasn’t all alone anymore. I also used EMDR to help him process memories that part was holding, and the IFS work deepened what the EMDR did.

It all quieted down. Now he comes home with the presence to be with his wife. Does he still play video games? Yes. He’s choosing to, and choosing is very different from a firefighter reflex. His wife felt important and supported again, and she came to understand that his distance had never been about her. It was his parts.

What To Do Next

You don’t need to wait for a crisis to start working with your firefighters. Here are four steps you can take this week.

  1. Name your firefighter. Write down the behavior you reach for when you want to escape. Food, a drink, the phone, a game or a new argument all count.
  2. Track the moment, not the behavior. Each time the urge shows up, jot down what happened right before it. After a few days, look for the pattern in the timing.
  3. Get curious instead of critical. When you notice the urge, ask the firefighter what it’s afraid would happen if it didn’t step in. It’s trying to help you, even if the way it helps is costing you.
  4. Get support for what’s underneath. Old pain, especially pain from childhood, is hard to be with alone. This is where IFS and EMDR therapy can help, because they work with the exile directly instead of fighting the protector.

If you only do one thing, start with step two tonight. The timing will tell you where to look.

Your numbing behaviors are a firefighter part doing its best to protect you from pain it believes is too much. When you stop fighting the firefighter and start caring for the wounded part it protects, the self-sabotage stops, and you can finally be present with the person you love. If you recognize yourself or your partner in this, call my office for a 20-minute phone consultation and we’ll talk about what’s underneath. This is how we make the world safe for love, from the inside out.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: What are numbing behaviors?
A: Numbing behaviors are things people do to get away from an uncomfortable feeling, such as overeating, drinking, endless scrolling, gaming or starting arguments. Food, alcohol and screens are not bad in themselves. They become numbing behaviors when they are used, often unconsciously, to escape emotional pain instead of feeling it.

Q: What is a firefighter part in Internal Family Systems?
A: In Internal Family Systems (IFS) therapy, a firefighter is a protective part that jumps in when emotional pain starts to surface and tries to stop it immediately, usually through distraction or escape. It protects a wounded part called an exile, which carries pain from the past. Firefighters mean well, but their quick fixes can damage health and relationships.

Q: Why do I replace one bad habit or addiction with another?
A: When you take away one behavior without healing the pain behind it, the protective part loses its tool but still has its job. The pain is still there, so the part looks for a new way to manage it, which is why someone who quits drinking may start vaping or overeating. Lasting change comes from healing the wounded part so the protector can stand down.

Q: How do I know if my phone or gaming is hurting my relationship?
A: Look at when you reach for it. If it shows up at the same emotional moments, such as after an argument or right when it’s time to be close with your partner, and it feels like a reflex rather than a choice, a firefighter part may be at work. Your partner feeling unimportant or alone in the evenings is another sign worth paying attention to.

Q: Can IFS and EMDR be used together?
A: Yes. EMDR helps process the painful memories a wounded part is holding, and IFS helps a person build a relationship with that younger part from a calm, compassionate place. Todd Creager uses both, and in his experience the IFS work strengthens what EMDR accomplishes.

Not sure what your firefighter is protecting? Todd works with individuals and couples over Zoom, and every new client starts with a 20-minute phone consultation with Todd himself. Call the office or reach out through toddcreager.com to set up your call.