Todd Creager

Orange County Marriage Therapy

Need a Little Advice?

Todd Creager

Why Cheating Ultimately Hurts the Cheater Most

by Leave a Comment

Key Takeaways

Why Cheating Ultimately Hurts the Cheater Most

When someone cheats, they hand control of their life to wounded, reactive parts of themselves — not to their best, most grounded self.

The lying, managing, and hiding that follows an affair pulls the cheater further from the calm, clear, connected person they’re capable of being.

Healing the internal wounds that drove the cheating is what actually returns someone to self-leadership — and that work matters whether the relationship survives or not.

Most conversations about infidelity center on the betrayed partner — the pain, the shock, the broken trust. And that pain is real. I’ve sat with hundreds of couples in the aftermath of infidelity, and I understand the full weight of it.

But there’s something that gets far less attention: how cheating cheats the person who did it.

That’s not about punishment or karma.

It’s about what actually happens inside someone when they choose to cheat — and what they lose in the process. After decades working with individuals and couples through infidelity recovery, I’ve come to see this clearly through the lens of Internal Family Systems, or IFS. And this framework changes everything about how we understand why cheating happens, and what it truly costs.

How Cheating Hurts the Cheater: The Self You Walk Away From

Every person has what IFS calls the “Self” — your best, most grounded version of who you are. It’s the part of you that’s calm, clear, curious, compassionate, and genuinely connected to other people.

When you’re living from that Self, your life feels real. Your relationships feel real. You make decisions from clarity rather than fear or desperation.

When you cheat, you step away from all of that.

What takes over instead are what IFS calls “protective parts” — specifically the firefighter, whose job is to distract you from pain, and the manager, whose job is to keep things from falling apart. The firefighter says: this person finds you attractive — escape into that. The manager says: now cover it up, keep the story straight, don’t get caught.

Neither of those parts is your Self. And the longer the cheating continues, the more those parts run the show.

I often use this image with the people I work with: you’ve handed the keys to your car over to a panicked passenger. They don’t know how to drive. They’re just trying not to crash. That’s not leadership. That’s survival mode — and it’s no way to live.

What Actually Drives Cheating (It’s Rarely What People Assume)

It’s easy — and wrong — to brand someone who cheated as simply a bad person. Most of the time, something else is going on beneath the surface, and getting honest about that is what makes real healing possible.

Take someone I worked with who had been functioning well in their marriage for years. Then they lost their job. Their sense of self-worth took a serious hit. And that’s when the affair started.

What they were really doing was running from that wound — the feeling of worthlessness — by finding someone who seemed drawn to them.

For a moment, it worked. They felt better about themselves.

That’s the firefighter doing exactly what it was designed to do: create an escape from pain.

The wound itself was much older than the marriage. It often goes all the way back to childhood — growing up in a home where no one was really there for your pain. That wound stayed buried until life cracked something open. And when it did, the protective part stepped in with the fastest solution it knew.

That’s not an excuse for cheating.

It doesn’t minimize the damage done to a partner or a family. But it is a far more accurate picture of why it happens — and that accuracy is what opens the door to genuine change.

What the Person Who Cheated Actually Loses

The affair ends — or gets discovered — and something becomes very clear: the person who cheated has been operating without two of the most important qualities a human being can have.

Calm. And clarity.

Both are properties of the Self. And both get buried the moment the firefighter and manager take over.

The lying alone is exhausting. Keeping the story straight, managing two lives, making sure nothing slips — that’s the manager working overtime. And underneath all of it, the original wound is still there, untouched. The cheating didn’t heal anything. It just created more to manage.

So what did cheating actually solve? Nothing lasting. The pain it was meant to escape is still waiting. The Self that was supposed to be in the driver’s seat is sidelined. And now there’s a layer of shame and damage on top of everything else.

I want to be direct here: even when the cheating feels like a relief, it isn’t building anything. It’s borrowing against the life you’re actually capable of living.

Getting Back in the Driver’s Seat

This is the part I want anyone who has betrayed their partner to hear — and to hold onto even when the weight of it feels like too much.

You can get back to Self-leadership.

That means getting curious about those protective parts instead of hating them or running from them.

The firefighter that led you to cheat was trying to help you, in the only way it knew how. The manager that had you lying was trying to keep your family from falling apart. They aren’t villains. They’re wounded strategies — and they can change when the wounds beneath them actually get addressed.

That’s the work. In therapy, we go toward those exiled, wounded parts. We help them heal. When those wounds are no longer raw and untouched, the protective parts don’t need to work so hard. The firefighter can stand down. The manager can breathe. And your actual Self — clear, calm, connected — can come back into the driver’s seat.

That process is worth doing whether your relationship heals or not.

I’ve worked with people whose betrayed partners ultimately chose to leave. And sometimes, when that happens, the person who cheated thinks: why bother with therapy now? The relationship is over.

Don’t think that.

You still have a life ahead of you. If those wounds stay unaddressed, the same patterns repeat — in the next relationship, in how you parent, in how you see yourself. The healing is for you, not just for the partnership.

Where to Start If You’re the One Who Cheated

A few concrete places to begin:

Get curious, not condemning. Ask yourself what you were feeling in the weeks or months before the affair started. What was the emotional pain you were running from?

Stop running the manager’s script. The constant self-protection keeps you locked outside of your own life. It’s exhausting — and it doesn’t hold long-term.

Find a therapist who works with IFS or trauma-informed approaches. The wounds that drive this behavior can genuinely heal, but they need to be approached directly, with real support.

Do this work even if the relationship has ended. Self-leadership isn’t contingent on your partner’s forgiveness. It’s yours to reclaim regardless of where things stand.

The first step is being willing to get honest — with yourself, about what was really going on.

The person who cheated isn’t just the villain in someone else’s story.

They’re someone who lost access to their own best self and didn’t know how to find their way back.

That’s what cheating really costs. And that’s what genuine recovery — real, internal recovery — gives back.

If you’re ready to start, I’ve put together an Infidelity First Aid Kit to help stop the immediate damage and begin the real work of healing — whether you’re the betrayed partner or the one who did the betraying.

The Infidelity First Aid Kit

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: Does how cheating hurts the cheater depend on whether they got caught?

A: Getting caught doesn’t determine the damage. Whether the affair was discovered or ended quietly, the person who cheated has already been operating from a place of deception — and that deception costs them access to their own calm, clarity, and genuine connection.

The internal cost is there either way.

What getting caught does is create an opportunity — painful as it is — for the real healing work to begin.

Q: Can someone who cheated actually change long-term?

A: Yes — but only if they address what drove the behavior in the first place. Promises and good intentions without internal work rarely hold.

When the underlying wounded parts of a person’s psyche get the attention they need, real, lasting change becomes possible. Surface-level remorse is not the same thing as healing.

Q: Should the betrayed partner care about why the cheating happened?

A: That’s completely up to them, and there’s no wrong answer. The betrayed partner has every right to end the relationship — full stop.

For couples who want to rebuild, understanding what actually drove the affair (not as an excuse, but as a genuine explanation) often becomes part of what allows trust to come back over time.

Q: What is IFS and how does it apply to understanding infidelity?

A: Internal Family Systems (IFS) is a therapy approach that maps the different “parts” of a person’s inner world — including protective parts like the manager and firefighter, and the wounded parts (called exiles) those protectors are guarding. In the context of infidelity, IFS helps explain how someone can act so far outside their own values: a protective part took over.

Healing in IFS means helping those wounded parts so the person’s core Self can lead again.

Q: What if my partner refuses to do any work after cheating?

A: That’s a genuinely painful position to be in. If your partner won’t do the internal work, you still have the right — and the responsibility to yourself — to make decisions based on what you observe, not just what you’re promised. And regardless of what your partner does, your own healing matters.

For the betrayed partner, individual therapy in the early stages is often just as valuable, sometimes more so, than couples work.

Ready to stop the bleeding and begin the real healing? 

Get the Infidelity First Aid Kit — a practical starting point for the hardest early stages of infidelity recovery, whether you were betrayed or did the betraying: https://www.toddcreagertraining.com/infidelity-first-aid 

Why Betrayal Cuts Deeper Than the Affair Itself — And How to Heal

by Leave a Comment

Key Takeaways

Why Betrayal Cuts Deeper Than the Affair Itself — And How to Heal

→ An affair doesn’t just hurt because of what happened — it activates wounded parts from your past, which is why it can feel like a life-or-death experience.

→ Internal Family Systems (IFS) helps you identify the protective and wounded parts driving your response, while EMDR helps you process the stuck memories behind them.

→ The goal isn’t blind trust — it’s becoming self-led, so you make decisions from your highest self, not from fear, anger, or old wounds.

→ True healing after infidelity means both partners doing their own work so the relationship is run by two whole people, not two sets of protective parts.

If you’ve been betrayed by your partner, you already know — it doesn’t just hurt. It feels like the ground disappeared beneath you. Like something fundamental about your safety in the world just shattered.

And of course it does. Your partner cheated. You discovered it. That’s devastating, full stop.

But here’s what most people don’t realize: the reason it feels like life or death isn’t only because of what happened right now. It’s because the betrayal woke up wounded parts of you that have been there long before this relationship. And understanding that is the first step toward real healing.

Let me walk you through what’s actually happening inside you — and what we can do about it.

Why Infidelity Trauma Activates Your Deepest Wounds

When you discover an affair, something happens that goes beyond the present moment. Yes, the pain is real. Yes, it happened because of what your partner did. Nobody is minimizing that.

But betrayal has a way of reaching back in time. It activates what we call in Internal Family Systems the “exiles” — those wounded parts of you that formed when you were younger. Maybe you were told you weren’t good enough. Maybe you experienced abandonment. Maybe at a really vulnerable moment, a parent said something that stuck with you, and it’s been following you ever since.

These wounds create negative beliefs. Things like “I’m not safe” or “I’m not good enough.” And even when life is going fine, those beliefs are sitting there quietly. They don’t go away on their own.

So when betrayal happens, it’s like a match hitting gasoline. The affair says “you were betrayed,” and those old wounds hear “see, you were never safe” or “you were never enough.” That’s why it feels like life or death. It’s not just one pain — it’s every pain, all at once.

How IFS and EMDR Work Together to Heal Betrayal

Here’s where it gets hopeful. Because once you understand what’s happening inside you, there are powerful tools to actually heal it.

Internal Family Systems gives us a map. It helps you see that you’re made up of a healthy self — that part of you that’s compassionate, courageous, clear, calm, creative, connected. That’s who you really are at your core.

But you also have other parts. There are the exiles — those wounded parts carrying old pain. There are the managers — the parts that keep you functional and keep the wounds hidden. And there are the firefighters — the parts that flare up and try to distract you when the pain gets too intense.

IFS helps you identify all of these parts. It helps you see which ones have been activated by the betrayal and understand what they’re trying to protect you from.

Then EMDR steps in. Eye Movement Desensitization and Reprocessing uses bilateral stimulation — activating both sides of the brain — to help you process trauma that got stuck in time. Those memories that your wounded parts are carrying? EMDR helps your brain move through them so they stop running the show.

In a nutshell: IFS identifies the parts. EMDR processes the memories those parts are holding. Together, they’re incredibly powerful.

The Real Goal: Becoming Self-Led After Betrayal

Here’s what I want you to understand — and this is the piece that changes everything.

The goal of this work isn’t to just start trusting your partner again. If they haven’t earned that trust, you shouldn’t trust them. That would be reckless, not healing.

What we’re doing is healing YOU.

We’re helping you get to a place where your decisions come from your highest self, not from your protective parts. Not from the part that’s terrified of being abandoned again. Not from the part that wants to punish. Not from the part that wants to make it work no matter what just to avoid feeling like a fool.

When those protective parts and those old wounds get processed, something remarkable happens.

You become intuitive again. You can actually tune in and ask yourself: “How safe am I really, right now, in this situation?” And you can trust the answer — because it’s coming from clarity, not from fear.

That’s what we call a self-led life. And when both partners do this work — when the person who betrayed also looks at their own parts and does their own healing — you get a self-led relationship. Two people whose highest selves are running the show.

It’s not perfect. Parts still flare up. But with awareness, you catch it. You notice it. You have a relationship with those parts instead of being controlled by them.

What To Do Next If You’re Healing From Betrayal

If any of this resonated with you, here’s where to start:

→ Recognize the layers. Understand that your pain isn’t just about the affair — it’s connected to older wounds that need attention too.

→ Learn about your parts. Start noticing the protective parts that show up — the anger, the fear, the need to control. They’re trying to help you, but they don’t have to run the show.

→ Seek integrated support. Look for a therapist who works with both IFS and EMDR — the combination is where the deep healing happens.

→ Don’t rush trust. Healing yourself comes first. Trust is something your partner earns while you do your own work.

The first step you can take today is to check out Todd’s Infidelity First Aid Kit Program. It’s designed to give you a powerful starting point for healing — whether you just discovered the betrayal or you’ve been carrying it for a while.

As devastating as betrayal is, healing is very possible. I’ve seen it happen. I’ve helped people use these tools to move through infidelity and come out the other side with more clarity, more connection with themselves, and stronger relationships. The wound doesn’t have to define you. Your highest self is still in there — and it’s ready to lead.

Check out the Infidelity First Aid Kit Program and take that first step.

The Infidelity First Aid Kit

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: Why does an affair feel like a life-or-death experience?

A: Beyond the pain of the betrayal itself, an affair activates wounded parts from your past — old experiences of abandonment, not feeling safe, or not being good enough. When those old wounds get triggered alongside the present pain, it creates an overwhelming response that feels like survival is at stake.

Q: What is Internal Family Systems (IFS) therapy?

A: IFS is a therapeutic approach that helps you understand the different “parts” of yourself — your healthy core self, your wounded parts (exiles), and your protective parts (managers and firefighters).

It gives you a framework for understanding why you react the way you do and how to heal from the inside out.

Q: How does EMDR help with betrayal trauma?

A: EMDR uses bilateral stimulation to help your brain process traumatic memories that are stuck in time.

When combined with IFS, it targets the specific wounds and memories that your parts are carrying, allowing you to move through them instead of being controlled by them.

Q: Should I trust my partner again after an affair?

A: The goal isn’t to blindly trust again. It’s to heal your own wounds so that you can make clear, intuitive decisions about your relationship.

Trust is something your partner earns through their own work and changed behavior — not something you force before you’re ready.

Q: Can a marriage survive infidelity?

A: Yes, but it requires both partners doing deep personal work. When both people become “self-led” — operating from their highest selves rather than protective parts — a new kind of relationship becomes possible.

One built on genuine connection, vulnerability, and honest communication.

Why the Same Fight Happens 100 Times and How IFS Can Stop It

by Leave a Comment

Why the Same Fight Happens a Hundred Times (And What’s Actually Going On Underneath)

Here’s something I’ve noticed after working with couples for over three decades: most people walk into my office convinced they have a communication problem. They don’t. What they have is a protection problem.

Two people who care about each other, both running old defensive programs that were never designed for the relationship they’re trying to build right now.

That couple who keeps having the same argument about the dishes or the in-laws or how money gets spent? They’re not really fighting about any of those things. Their protectors are fighting. And until we understand that, the loop just keeps spinning.

I want to walk you through what I mean by that, because once you see it, you can’t unsee it. And that’s where real change starts.

The Short Version

Repetitive couple arguments aren’t about the topic on the surface. They’re driven by protective parts of each partner—parts that developed in childhood to shield us from old wounds. Internal Family Systems (IFS) therapy gives couples a framework to recognize those parts, pause the automatic reaction, and communicate from their healthy adult self instead. The result is that the bickering loop breaks—not because you learn a script, but because you’re no longer letting a frightened eight-year-old run your marriage.

What most people miss:

→ The partner who shuts down isn’t being cold. They’re running a childhood survival program.

→ The partner who gets loud isn’t being aggressive. A part of them is fighting against invisibility.

→ You don’t fix this by trying harder at communication. You fix it by learning to speak about your parts rather than speaking as your parts.

What’s Really Going On When Couples Keep Having the Same Fight

Every couple I’ve ever worked with—and I’m talking about thousands of couples at this point—comes in describing some version of the same thing. She says one thing, he does another thing, and within ninety seconds they’re right back in the ditch. Different words, same fight. Over and over.

The reason it keeps happening is that it’s not actually them fighting. It’s their protectors. In Internal Family Systems therapy—IFS, which I use in my practice alongside EMDR and other trauma treatments—we recognize that every person carries different parts.

Some of those parts are wounded. They got hurt in childhood, and they carry beliefs like I’m not good enough or I’m not safe or I don’t matter. Nobody gets through life unbruised.

And then we develop other parts—protective parts—whose whole job is to make sure we never have to feel those old wounds again. Those protective parts made a lot of sense when we were kids. The problem is they’re still running the show decades later, in a relationship they weren’t designed for.

Managers and Firefighters: The Two Types of Protectors

IFS identifies two kinds of protective parts, and I find this distinction incredibly helpful when I’m sitting with a couple who can’t figure out why they keep ending up in the same place.

The Manager

The manager is the part that works preventively. It tries to keep the old wounds from ever getting activated in the first place. A manager might look like the person who gets critical and controlling—picking at their partner, pointing out what’s wrong, keeping a mental scoreboard. Or it might look like the person who goes quiet and compliant, never rocking the boat, never asking for what they need. Both are management strategies. Both are trying to prevent pain.

The Firefighter

The firefighter shows up when the wound is already activated—when the pain is coming up fast and overwhelming. Firefighters don’t prevent; they distract. They pull you toward anything that will take the edge off: a video game, a bottle of wine, scrolling your phone for three hours, picking a new fight about something else entirely. The firefighter doesn’t care about long-term consequences. It just needs the pain to stop right now.

When you see a couple locked in a cycle—one partner escalating, the other withdrawing—what you’re almost always seeing is a manager in one person triggering a firefighter in the other. And then it feeds back on itself.

A Real Pattern I See in My Office All the Time

Let me give you an example. I’m thinking of a couple I worked with—and I’ve worked with dozens of variations of this same dynamic, so I’m combining details here to protect privacy.

She grew up feeling invisible. Her parents were preoccupied, distracted, emotionally unavailable. She learned that she had to fight to be seen. So when she feels her partner pulling away, a part of her rises up—a manager—that gets loud and critical. “You never show that you care about me. Never.” That’s not her whole self talking. That’s the part of her that refuses to be invisible again.

He grew up with a parent who was emotionally volatile—raging, unpredictable, sometimes frightening. As a child, his survival strategy was to disappear. Get small, get quiet, find something to focus on until the storm passed. So when his wife’s voice starts rising, a part of him—his firefighter—does exactly what it was trained to do: he shuts down. Goes to the computer. Closes the door. Puts on a game.

And then what happens to her? She feels even more invisible. So her protector cranks up louder. Which makes his protector retreat further. Back and forth, back and forth. The bickering loop.

Neither of them is a bad person. Neither of them is trying to hurt the other. They’re each running a program that made total sense when they were seven years old. It just doesn’t work now.

Why “Just Communicate Better” Doesn’t Work

I know this might be a little different from what you’ve heard elsewhere. A lot of relationship advice comes down to learning communication formulas—use “I statements,” mirror your partner back, take turns. And those tools have their place. I teach some of them myself.

But here’s the thing: when a protective part has hijacked you, you can’t use those tools. You can know the formula perfectly and still not be able to access it in the moment, because the part of you that’s running the show doesn’t care about formulas. It cares about survival.

That’s why I’ve found IFS to be so powerful with couples. It doesn’t just give you new words to say. It helps you understand why you can’t say them when it matters most—and what to do about that.

Speaking “From” a Part vs. Speaking “As” a Part

This is the key shift, and I’ve seen it change relationships in ways that still move me after all these years of doing this work.

Speaking as a part sounds like: “You always demonstrate how you don’t care about me.”

Speaking from a part sounds like: “There’s a part of me that feels really lonely when I’m in pain and you pull away.”

Can you feel the difference? The first one comes at your partner like an accusation. The second one lets your partner see what’s actually happening inside you. It’s vulnerable, it’s honest, and it makes it much easier for the other person to respond with care instead of defense.

When someone says “There’s a part of me that…” they’re speaking from their healthy, mature self. They’re acknowledging the part without being consumed by it. They’re honoring what that part feels while still being present in the adult relationship.

I’ll be personal for a second here. In my own life, I had a strong habit of getting defensive. And what I had to learn was that the defensive part wasn’t a failure in me. It was a part trying to protect me from feeling inadequate. Once I could recognize that—oh, there’s that part again, it believes I’m only okay if my partner is happy with me—I could start to question it. Is that actually true? Do I need her approval to be a worthwhile person? The answer, clearly, is no. But until I saw the part for what it was, it ran me.

The Pause-and-Pivot Practice

So how do you actually do this in real life, when emotions are high and your protector is screaming at you to do the same thing you’ve always done?

I teach couples to pause and pivot. It’s simple to describe, harder to practice, and incredibly rewarding when it starts to click.

Step 1: Notice the Part

You catch yourself in the reactive moment. Your jaw is tightening, your chest is constricting, you’re about to say the thing you always say. Right there, you notice: a part of me is activated right now. That noticing—that tiny gap of awareness—is everything.

Step 2: Tune In

Instead of acting on the impulse, you turn toward it with curiosity. What is this part trying to protect me from? What does it believe will happen if it doesn’t step in? You don’t have to have a long internal dialogue. Even a half-second of wondering is enough to create space.

Step 3: Speak About It

Now you communicate from your adult self, about the part: “I want to hear you, but I notice there’s a part of me that’s freaking out right now. It wants to defend itself and get mean, and I know that’s not going to help us.”

That kind of honesty does something remarkable. It disarms the cycle. When you name what’s happening inside you without acting it out, your partner’s protective part can stand down too. The bickering loop loses its fuel.

Recognizing Which Pattern Is Running Your Relationship

Here’s a framework I use with couples to help them identify what’s happening under the surface. See which pattern sounds familiar:

Pursue – Withdraw What it looks like: One partner escalates, the other shuts down or leaves the room. The wound underneath: Pursuer fears being invisible or abandoned. Withdrawer fears being overwhelmed or out of control. The pivot: “A part of me needs to know you’re still here.” / “A part of me shuts down when things feel intense.”

Criticize – Defend What it looks like: One partner lists grievances, the other explains why they’re wrong. The wound underneath: Critic fears not mattering. Defender fears being inadequate. The pivot: “There’s a part of me that feels dismissed.” / “There’s a part of me that hears I’m failing you.”

Freeze – Freeze What it looks like: Both partners go silent, avoid conflict entirely, and drift apart over time. The wound underneath: Both carry fear that any expression of need will cause rejection or chaos. The pivot: “I notice a part of me goes quiet when things get hard. I don’t want that for us.”

Escape – Over-Adapt What it looks like: One partner numbs through substances or distraction; the other over-functions and loses themselves. The wound underneath: Escaper fears facing internal pain. Over-adapter fears that setting boundaries will cause abandonment. The pivot: “A part of me is running from what I feel.” / “A part of me is afraid to ask for what I need.”

When Bigger Wounds Are Part of the Picture

I want to be honest about something. The pause-and-pivot approach works beautifully for everyday protective patterns—the defensiveness, the withdrawal, the criticism that shows up in daily life. But some couples are dealing with layers that go deeper.

When infidelity is involved, for instance, the wounds are fresh and they’re intense. The betrayed partner’s protectors are in overdrive for good reason—the threat wasn’t imagined, it was real. And the person who betrayed may have their own firefighters running the show: the drinking that was an escape from anxiety, the affair that was a distraction from pain they didn’t know how to face.

I work with a lot of couples in this situation, and what I’ve found is that IFS gives them a language for what happened that goes beyond blame. Instead of “You destroyed our marriage,” it becomes possible to say, “A part of you was running from something, and it caused tremendous damage.” That’s not letting anyone off the hook. It’s making it possible to actually deal with what happened, rather than staying stuck in the loop of accusation and defense.

If past trauma—whether childhood experiences, previous betrayals, or other deep wounds—is part of your story, the protective parts can be especially entrenched. In those cases, working with a therapist who understands IFS and trauma treatment methods like EMDR can make a significant difference. The parts didn’t develop overnight, and they usually need more than a conversation to start loosening their grip.

What Recovery Actually Looks Like

I want to be clear about something, because I think a lot of content out there gives people the wrong impression. This isn’t a weekend fix. Recognizing your parts is the beginning, not the end.

What I typically see with couples who commit to this work is that the first few weeks feel awkward. You’re catching yourself mid-reaction, and it’s clunky. You might notice the part but still act on it anyway. That’s normal. That’s progress, actually, because you couldn’t see it before at all.

Over a few months, something shifts. The pause gets a little longer. The pivot gets a little more natural. And your partner starts to feel safer—not because the problems are gone, but because you’re no longer coming at them with a seven-year-old’s survival strategy.

I’ve watched couples who could barely sit in the same room get to a place where they can hold each other’s pain. That doesn’t happen because they read a book or memorized a technique. It happens because they learned to see themselves—and each other—differently.

Frequently Asked Questions About IFS and Couples Work

What is Internal Family Systems (IFS) therapy?

IFS is a therapeutic model developed by Dr. Richard Schwartz that recognizes we all have multiple parts within us—protective parts, wounded parts, and a core Self. In couples work, it helps partners understand that their reactive patterns are driven by protective parts trying to shield them from old pain, not by character flaws.

Can IFS help with infidelity recovery?

Absolutely. I use IFS alongside EMDR and other approaches in my work with couples recovering from betrayal. IFS gives both the betrayed partner and the person who betrayed a framework for understanding what drove the behavior and what needs to heal—without bypassing the pain or rushing to forgiveness.

Do both partners need to learn IFS for it to work?

It’s most effective when both partners engage with the framework, but even one person shifting out of their protective pattern changes the entire dynamic. When one partner stops speaking “as” their reactive part, the other partner’s protector often has less to react to.

How is IFS different from regular couples counseling?

Traditional couples counseling often focuses on communication skills and conflict resolution strategies. IFS goes underneath those strategies to address why you can’t use them when it matters most. It’s not that communication tools are bad—it’s that they don’t work when a protective part has taken the wheel.

What are “managers” and “firefighters” in IFS?

Managers are protective parts that work preventively—they try to keep you from ever feeling the old wound. They might show up as people-pleasing, controlling behavior, or chronic criticism. Firefighters are reactive—they activate when the wound is already coming up and try to distract or numb you away from it through things like substance use, screen time, emotional affairs, or explosive anger.

How long does IFS couples therapy typically take?

Every situation is different, which is something I’m always honest about. Some couples feel a meaningful shift within a few sessions once they start to see the parts dynamic at play. Deeper work—especially when trauma, addiction, or infidelity is involved—often benefits from several months of consistent effort. The goal isn’t perfection; it’s developing the awareness to catch the pattern before it takes over.

Moving Forward

If you recognized your relationship in any of this, I want you to know something: that recognition is a sign of strength, not failure. The fact that you’re still trying to understand what’s going wrong means a part of you hasn’t given up. And that part matters.

The couples who do well in my practice aren’t the ones who never fight. They’re the ones who learn to catch themselves in the act—to notice when a protective part has taken over, to pause, and to choose a different response. It’s not about being perfect. It’s about being willing to look at what’s really happening.

That’s how we break the bickering loop. Not with a better argument, but with a better understanding of who’s actually doing the arguing.

About Todd Creager

Todd Creager, LCSW, LMFT, is a relationship therapist and infidelity recovery specialist with over 30 years of clinical experience working with couples. He integrates Internal Family Systems (IFS), EMDR, and other evidence-based approaches to help partners move from reactive bickering to genuine connection. Todd’s work is grounded in the belief that recovery—from betrayal, from old patterns, from the wounds we carry—is not only possible but can lead to deeper, more authentic relationships than partners ever had before.

What if your next argument could bring you closer instead of driving you apart?


Learn how in Todd Creager’s Loving & Connecting Masterclass.
Lifetime access. Real results.

Say Yes to a Better Relationship

Why Willpower Fails in Sex and Intimacy

by Leave a Comment

What’s really going on when your body won’t cooperate — and why pushing harder only makes it worse

I’ve worked with thousands of individuals and couples over the years, and there’s one thing I hear more often than almost anything else: “I’ve tried so hard to fix this.”

They’re talking about their sex life. Maybe it’s low desire. Maybe it’s performance anxiety. Maybe it’s a pattern of turning to porn or even infidelity that they can’t seem to stop. And they’ve been using willpower — gritting their teeth, white-knuckling it, forcing themselves to either show up or stop — and it’s not working.

Here’s what I want you to know right away: willpower doesn’t fail because you’re weak. Willpower fails because it’s the wrong tool for the job. And understanding why changes everything.

When You Want to Be Intimate, But Your Body Says No

Let me paint a picture that might feel familiar. You care about your partner. You want to connect with them physically. But something happens — or doesn’t happen. You can’t maintain an erection. You can’t reach orgasm. Ejaculation happens too quickly, or not at all. Your desire just isn’t there.

So what do you do? You try harder. You tell yourself, “This time it’ll be different.” You psych yourself up. And when it doesn’t work, the anxiety gets worse. The shame gets heavier. And the cycle tightens.

I want to offer a completely different way of looking at this. In my practice, I use an approach called Internal Family Systems, or IFS. And one of the most important things IFS teaches us is this:

You’re not broken. There’s a part of you that’s trying to protect you.

That might sound surprising. How could losing your erection be protective? How could shutting down sexually be your body looking out for you? But stay with me here.

We’re Not Just One Thing — We’re Made Up of Parts

Internal Family Systems is built on the idea that all of us are made up of different parts. Not in a pathological way — this is normal human psychology. We all have a core Self (capital S) that’s wise, compassionate, courageous, curious, and calm. That Self is always there inside you.

But we also have protective parts. These parts developed for good reasons, usually early in life, and their whole purpose is to keep us from feeling pain we once couldn’t handle.

In IFS, there are two main types of protective parts:

Managers try to prevent pain before it happens. They plan, they control, they shut things down preemptively. In the bedroom, a manager is the part that lowers your desire, takes away your erection, or blocks orgasm. It’s saying, “If we don’t go there, we can’t get hurt.”

Firefighters show up after the pain has already started to surface. They react fast and urgently, doing whatever it takes to numb or extinguish that pain. In the sexual arena, a firefighter might drive someone toward compulsive porn use, affairs, or hypersexual behavior — anything to put out the emotional fire.

And underneath both of these? Wounded parts — sometimes called exiles. These are the younger, more vulnerable parts of you that carry shame, fear, inadequacy, or old emotional injuries. The managers and firefighters exist to keep these wounded parts from being felt.

Why Willpower Can’t Reach What’s Really Happening

Now think about what willpower actually does. It says to these parts: “Stop it. Perform. Don’t look at that. Be normal.”

But these parts aren’t acting up because they’re misbehaving. They’re acting up because they’re scared. They’re protecting something. Willpower doesn’t address what they’re protecting — it just tries to override them. And that’s a battle you’re going to lose, because those parts are deeply wired into your nervous system.

I see this every week in my office. A man can’t maintain an erection with his wife, so he tells himself, “Just relax, just focus.” But the part that’s shutting him down isn’t listening to logic. It’s guarding him from the intense vulnerability of being truly seen and possibly coming up short. No amount of self-talk can override that kind of protection.

On the other side, I work with people who are desperately trying to stop using porn or to stop having affairs. They feel tremendous guilt. They make promises to themselves. And for a while, willpower might hold. But then something happens — a failure at work, a fight with their partner, a wave of old shame — and the firefighter part rushes in. The compulsive behavior returns, and the person feels even worse than before.

I have a client right now whose pattern of infidelity started at the exact time he began experiencing significant setbacks at work. That’s not a coincidence. The affair was a firefighter response — someone gave him attention and validation, and that extinguished, at least temporarily, the unbearable feeling of failure. Willpower couldn’t touch that because it wasn’t addressing the wound underneath.

The Bedroom Is One of the Most Vulnerable Places We Go

This is something I don’t think gets talked about enough. We carry all these ideas about how things are supposed to go in bed. And when our body doesn’t cooperate with those expectations, there’s enormous opportunity for shame to surface.

Shame is one of the most painful human emotions. And the bedroom, because it asks so much of us emotionally — to be open, present, physically naked and responsive — is where our old shame wounds are most likely to get activated.

So of course your protective parts show up there. They’re doing their job. The question isn’t, “How do I force them to stop?” The question is, “What are they trying to protect me from?”

A Quick Note on Physical Causes

I always want to be honest about this: sometimes there’s a hormonal issue. Sometimes a medication side effect is involved. Those are real, and they deserve attention. If you haven’t had a thorough medical evaluation, that’s a good starting point.

But in my experience, once physical factors have been ruled out or addressed, the issue is almost always relational and emotional at its core. And that’s actually good news, because it means there’s a clear path forward.

What Actually Works: Self-Led Sexuality

If willpower doesn’t work, what does?

In my work, I help people move toward what I call self-led sexuality. This means that instead of your managers or firefighters running the show in the bedroom, your true Self — that wise, calm, compassionate core of who you are — is in the lead.

And the first step toward self-led sexuality is probably not what you’d expect. It’s not about performing better or resisting harder. It’s about getting curious.

Curious about the part of you that’s causing the problem.

I know that sounds counterintuitive. When something is making your life miserable — when you can’t be present sexually with your partner, or when you keep acting out in ways that wreck your relationship — the last thing you want to do is welcome that part. You want to get rid of it. You want to fight it.

But here’s what decades of clinical work have taught me: fighting these parts doesn’t free you. Understanding them does.

How This Looks in Practice

When I work with someone using IFS, often alongside EMDR (Eye Movement Desensitization and Reprocessing), we begin by helping them notice and name the parts that are showing up.

We start to separate the person from the part. Because when your body won’t perform, it can feel like all of you is broken. But when you can say, “There’s a part of me that’s shutting down right now, and it’s scared,” something shifts. You’re no longer the problem. You’re someone who has a part that’s trying to protect you. And that creates room to breathe.

From that place of a little more spaciousness, we can get curious about the part. What is it afraid of? What would happen if it stepped back? When did it first start protecting you this way? Often, these parts are younger parts — they carry memories of times when you felt ashamed or inadequate or overwhelmed. And they’ve been working overtime ever since.

The goal is to help these parts unburden what they’ve been carrying. When that happens — when a wounded part no longer holds all that old shame or fear — the protective parts don’t need to work so hard. They can relax. And your true Self can lead in the bedroom and in the relationship.

A Word About Shame and Judgment

If you’re someone who’s been using porn compulsively, or if you’ve had an affair, I want to be clear about something. I’m not saying those behaviors are okay. Infidelity causes real, deep pain to the person who’s been betrayed. That’s undeniable.

But judging yourself into the ground hasn’t fixed it, has it? If shame and self-criticism were going to solve this, they would have done it by now.

What I’m offering is a different lens. When we can look at the firefighter part — the part that drove you toward that behavior — with some curiosity instead of pure contempt, we can finally get to what’s underneath. And that’s where the real healing happens. Not through willpower. Through understanding.

What You Can Start Doing Today

You don’t have to wait until you’re in a therapist’s office to begin this work, though professional support makes a real difference with the harder layers. Here are some honest starting points:

Notice without reacting. The next time you feel yourself shutting down sexually or feel pulled toward a compulsive behavior, pause. Instead of fighting it, just notice. “There’s a part of me doing this right now.” That simple shift — from “I’m broken” to “a part of me is activated” — is more powerful than you might think.

Get curious, not critical. Ask that part, gently: “What are you trying to protect me from?” You might not get an answer right away. That’s fine. The curiosity itself starts to change the relationship between you and that part.

Stop making it a willpower contest. This is maybe the most important thing. If you keep framing this as something you need to force your way through, you’ll keep losing. Not because you’re weak — because force doesn’t heal fear.

Consider working with a therapist trained in IFS or EMDR. These approaches get to the root-level wounds relatively quickly compared to traditional talk therapy alone. I combine both in my practice because I’ve seen how effective they are together — the healing happens from the inside out.

Why This Matters for Your Relationship

Sexual intimacy isn’t just physical. It’s one of the ways we feel most connected to our partner — and most exposed. When things aren’t working in the bedroom, it affects the entire relationship. Resentment builds. Distance grows. Both people start to feel like something fundamental is wrong.

But when you understand that what’s happening isn’t a failure — it’s a protection — you can approach each other with more compassion. Couples I’ve worked with who learn this framework together often tell me that it’s the first time they’ve been able to talk about their sexual struggles without blame or defensiveness.

That’s Self-led relating. And it’s where real intimacy lives.

You’re Not Broken. You’re Protected.

If you take one thing from this article, let it be this: what’s happening in your body — whether it’s shutting down or acting out — isn’t evidence that something is wrong with you. It’s evidence that something inside you is trying to keep you safe from pain you once couldn’t handle.

The path forward isn’t about pushing harder. It’s about turning inward with curiosity, getting to know those parts, and helping them let go of what they’ve been carrying. When that happens, more of your true Self can show up — in the bedroom, in your relationship, and in your life.

This is the kind of work I do every day with individuals and couples. And I’ve seen it change people’s lives. If you’re ready to stop fighting yourself and start understanding yourself, I’d love to help.

Rediscover the Spark: Fall Back in Love with Your Partner!

Have you ever felt like the flame in your relationship is flickering? You’re not alone. It’s common for even the most passionate romances to hit a lull.

But what if you could reignite that spark and fall deeply in love all over again?

Don’t let your love story lose its luster. Click now to access “Rekindling Romance: The Art of Falling Back in Love” and start your journey to a more fulfilling, passionate relationship today! 🌟💕

The Civil War Inside You After Betrayal

by Leave a Comment

When someone come to see me after a betrayal, it doesn’t take long before they ask me: Am I going crazy?

Not because it’s a common question. Because it’s the only question that makes sense when you’re feeling two completely opposite things at the same time. I want to leave this man — and I am so deeply in love with him. I love this woman, but everything in me wants to run away from her.

That isn’t weakness. That isn’t instability. What you’re experiencing is what I call the Civil War of Betrayal. And it happens inside both partners — the one who was betrayed, and the one who did the betraying.

The short version:

→ After infidelity, both partners experience a painful internal war between opposing parts of themselves — and that’s completely normal.

→ What most people miss: the part of you that wants to leave and the part that wants to stay are both trying to protect you.

→ Healing doesn’t mean getting rid of these parts. It means getting curious about them — and letting your deeper Self lead.

The War Inside the Betrayed Partner

When someone discovers their partner has been unfaithful, they don’t just feel one thing. They feel everything.

Sometimes within the same hour.

They want their partner to hold them. They want to throw their partner out. They want answers. They want to stop asking questions. They want the marriage to be saved.

They’re already imagining the divorce.

That internal tug-of-war isn’t a sign something is broken inside you. It’s an understandable response to a devastating breach of trust.

To make sense of it, I work with a framework called Internal Family Systems — IFS — developed by Dr. Richard Schwartz.

It’s one of the most compassionate and practical tools I’ve found in over 30 years of working with couples in crisis.

The basic idea is this: we all have multiple parts inside of us. Not multiple personalities in a clinical sense — just the natural reality that we’re complex people with competing needs, fears, and desires.

IFS gives us a language for those parts, and a path toward helping them work together rather than against each other.

The Exile: The Wound You’re Protecting

At the center of the pain is what IFS calls the exile — the wounded, vulnerable part. For the betrayed partner, this part carries feelings of abandonment. Deep, gut-level abandonment.

The person you trusted the most, the one you built a life with, chose someone else.

That’s not just a relationship problem. For many people, it reaches back and touches earlier wounds of being left, overlooked, or not valued enough.

If you’ve experienced abandonment before — and so many of us have, in one form or another — this new wound can reawaken all of that. The exile part is so tender, so raw, that other parts of you immediately mobilize to make sure it doesn’t have to feel the full weight of the pain.

The Manager: The Part That Wants to Investigate Everything

The manager is a protective part. Its job is to keep the exile’s pain at a manageable distance.

After infidelity, the manager often shows up as an obsessive need for information.

You’re checking phones at 2 a.m. You’re going back through credit card statements. You’re asking the same questions over and over, looking for details you’re not even sure you want.

That behavior can look self-destructive from the outside. But the manager is doing what managers do — trying to create a sense of control in a situation that feels completely out of control.

It’s also quietly trying to protect that abandoned exile from being surprised again.

The manager also carries the part that wants the family to stay intact. The part that remembers the twenty years of good. The part that doesn’t want the kids to grow up in two households.

It plays the long game. It wants things to go back to the way they were before you found out.

The Firefighter: The Part That Just Wants the Pain to Stop

When the exile’s pain breaks through anyway — when the manager can’t hold it back anymore — the firefighter shows up.

The firefighter’s only goal is to extinguish the pain immediately. It doesn’t care about long-term consequences. It wants relief right now.

I’ve seen betrayed partners who acted out in revenge affairs. Others who screamed and threw things. Some who went completely numb and withdrawn. Some who made impulsive decisions about ending the relationship without really processing what they wanted.

These aren’t signs of instability — they’re firefighters doing what firefighters do. The house is on fire. They’re just grabbing whatever hose is nearby.

The Civil War Inside the Person Who Betrayed

Here’s the part that surprises people: the person who cheated is often fighting their own internal war too. I want to be clear — cheating is a choice, and the person who cheated is 100% responsible for that choice. I never use any of this to offer an excuse or a way out. But there’s a difference between responsibility and the full picture.

The part of a person that cheated is often a firefighter — a part that was trying to escape something painful. Loneliness. Feeling unseen. A long-buried fear of inadequacy.

That doesn’t justify the choice. It helps explain the person behind it.

Almost every person who cheated that I’ve worked with carries a deep sense of having betrayed themselves, not just their partner. That shame is real and it’s painful.

And it creates its own internal war — the part that wants to come toward the partner and repair, and the part that wants to disappear from the shame entirely.

What This Looks Like in Real Life: Lucy and John

Let me tell you about a couple I worked with — I’ll call them Lucy and John. Lucy had cheated on John. When they came to me, John was in shock. Furious.

Heartbroken. He loved his wife deeply, and in the same session where he talked about that love, he was also saying he was ready to file for divorce. Same person. Same hour.

Lucy was dealing with her own war. Part of her was genuinely remorseful — she felt like a guilty little girl, desperate to be forgiven. But another part of her was angry about the relationship and blamed John for dynamics that had existed for years. Both parts were real.

Both parts were showing up. And they were making it almost impossible to have a productive conversation.

One session they’d be on the verge of reconciliation. The next, John would shift into a place of deep pride and self-respect — “How could I stay with someone who did this to me?” — and the whole thing would feel like starting over.

That’s not a couple failing at healing. That’s two people with parts that are all showing up at once, trying to be heard.

The One Thing That Can Lead Through All of This: The Self

IFS describes something beyond all the parts — what Schwartz calls the Self. Not a part, but the essence of who you are. The Self doesn’t get triggered. It doesn’t react from fear or shame. It has the capacity for what I think of as the C-words: compassion, curiosity, calmness, clarity, and connectedness.

When the Self is in the lead, something shifts. Instead of reacting to your partner’s pain, you get curious about it. Instead of defending yourself from their anger, you get curious about the wound underneath it.

That doesn’t mean being a doormat. It means responding from depth rather than from panic.

With John and Lucy, the turning point came when John started to get genuinely curious about the part of Lucy that had cheated. Not “how could you do this” — but “what part of you did that, and what was that part trying to do?”

That question changed everything.

Not because it absolved her, but because it created enough space for something real to happen between them.

Lucy also had to get curious about the parts of John that were still showing up — his anger, his shame, his love.

And John had to make room to be curious about himself: why the intense pull toward her right after discovery, and why the equally strong moments of withdrawal and disgust.

These aren’t contradictions.

They’re parts. And they all make sense once you actually look at them.

Why I Combine IFS with EMDR

Understanding your parts is genuinely powerful. But understanding them isn’t always enough to release them. That’s where EMDR — Eye Movement Desensitization and Reprocessing — comes in.

EMDR was originally developed to treat PTSD, and infidelity can absolutely create traumatic symptoms. The intrusive thoughts. The flashbacks. The inability to feel safe.

When IFS helps a person identify and connect with a wounded part, EMDR can help actually process and release the memory and the charge that part is carrying.

Together, these approaches don’t just help people understand what happened — they help people heal from it.

For John and Lucy, working with both approaches meant that over time, the parts quieted. Not gone — they’re still people, and people still have parts. But the parts weren’t running the show anymore. The Self was.

Something You Can Try Right Now

If you’re reading this because infidelity has entered your relationship, try one thing. Just one.

Take a breath and ask yourself: what part of me is most present right now? Is it the part that wants to fight? The part that’s heartbroken? The part that still wants the relationship to work? Just notice it. You don’t have to do anything with it yet.

Then see if you can soften slightly toward that part — not in a way that agrees with everything it’s saying, but in a way that acknowledges it’s there for a reason. It’s protecting something. It’s carrying something.

If another part won’t let you do that — an angry part, a critical part, a part that says “this is ridiculous” — that’s okay too. Ask that part to soften just a little, so the other part has some room.

It’s a small step. But it’s the kind of step that over time can move you from civil war to something that actually feels like peace — within yourself, and maybe eventually with each other.

A Note on What’s Possible

John and Lucy didn’t wipe the slate clean. That’s not how healing works. But in some real ways, their relationship became deeper and more connected than it had been before the infidelity. They developed the capacity to make room for each other’s parts — to be curious rather than just reactive — and that changed who they were together.

That’s what I’ve seen across decades of this work: when people stop fighting the war inside themselves and start getting genuinely interested in what’s happening there, something opens up. Not just in the relationship — but in the person.

You’re not going crazy. You’re human. And healing is possible.

If you’re navigating infidelity right now, I created a resource specifically designed to help you get started: The Infidelity First Aid Kit. Click the link below — I think you’ll find it valuable, and hopefully even life-changing.

— Todd Creager, Making the World Safe for Love

The Infidelity First Aid Kit

How Your Attachment Style Shows Up in Bed

by Leave a Comment

Most people walk into my office with a pretty clear story about who they are in bed. “I’m the anxious one.” “My partner is avoidant.” They’ve read the books, taken the quizzes, and they’ve got their attachment style pinned down like a name tag at a conference.

And look, that’s a starting point. I get it. But after 35+ years of working with couples—many of them sitting across from me in the middle of an infidelity crisis or a dead bedroom—I can tell you that what actually happens between two people under the sheets is a lot messier and more fluid than those neat categories suggest.

The truth that most of the attachment-style content out there misses? You’re not just one style. Different parts of you carry different attachment patterns. And depending on which part gets activated in an intimate moment, you might show up as a completely different person than you did last Tuesday night.

Let’s get into what that actually looks like.

The Short Version

The four attachment styles—secure, anxious (fearful), avoidant, and fearful-avoidant (disorganized)—each create recognizable patterns during sexual intimacy. Secure attachment allows for full presence, giving, and receiving. Anxious attachment tends toward people-pleasing and losing yourself. Avoidant attachment leans toward disconnection and self-focused pleasure. Fearful-avoidant can swing between all of these, sometimes within the same encounter.

But here’s what the popular attachment content usually leaves out:

You are made up of multiple parts, and each part may carry its own attachment pattern. Your “secure self” might be running the show during a calm Sunday morning, but a triggered, fearful part might take over the moment things get physically vulnerable. This isn’t a flaw—it’s how the human system works. And understanding this changes everything about how you approach intimacy with your partner.

What Attachment Styles Actually Are (And Aren’t)

Before we talk about what happens in the bedroom, I want to reset something. There’s a tendency in popular psychology right now to treat attachment styles like personality types—fixed, singular, definitional. You take a quiz, you get a label, and now you’ve got your identity.

That’s not how it works. Not really.

Attachment theory originally comes from the work of John Bowlby and Mary Ainsworth, who studied how infants bond with their caregivers. The core insight is that our earliest relational experiences create internal working models—templates for how we expect relationships to function. Those templates follow us into adulthood, including into our sexual relationships.

The four main styles most people know are:

→ Secure attachment – a felt sense of safety in closeness and independence

→ Anxious attachment (sometimes called “fearful” or “preoccupied”) – a pull toward closeness paired with fear of abandonment

→ Avoidant attachment (sometimes called “dismissive”) – a pull toward independence paired with discomfort around emotional closeness

→ Fearful-avoidant attachment (sometimes called “disorganized”) – a conflicted experience of wanting closeness and fearing it at the same time

Now, what the research has been increasingly showing—and what I’ve been seeing in my clinical work for years—is that we’re not just one of these.

We carry different attachment adaptations in different parts of ourselves. A person might operate from secure attachment in their friendships, anxious attachment in their romantic relationship, and avoidant attachment specifically around sexual intimacy.

This is why two people can look at the same person and have totally different experiences of them. It depends on which part of that person is present.

Secure Attachment in the Bedroom: What Presence Actually Looks Like

When your secure self is present during intimacy, there’s a quality of flow to the experience. You can give to your partner—emotionally and physically—without losing yourself. And just as importantly, you can receive. You can take in the pleasure, the affection, the emotional nutrients your partner is offering.

That word “receive” is one I come back to over and over in my work with couples, because it’s something a lot of people struggle with far more than they realize.

Giving can feel controlled, manageable.

But opening yourself up to genuinely receive another person’s love, desire, and attention during sex? That requires a kind of vulnerability that only happens when you feel safe enough.

In secure mode, there’s a fluid back-and-forth. You maintain your sense of self—your own desires, your own body, your own experience—while also being attuned to your partner. It’s not selfless. It’s not selfish. It’s a kind of relational dance where both people are fully participating.

When both partners are operating from this place, the sexual experience doesn’t need to follow a script. The positions, the techniques, the sequence of events—none of that matters as much as the quality of connection underneath it all. I’ve seen couples with very simple physical routines who have incredible sexual satisfaction because they’re actually there with each other. Present. Attuned. Open.

Anxious Attachment in Bed: The Pleaser Pattern

When a fearfully attached part of you gets triggered during sex, what I most commonly see in my practice is a shift into people-pleasing mode. And I don’t mean the kind of generous attentiveness that comes from secure attachment. I mean a kind of anxious giving where the underlying motivation isn’t “I want to make you feel good” but rather “I need to make sure you don’t leave me.”

There’s a big difference between those two.

The person operating from anxious attachment in bed tends to give up their individuality. They stop asking for what they want. They stop paying attention to their own body’s signals. Their entire focus narrows onto one question: Is my partner okay? Are they happy? Are they going to stay?

Sexually, this can look like always deferring to the other person’s preferences. Never initiating something new. Going along with things that don’t feel great because saying “no” or “not like that” feels too risky. The underlying fear is that any assertion of self will be met with rejection, judgment, or abandonment.

I’ve worked with clients who can’t orgasm with their partner—not because of any physical issue, but because they literally cannot stop monitoring their partner’s experience long enough to be present in their own body. That’s the anxious attachment pattern running the show.

What sometimes confuses people is that this pattern can look like great sex from the outside. The anxiously attached partner may appear generous, attentive, willing. But underneath, they’re running on fear, not desire. And that distinction matters enormously over time, because it’s exhausting to be sexually present when your nervous system is constantly scanning for threat.

Avoidant Attachment in Bed: The Island Pattern

When a part of you that’s avoidantly attached shows up in the bedroom, it tends to look like disengagement—not necessarily from the physical act itself, but from the emotional dimension of it.

The avoidant pattern in sex often shows up as a focus on physical release without much interest in emotional connection. The person might go through the motions, might even enjoy the physical sensations, but there’s a wall between them and their partner. Vulnerability doesn’t feel safe. Letting someone truly see you, truly affect you—that’s where the avoidant part pulls back.

In my practice, I’ve noticed that people with strong avoidant patterns around sex are often not very good at receiving, either—but for different reasons than the anxiously attached person. The anxious person can’t receive because they’re too busy monitoring their partner. The avoidant person can’t receive because receiving means being affected by someone else, and that feels like a loss of control.

I think of the avoidant pattern as “island mode.” The person becomes an island unto themselves during sex. They might not be overly concerned with how their partner is doing or what their partner is feeling. It’s more about one’s own experience, one’s own pleasure, one’s own timeline.

This is also why some people who operate from strong avoidant patterns may prefer masturbation to partnered sex. With masturbation, there’s no emotional risk. No one to attune to. No vulnerability required. It’s pleasure without the relational exposure.

That’s not a judgment, by the way. It’s information. And when you understand the attachment pattern driving that preference, it opens up the possibility of making a different choice—not out of obligation, but out of a desire for something deeper.

Fearful-Avoidant in Bed: The Unpredictable Pattern

This is the one that often creates the most confusion for both the person experiencing it and their partner. Fearful-avoidant attachment (sometimes called disorganized attachment) carries both the anxious and avoidant patterns—and it can toggle between them rapidly.

In the bedroom, this might look like someone who is intensely people-pleasing one night and then emotionally checked out the next. They might go from “forget about me, it’s all about you” to “forget about you, it’s all about me”—and the partner on the receiving end is left thinking, “Who is showing up right now?”

That volatility is confusing. And if you’re the partner of someone whose fearful-avoidant part frequently gets activated during sex, it can feel like you’re making love to a different person depending on the day. That’s destabilizing.

What’s usually happening underneath is a nervous system that can’t decide whether closeness is safe or dangerous. So it oscillates. One moment it reaches for connection (the anxious side). The next moment it recoils from it (the avoidant side). In sexual situations—where you’re physically naked, emotionally exposed, and sensorially heightened—this push-pull can be especially intense.

I want to be clear: this isn’t someone being “difficult” or “crazy.” This is a nervous system responding to old, deep relational wounds. And with the right awareness and support, these patterns can shift.

Why the “Parts” Perspective Changes Everything

Here’s where I want to challenge the way most people think about attachment styles, because this is where the real growth happens.

It’s tempting to say, “I’m an avoidant” and leave it at that. But in my experience working with hundreds of couples, what’s more accurate—and more useful—is to say, “A part of me that carries an avoidant pattern tends to get activated during sex.”

Why does that distinction matter? Because when you identify with the pattern (“I am avoidant”), there’s not much room for change. It becomes who you are. But when you recognize it as a part of you—a part that developed for good reasons, usually protective ones—then you’re no longer stuck. You have a relationship with that part. You can be curious about it. You can even dialogue with it.

This perspective draws heavily from Internal Family Systems (IFS) work and other parts-based therapeutic approaches, and it maps onto what the attachment research is increasingly confirming: we are not monolithic. Different contexts activate different internal systems. The version of you that shows up with a trusted long-term partner may be very different from the version that shows up after a betrayal or during a period of high stress.

In the bedroom, this means that your attachment pattern during sex might shift depending on how safe you feel that day, what happened earlier in the conversation, whether there’s been a recent rupture in the relationship, or even how tired you are. It’s context-dependent. And knowing that gives you something to work with rather than a label to hide behind.

Recognizing Your Own Patterns: A Self-Reflection Framework

If you’re reading this and trying to figure out which pattern shows up for you in bed, here are some honest questions to sit with. These aren’t diagnostic—they’re reflective. Take your time with them.

If you tend toward anxious patterns: Do you find it hard to ask for what you want during sex? Do you monitor your partner’s reactions more than your own sensations? Do you sometimes feel like your sexuality exists to serve the relationship rather than to express your own desire? Does the thought of your partner being disappointed during sex create a disproportionate level of dread?

If you tend toward avoidant patterns: Do you prefer the physical act of sex but feel uncomfortable with prolonged eye contact, emotional sharing during intimacy, or post-sex closeness? Do you find yourself mentally “checking out” during sex even when your body is still engaged? Is masturbation easier or more satisfying than partnered sex more often than you’d like to admit?

If you tend toward fearful-avoidant patterns: Does your experience of sex feel inconsistent—sometimes connected, sometimes distant, and you’re not sure what determines which? Has your partner expressed confusion about who “shows up” in bed? Do you feel pulled between wanting deep closeness during sex and simultaneously wanting to withdraw?

If you tend toward secure patterns: Can you stay present in your own body while also attuning to your partner? Can you ask for what you want and also receive what’s offered? Does sex feel like a space of connection rather than performance, obligation, or escape?

Most people will recognize themselves in more than one of these. That’s the point. The goal isn’t to pick a box. It’s to notice which parts of you tend to show up under which conditions.

What to Do With This Information

Awareness is the first step, but it’s not the last one. Once you start recognizing which attachment pattern is running the show in any given intimate moment, you have options.

For the anxiously attached part, the work is often about developing what I call “emotional muscle”—the ability to stay present with your own experience even when your nervous system is screaming at you to abandon yourself and focus on your partner. This doesn’t mean becoming selfish. It means learning that you can be generous and still have a self.

For the avoidant part, the work tends to be about risk—specifically, the risk of being truly seen and affected by another person during sex. This often means slowing down, making eye contact, and staying present during the moments when the pull to check out is strongest.

For the fearful-avoidant pattern, the work is often about recognizing the oscillation as it’s happening. “Oh, I’m swinging into people-pleasing mode right now” or “I notice I’m pulling away.” That recognition—that moment of noticing—creates a tiny gap where choice becomes possible.

And for all of these, couples therapy or individual therapy with someone who understands attachment and intimacy can be extraordinarily helpful. These patterns didn’t develop overnight, and they usually don’t shift through willpower alone. Having a skilled guide who’s seen hundreds of people work through this—that makes a real difference.

Three Misunderstandings I See All the Time

“If my partner is avoidant, they just don’t want me.” This is almost never accurate. The avoidant pattern is a protective strategy, not a statement about desire. Most of the avoidant clients I’ve worked with do want connection—they just have a part that learned very early on that connection was dangerous. There’s usually a great deal of longing underneath the distance.

“Anxious attachment means I’m needy.” Needy is a judgment. Attachment anxiety is a nervous system response. The part of you that reaches for reassurance during sex isn’t being “too much”—it’s trying to feel safe. The work isn’t to suppress that need but to develop a more secure internal base so that need doesn’t run the show.

“Secure attachment means you never have issues in bed.” Not even close. Even people with predominantly secure attachment hit rough patches, experience desire discrepancies, deal with body image concerns, and go through seasons where sex is complicated. The difference is that secure attachment gives you the relational tools to talk about it, stay connected through it, and repair when things go sideways.

The Bigger Picture

What I really want you to take from this is that sexual intimacy is one of the most attachment-rich situations you’ll ever find yourself in. You’re physically close, emotionally exposed, and your nervous system is running hot. Of course your deepest relational patterns are going to show up there.

And that’s not a problem to solve—it’s an opportunity. The bedroom, more than almost any other context, gives you direct feedback about which parts of you feel safe and which ones don’t. If you’re willing to be curious about that feedback—not judgmental, curious—then your sexual relationship becomes one of the most powerful spaces for personal and relational growth you’ll ever have.

Both partners need to develop the emotional muscles to stay present for each other, even when old patterns get triggered. It takes work. It takes patience. It takes a willingness to be seen in your most vulnerable moments. But I’ve watched couples do this again and again over the course of my career, and what comes out the other side is something deeper and more real than what they started with.

That’s the part that gives me hope—and it’s why I keep doing this work.

Todd Creager, LCSW, LMFT, is a relationship and intimacy specialist with over 35 years of clinical experience helping couples rebuild trust, restore sexual connection, and work through the aftermath of infidelity. He is the author of multiple books on relationships and intimacy, and has helped hundreds of couples develop the emotional and relational skills needed to create deeper, more authentic partnerships.

Rediscover the Spark: Fall Back in Love with Your Partner!

Have you ever felt like the flame in your relationship is flickering? You’re not alone. It’s common for even the most passionate romances to hit a lull.

But what if you could reignite that spark and fall deeply in love all over again?

Don’t let your love story lose its luster. Click now to access “Rekindling Romance: The Art of Falling Back in Love” and start your journey to a more fulfilling, passionate relationship today! 🌟💕

She Called Herself a Venus Fly Trap — And I Was the Fly

by Leave a Comment

What a wild love story, borderline personality disorder, and a stolen key fob taught me about the parts of ourselves we hide — and what happens when someone draws them out.

Hi everybody. I get a lot of requests to be on my podcast, and I’ll be honest — I usually pass. But when Stephen Paul Edwards reached out, something about him intrigued me. Stephen is a writer with a PhD in spiritual counseling, and he’s the author of a book called The Venus Fly Trap. It’s a memoir about a relationship that was, by any measure, extraordinary. Wild. Funny. Erotic. And also deeply painful.

We had one of those conversations where forty-plus minutes felt like five. And I walked away thinking about themes that come up constantly in my work with couples — the parts of ourselves we exile, the relationships that force us to look at those parts, and the terrifying freedom that comes when you stop hiding.

I want to share some of what we talked about, because whether or not your story looks anything like Stephen’s, I think the underlying dynamics are going to feel very familiar.

How a Flower Question Became a Prophecy

The title of Stephen’s book came from the woman herself — and the way it happened tells you a lot about this relationship.

Stephen had just met her. They were texting about their first date, and he asked her a simple question: what’s your favorite flower? She said Bird of Paradise. Stephen, who has a very English, very dry sense of humor, texted back something like, “No way, mine too. But it’s a bit expensive. What’s your second favorite?”

She texted back within seconds: Venus fly trap.

And there it was. She was telling him exactly who she was, right from the beginning. She could be the Bird of Paradise — beautiful, exotic, stunning. And she could be the Venus fly trap. Both were true. Stephen said something that stuck with me: deep in his subconscious, he knew. He knew she was the Venus fly trap and he was the fly. But his desire to be with her overrode that intuition.

I talk about this with clients all the time.

That moment where something hits you intuitively — a warning, a knowing — and then your ego, your loneliness, your need to be with someone, pushes that knowing underground. It’s one of the most human things we do. And it’s one of the most costly.

A Fantasy Life That Wasn’t Real Life

Stephen was living in a 7,500-square-foot mansion. He was making a million dollars a year. He was driving a Rolls Royce. And the woman he fell for — he calls her Tamar in the book — was a former international supermodel. Five-eleven. Gorgeous. Extraordinarily intelligent. Extraordinarily intuitive.

And she had acute borderline personality disorder. All nine diagnostic symptoms, off the charts.

The stories Stephen told me were the kind you can’t look away from. They almost got thrown off a luxury cruise ship after having sex on the penthouse veranda while passengers watched from the deck above. She got banned from his entire neighborhood after the police showed up with dogs and six sheriff’s cars. She threw a fake engagement party for them at a bar in Miami without telling him. She stole the key fob to his Rolls Royce so he couldn’t leave her hotel — then pretended she had no idea what he was talking about.

And through all of it, Stephen loved her. He still does. He told me that directly, and I believe him.

But here’s what I found most striking about the way Stephen described their life together: he called it a fantasy world. Not real life. They didn’t have kids. They traveled constantly. They stayed in beautiful hotels. They had a sex room in the mansion and played backgammon in between everything else. It was exciting and intense and it was, by his own admission, not sustainable.

He compared her to heroin. And he said the same thing a heroin addict would say: I know I can never go near her again. Because if I do, I’m right back where I was.

Borderline Personality Disorder: What I Want People to Understand

I want to pause here and say something about borderline personality disorder, because I think it’s important.

BPD exists on a spectrum, like most things in our field. Some people have milder forms that are very treatable. They can manage it. It doesn’t run their lives. Other people have it acutely, and the picture is much harder.

In Stephen’s case, Tamar’s BPD was severe. And the piece that made it truly heartbreaking was this: her father had put her in an asylum when she was sixteen years old. So she would never go to therapy. Never. Because in her mind, if anyone found out she had this issue, they’d put her back in. That fear was so deep and so primal that it closed the door on any possibility of treatment.

That’s the part of this story that, as a clinician, really gets to me. The disorder itself is painful enough. But when someone’s early experiences have made them terrified of the very help that could give them relief — that’s a kind of trap that’s much harder to escape than any relationship.

And I think Stephen understood that. When he finally made the decision to end the relationship, it wasn’t because he stopped loving her. It was because he realized this particular disorder, at this severity, in a person who would never accept treatment — there was no path through it together. As he put it: do you want a life, or do you want a life like that?

The Parts We Hide and the People Who Draw Them Out

This is where the conversation really got into territory that I think about every day in my practice.

Stephen said something I loved. He said Tamar was the greatest gift he’d ever received from another person. He called her a “master teacher.” What she taught him, he said, was to own the part of himself he’d been hiding his entire life.

We all have a light side and a dark side. Most of us spend enormous energy keeping that dark side out of view. Not just from other people — from ourselves. We judge it. We shame it. We pretend it doesn’t exist. And then we wonder why we make decisions that don’t make sense to us, or why we’re drawn to people and situations that seem so clearly destructive from the outside.

I do trauma work. I use Internal Family Systems therapy, EMDR, different modalities. And one of the core ideas across all of this work is that we have parts. Some parts are easy to present to the world — the kind, the loving, the competent. Other parts are harder. The insecure parts. The vengeful parts. The sexual parts. The parts that are selfish or needy or afraid.

When we exile those parts — when we push them underground because they’re not acceptable to us or our family or our culture — they don’t disappear. They run us. We can’t make good decisions because we’re being driven by parts of ourselves we refuse to acknowledge.

Stephen was drawn to Tamar because his outside mirrored his inside. He’d been diagnosed as manic depressive at sixteen. His whole life had been up and down. He loved the excitement, the adventure, the fact that they didn’t live a normal life. That wasn’t just about her being exciting. It was about a part of him that needed that intensity to feel alive.

And by the end of writing this book, Stephen said something that I thought was remarkable. He said: there’s nothing left to hide. I have nothing left to hide. What a way to live. That’s a kind of freedom most people never get to.

A Couple I Worked With — The Ring on the Finger

Stephen’s story reminded me of a couple I saw years ago in Newport Beach, California. Good-looking couple. They came in and I asked what brought them to therapy. She held up her left hand, pointed to her bare fourth finger, and said, “This is why we’re here.”

So I looked at him and asked why he hadn’t proposed. He said he wanted to. He loved her. But she needed to get her emotions under control first. He used the word “mayhem.” Their conflicts were mayhem.

And she said: if you put a ring on my finger, maybe there wouldn’t be mayhem.

He said: maybe the problem is that you sleep with other men because you’re angry at me when I don’t put the ring on your finger.

And she said: I wouldn’t sleep with those other men if you gave me the ring.

You can hear the trap, right? It’s circular. In her reality, he was the villain and she was the victim. It’s the same dynamic Stephen described. This roping-in quality where you’re put in a position where you can’t move. Like a straight jacket — and as Stephen said, he was helping her put it on.

I eventually shared with this man that I believed she had borderline personality disorder. I showed him the nine diagnostic criteria from the DSM. And I watched his body relax. Because even though part of him knew something was off, the gaslighting had been so effective that he’d internalized it. He thought the problem was him. Just hearing that it wasn’t — that there was a name for what was happening — freed him from an enormous weight.

The Slow Loss of Self That Comes with Gaslighting

One of the things Stephen talked about that I think is so important for people to hear is how gradual the process of losing yourself really is.

He didn’t wake up one morning and realize he’d lost his mind. It happened little by little. He wanted to believe her so badly that each small distortion of reality seemed manageable. She’d make accusations out of thin air — claiming she could smell another woman’s perfume on him, saying she’d seen a picture of someone, none of it real — and he’d try to manage it. He’d agree with her. He’d make jokes. He’d rationalize.

That’s what we do when we’re in these situations. We rationalize. We tell ourselves it’s not that big of a deal. And each time we do that, we give away a little more of ourselves. Until one day you realize you’re not sure what’s real anymore.

And the person doing the gaslighting? In many cases, they don’t fully know they’re doing it. With BPD, the accusations feel real to them in the moment. Their fear of abandonment is so intense that it creates a reality in their mind — and then they project that reality onto you. She’d text him pages of awful accusations, and then when she was done, she’d text “I love you.” She was emoting. Whatever she was feeling came out, got projected, and then when the wave passed, the love was back.

I’ve seen this pattern hundreds of times. It’s confusing and it’s crazy-making, and it’s not your imagination.

Why Stopping and Looking Inside Changes Everything

I think one of the most important decisions any person can make — and I really believe this separates people who have better lives from people who don’t — is the decision to stop running and look inside.

Stephen spent most of his life going two hundred miles an hour. He told me he journaled, but he never read his journals. That’s such a good detail, because it captures exactly how people run. They go through the motions of self-reflection without ever actually doing it. The journal exists, but the looking doesn’t happen.

About three years ago, Stephen took a break from relationships and gave himself time to actually reflect. And writing the book became that process. He said he’d find himself writing and laughing at what happened, then crying at what happened. It was cathartic in a way that just living through it never could have been.

That’s what happens when you stop. The emotions that were too big to feel in the moment finally get their chance. And when you let them through, something shifts. You develop a deeper relationship with yourself. You stop performing a version of yourself and start actually being yourself.

Stephen said he’d been performing since he was a teenager. I think a lot of people can relate to that. You put on a version of yourself that the world finds acceptable, and you run with it for years — decades — until something forces you to stop. Sometimes that something is a crisis. Sometimes it’s a relationship that blows your life apart. And sometimes, if you’re fortunate, it’s a choice you make before the crisis forces it.

Childhood Trauma and Why We’re Drawn to Who We’re Drawn To

Both Stephen and Tamar had childhood trauma. Stephen was diagnosed as manic depressive at sixteen. Tamar’s father was a billionaire who raised her like a princess and then had her institutionalized as a teenager. They both carried deep wounds into adulthood, and those wounds shaped who they were attracted to and why.

This is something I see over and over in my practice. Childhood trauma doesn’t just affect how you feel about yourself. It affects who you choose. The partner who feels like electricity, who makes you feel more alive than anyone else, who you can’t seem to walk away from — that person often fits with your wounds in ways you don’t fully understand until you stop and look.

I’ve spent years developing a program called Healing Infidelity from the Inside Out, and the “inside out” part is the whole point. The external behaviors — the cheating, the lying, the chaos — are symptoms. The real work happens when you turn inward and ask: what part of me was looking for this? What was I running from? What did this person or this situation give me that I didn’t know how to give myself?

I also think there are societal reasons we end up in these patterns. We’ve been taught to hide from ourselves. If a feeling isn’t acceptable to our family or our culture, it goes underground. We exile it. And then it runs us from the shadows.

Monogamy, Sexual Freedom, and Learning to Handle Complexity

Stephen and I had a really interesting exchange about what he called “the new sexual revolution.” His take was that people are more sexually liberated than they were fifty years ago, and that this liberation keeps building on itself. Women are claiming parts of themselves that used to be forbidden. Social media lets us see into lives we never would have seen before. The boundaries around identity and sexuality are shifting in real time.

And I think he’s right. But here’s where my clinical mind goes: with that freedom comes complexity. And complexity requires skills that most of us were never taught.

I wrote a book called The Long, Hot Marriage, and I’ve chosen a monogamous lifestyle myself. And I’ve had to evolve in how I think about this. I’ve worked with couples in polyamorous relationships, and some of them do it in a very healthy, intentional way. I’ve worked with monogamous couples who do it in an unhealthy way. The structure isn’t the issue. The issue is: do you have the emotional maturity and communication skills to honor whatever contract you’ve created?

In my own marriage, I can tell my wife that some part of me wants to flirt with a woman half my age. And she’ll say, “Yeah, you’re a creeper.” And we laugh. Because that part of me is allowed to exist. It’s acknowledged. It’s not exiled into the shadows where it could cause real damage. That’s what I mean by handling complexity.

For Stephen, the issue wasn’t that Tamar was bisexual or non-monogamous. The issue was that her behavior was driven by a disorder that made real partnership impossible. She was smart enough to articulate interesting ideas about monogamy — and Stephen acknowledged that. But the illness underneath meant those ideas were serving a compulsion, not a philosophy.

If Any of This Sounds Familiar…

I’m sharing all of this because Stephen’s story, as wild as it is, contains threads that run through so many of the relationships I see in my practice. The gaslighting. The losing yourself. The choosing someone who matches your wounds. The rationalization. The way excitement and trauma can feel almost identical when you’re in the middle of it.

Your version of this might not involve a Rolls Royce or a cruise ship or a stolen key fob. But if you’re with someone and you feel like you’re in a straight jacket — and part of you knows you’re helping them put it on — that’s worth paying attention to.

And if you’ve come out the other side of a relationship like this, and you’re trying to make sense of what happened and why you stayed — please know that making sense of it is some of the most important work you can do. Not to assign blame. Not to beat yourself up. But because understanding the parts of yourself that were running the show is how you stop repeating the pattern.

Stephen’s book is available at VFT23.com, where you can also get a free e-version and a bonus book called Madness and Mayhem. I’d recommend it. Not just for the stories — though those are something — but for the honesty. Stephen said that by the time he finished writing, he had nothing left to hide. That kind of radical honesty is rare, and it’s the thing that makes real healing possible.

If you’re dealing with a relationship that feels impossible to understand, or if you know you need to stop running and start looking — reach out. That’s what I’m here for. You don’t have to figure it out alone.

About This Article

This article is based on a podcast conversation between Todd Creager, LCSW, and Stephen Paul Edwards, author of The Venus Fly Trap. Clinical observations are informed by over 30 years of practice specializing in couples therapy, infidelity recovery, and trauma work using Internal Family Systems (IFS) and EMDR. Client details in Todd’s clinical examples have been changed to protect privacy. Stephen’s book The Venus Fly Trap and bonus book Madness and Mayhem are available at VFT23.com.

Todd Creager, LCSW, is a licensed clinical social worker and relationship therapist. He is the author of The Long, Hot Marriage and the creator of the Healing Infidelity from the Inside Out program.

Watch The Interview with Stephen Paul Edwards

About Stephen Paul Edwards

Stephen Paul Edwards is a writer, speaker, and spiritual development coach with a PhD in spiritual counseling. Originally from England, Stephen spent years working alongside Tony Robbins before launching his own personal and spiritual development program.

His memoir, The Venus Fly Trap, tells the raw, funny, and heartbreaking story of a relationship that changed his life and forced him to confront the parts of himself he’d been hiding for decades.

His bonus book, Madness and Mayhem, gives readers a taste of the full story – get a free version here: https://bit.ly/3MvAtAa  

When Your Partner’s ‘Insecurity’ Is Actually a Control Strategy

by Leave a Comment

A partner who seems insecure—who needs constant reassurance, who gets jealous, who reacts strongly when you spend time with other people—and on the surface, it looks like vulnerability.

It looks like someone who cares deeply and is afraid of losing you. And sometimes, that’s exactly what it is.

But sometimes it’s not.

Sometimes what looks like insecurity is actually manipulation. And the difference between those two things is enormous—not just in how it affects the relationship, but in how it affects you.

Your sense of self, your mental health, your ability to trust your own perceptions. I’ve spent decades working with people who have slowly lost their sense of who they are because they were living with a partner whose “insecurity” was really about power and control. My work with them is about helping them reclaim that sense of self, whether they choose to stay or leave.

The Short Version

Insecurity and manipulation can look remarkably similar in the early stages of a relationship. Both involve neediness, reassurance-seeking, and emotional reactivity.

The critical distinction comes down to one question: Is this person driven by fear of losing you, or by a need to control you?

That sounds simple. In real life, it’s anything but. So here’s what most people don’t realize until they’re deep into it:

With genuine insecurity, reassurance actually works—at least temporarily. With manipulation, nothing you do is ever enough because the goalpost keeps moving.

→ Insecure partners can still apologize and take responsibility. Manipulative partners turn every conflict back on you.

→ The most adaptive, kind, good-hearted people are often the most vulnerable to this dynamic—not because they’re weak, but because they genuinely want to see the best in their partner.

Why This Is So Hard to See When You’re In It

Let me be honest with you. The people I work with who are being manipulated—they’re not foolish. They’re usually incredibly thoughtful, empathetic people. That’s part of why this works on them. They have a real capacity to see their partner’s pain, and they want to help. When their partner says, “I’m just scared of losing you,” they believe it, because they themselves would be sincere if they said something like that.

Here’s the thing. In many of these relationships, the manipulation doesn’t show up on day one. The early stages might feel wonderful—attentive, connected, maybe even a little intense. It’s only over time, sometimes years, that the pattern reveals itself. And by then, you’ve already adjusted your behavior so many times that you can’t remember what normal felt like.

I’ve worked with people who tell me, “I used to have so many friends. I used to be confident. I don’t know what happened.” What happened was gradual. And it was designed to be gradual, so you wouldn’t notice.

Six Patterns That Separate Insecurity From Manipulation

In my clinical experience with hundreds of couples over more than 30 years, I’ve identified a handful of patterns that reliably distinguish genuine insecurity from manipulative control. None of these is a diagnosis on its own. But if you recognize several of them happening together, it’s worth paying very close attention.

1. The Goalpost That Never Stops Moving

When someone is genuinely insecure, they need reassurance—and when they get it, there’s usually some relief. It might not last forever, but there’s a moment of, “Okay, I feel better.”

With a manipulative partner, you can change your behavior, give up things that matter to you, reorganize your entire life around their comfort—and it’s never enough. A behavior that was perfectly fine yesterday suddenly becomes a crisis today. You find yourself thinking, “I did exactly what they asked, so why are they still upset?”

The answer is that the upset was never about what they said it was about. It was about keeping you off-balance. Because a person who is constantly trying to figure out what they did wrong is a person who is easy to control.

2. Apologies That Only Go One Direction

This one is subtle but very telling. In a healthy relationship—even one where one partner struggles with insecurity—apologies go both ways. Your partner might overreact, and then later say, “I’m sorry. I know I was being unreasonable. I’m working on it.”

In a manipulative dynamic, you do the apologizing. You apologize because something you said or did made them upset. But when you bring up your pain, the conversation pivots. Suddenly it’s about how your reaction was the problem. They don’t take responsibility. They redirect. Over time, you start to accept that your feelings are less important—that your job is to manage their emotions, not the other way around.

I want to be direct about this: if you’re always the one apologizing and your partner rarely or never takes genuine accountability, that’s a pattern worth examining. An insecure person can still own their behavior. A manipulator almost never does.

3. Your Reality Starts to Feel Unstable

Does an insecure partner sometimes see things differently than you? Of course. Two people can witness the same event and have genuinely different experiences of it. That’s normal.

What is not normal is when you start to doubt your own memory. When you clearly remember something happening and your partner tells you it didn’t. When you’re told you’re “too sensitive” or “imagining things” so many times that you begin to wonder if maybe they’re right.

This is gaslighting, and it serves a very specific purpose. If you can’t trust your own perceptions, you become dependent on someone else to define reality for you. And guess who steps into that role?

I spend a lot of time with clients helping them reconnect with their own internal compass. I ask them: “If your partner hadn’t said those things, what would you believe? What do you think happened?” That simple question can be surprisingly powerful for someone who hasn’t been asked what they think in a very long time.

4. Isolation Dressed Up as Protection

A certain amount of jealousy in a relationship isn’t always destructive. Sometimes it’s a sign that someone values you and the relationship. An insecure partner might feel uncomfortable when you go out with friends, and they’ll tell you that—but they won’t try to stop you.

A manipulative partner will. And they’ll frame it as love.

I worked with a couple where the husband had effectively cut off his wife’s relationship with her own father. He presented it as protecting her boundaries—her family was “dysfunctional,” he said, and she didn’t need the stress. The mother, who stayed quiet, was tolerated. But the father, who pushed back against the son-in-law’s behavior, was shut out entirely. By the time I saw them, this woman’s father hadn’t seen his grandchild for over a year.

That wasn’t protection. That was isolation. And the real reason was that people who love you—friends, family—are voices of reason. They see what’s happening. A controlling partner doesn’t want you hearing those voices, because if you did, you might set boundaries. You might get healthier. And that threatens their control.

If you used to have a full social life and you don’t anymore, and you can’t quite explain what happened—take a careful look at who benefited from that change.

5. The Silent Treatment as a Weapon

There’s a difference between someone who needs space to calm down after a disagreement and someone who withdraws affection as punishment.

The manipulative version sounds like: “If you set that boundary, I’m leaving.” Or it’s just silence. Cold silence, designed to make you panic and give in. It’s not, “I need time to process.” It’s, “You will comply, or you will suffer.”

This is a calculated move to force submission. It’s not fear. It’s not insecurity. It’s power.

6. Boundaries Are Treated as an Attack

People who struggle with insecurity might initially resist a boundary—but with some patience and communication, they can come to respect it. They might not like it, but they can sit with the discomfort.

For a manipulative partner, your boundaries are the enemy. Every boundary you set becomes a battle. They’ll question your motives, accuse you of not loving them, or escalate the situation until you back down.

Why? Because boundaries limit their control. And control is what this is about. Not love. Not vulnerability. Control.

The Distinction That Changes Everything: Fear vs. Power

If I could leave you with one thing from this article, it’s this: Insecurity is fear-based. Manipulation is power-based.

The insecure partner is afraid of losing you. The manipulative partner is afraid of losing control over you. Those are two very different fears that produce two very different behaviors.

Now, I’ll be honest—underneath the need for power, there is often fear. Maybe this person grew up in a chaotic household where they had no control, and now they feel safe only when they’re running the show. Understanding that doesn’t excuse the behavior. But it does help explain it. And it helps you see that this isn’t something you caused and it’s not something you can fix by being more accommodating. The accommodation is the trap.

Side-by-Side: Insecurity vs. Manipulation

I’ve put together this comparison from patterns I’ve observed over decades of clinical work. No single item is definitive on its own, but clusters of these behaviors are very meaningful.What to Do If You Recognize These Patterns

I want to be careful here, because every situation is different, and I don’t believe in one-size-fits-all advice. But I can share what I’ve seen work in my practice.

Start by Trusting Yourself Again

If you’ve been in a manipulative dynamic for a while, your own internal compass may feel broken. It’s not. It’s been suppressed. The work starts with asking yourself what you think, what you feel, and what you would believe if no one else was telling you what to believe.

This sounds simple. For someone who has been gaslighted for years, it can be one of the hardest things they’ve ever done.

Get Outside Perspective

There’s a reason manipulative partners cut off your support system. Those people see what you can’t see when you’re in the middle of it. Reconnecting with trusted friends, family, or a therapist who understands these dynamics is not weakness. It’s one of the bravest things you can do.

Understand Your Own Patterns

Many people who end up in manipulative relationships are highly adaptive. They learned early in life to read other people’s moods and adjust accordingly. That skill, which was probably a survival strategy at some point, makes them especially susceptible to a partner who uses emotional volatility as a control mechanism.

Understanding this about yourself isn’t about self-blame. It’s about knowing what to watch for—in this relationship and in future ones.

Professional Support Matters

I’ll say this plainly: these dynamics are complex, and trying to sort through them alone is extraordinarily difficult. A therapist who specializes in relational dynamics, gaslighting, or emotional abuse can help you see patterns you’ve been too close to recognize. This is true whether you decide to stay in the relationship or leave.

If you stay, certain things absolutely have to change. If you leave, you’ll need support to rebuild your sense of self. Either way, you don’t have to do this alone.

The Hardest Part: Cognitive Dissonance

Here’s something I don’t hear people talk about enough. When you start to realize that your partner’s behavior might be manipulation rather than insecurity, you’re going to experience a painful internal conflict.

Because you want to see your partner as a good person. Maybe in the beginning of the relationship, they were wonderful—or they seemed to be. You’re holding onto that version of them. The idea that the person you love might be deliberately controlling you creates a kind of cognitive dissonance that is genuinely agonizing.

This is normal. And it’s exactly why people stay in these relationships long after they’ve sensed something was off. The dissonance itself becomes another barrier to clarity.

The only way through it is to face what’s true—not all at once, but gradually, with support. It takes real courage. And the people who do this work, who sit with the discomfort and come out the other side, are some of the strongest people I know.

Questions I Hear Often

Can a manipulative partner change?

It’s possible, but it requires them to genuinely recognize and take responsibility for the behavior—not just apologize when caught. In my experience, meaningful change only happens when the manipulative partner does their own deep personal work, usually with a therapist, over an extended period. It’s not your job to make that happen or wait for it.

What if my partner has some of these traits but not all of them?

Human behavior doesn’t fit neatly into categories. Some people have genuine insecurity and controlling tendencies. The question isn’t whether to label your partner but whether the overall pattern is eroding your sense of self. If you’re constantly walking on eggshells, if you feel smaller and more confused over time, that’s worth addressing regardless of the label.

Is it possible I’m the manipulative one?

The fact that you’re asking that question is actually a meaningful data point. People who are genuinely manipulative rarely wonder about it. They’re defensive, not self-reflective. If you’re worried about your own behavior, that concern itself suggests you have the self-awareness and empathy that characterize an insecure partner, not a controlling one. That said, a good therapist can help you examine your patterns honestly.

Moving Forward

If anything in this article resonated with you—or if you recognized these patterns in someone you care about—I want you to know something.

This experience is demoralizing.

It can take your mental health and even your physical health down many notches. But you are not broken, and you are not crazy. What you’re experiencing is real.

The path forward starts with acknowledging what’s true, dealing with the confusion and cognitive dissonance, and coming out the other side with a stronger sense of who you are.

You deserve a relationship where reassurance actually reassures. Where your boundaries are respected. Where your reality is honored. That’s not too much to ask. It’s the bare minimum.

This is Todd Creager, making the world safe for love.

About the Author

Todd Creager, LCSW, LMFT, is a licensed couples therapist and infidelity recovery specialist with over 30 years of clinical experience. He has worked with hundreds of couples dealing with trust violations, emotional manipulation, and the complicated work of rebuilding relationships. Todd specializes in helping individuals who have lost their sense of self through prolonged manipulation to regain their internal compass and emotional stability. He is the author of multiple books on relationships and intimacy, and his approach combines clinical expertise with genuine compassion for the people sitting in his office.

Limitations: This article provides general educational information, not clinical diagnosis. Every relationship is unique, and the patterns described here exist on a spectrum.

If you’re concerned about manipulation in your relationship, professional assessment is recommended.

Feeling like you might be the victim of verbal abuse and/or gaslighting?

GET YOUR CHECKLIST HERE!

Why You Cannot Move On After Being Lied To: Cognitive Dissonance Explained

by Leave a Comment

Cognitive Dissonance: Loving Someone Who Lies

Hi everybody, this is something I see in my office almost every week. A client sits across from me and says, “I found out he’s been lying to me for years. About so many things. But I still love him. What’s wrong with me?”

Nothing is wrong with you. You’re experiencing what psychologists call cognitive dissonance, and when it comes to loving someone who has lied to you, it’s one of the most confusing and painful experiences you’ll go through.

Here’s the short version: Cognitive dissonance happens when you’re holding two conflicting truths at the same time. You loved someone deeply AND they’ve been lying to you. Both things are real. Your brain is trying to reconcile something that doesn’t reconcile easily, and that creates tremendous internal conflict.

But here’s what most people miss about this experience:

→ The confusion you feel isn’t weakness or gullibility. It’s actually evidence of your capacity to trust and form genuine connections.

→ This isn’t just an emotional struggle. Your nervous system and attachment patterns from childhood are involved, which is why you can’t just “logic your way out” of it.

→ The presence of cognitive dissonance doesn’t mean you should leave OR that you should stay. It means you need time and information before your heart and mind can align again.

The Three Core Conflicts I See When Lies Are Discovered

When someone discovers their partner has been lying to them—whether it’s lies about infidelity (sexual, emotional, or financial), addiction, money, online activities, or other deceptions—they typically face three overlapping conflicts. I’m going to walk you through each one because understanding them helps you be kinder to yourself during this confusing time.

Love vs. Reality

I’m thinking right now of a woman I’ve been working with. She was married for 25 years. Twenty-five years of what she experienced as a committed, loving partnership. She gave herself fully to this marriage and their family. She was loyal. She loved him deeply.

When she discovered the multiple infidelities and saw just how good he was at covering them up—the sophistication of his lies, how he did it, the systems he had in place—it devastated her. Why? Because the lies meant she hadn’t been living in reality at all.

Here’s what makes this so painful: He was living a completely different marriage than she was. She was experiencing a reality of mutual love, loyalty, family building, giving of herself. He was having a fantasy life with secret activities, all while love-bombing her and making her feel wonderful. That was part of how he manipulated her through lies. But he had a very different internal experience of their relationship.

Two people can be married and not be living in the same marriage. Nobody experiences marriage identically, but when one partner is lying and living a secret life, the gap becomes extreme.

And here’s the thing that creates cognitive dissonance: There were genuinely good moments. The lies don’t erase those moments. Even with people who are abusive, there are good moments, and that creates its own cognitive dissonance. But right now I’m talking about lies specifically.

Those good experiences you had? They were real for you. Your good feelings, your loving emotions, the oxytocin and dopamine responses in your brain, those were genuine. Some people tell me, “I never felt so loved and so loving with anyone else.” And then they find out this person has been lying to them, keeping massive secrets from them.

You’re facing your reality of love against the reality of lies you’re confronting right now. When people lie like this, it doesn’t always mean they don’t love you. But there were parts of them that were not capable of the kind of honest love you were giving. There were parts of them living in secrecy and deception. You had very different capacities to give and receive love, and you thought it was one thing when it was actually something else.

That reality is difficult to accept when you know you felt real love, real connection, real purpose. So if you’re hearing this and it relates to your situation, please understand: your confusion is normal. It’s completely understandable to feel this conflicted.

I’ve had people ask me, “What’s wrong with me? Why don’t I just move on?” It’s because there’s a part of you that doesn’t want to move on. A part that doesn’t want to give up the reality you were living all those years. That’s not so easy to just give up.

Attachment vs. Evidence

Related to this love-versus-reality conflict is the attachment-versus-evidence dynamic.

When you’re in an attachment relationship, especially if you’ve developed what psychologists call a “secure attachment,” you feel safe. You’re able to depend on your partner to some degree while also regulating your own emotions. The woman I mentioned earlier? She had formed a secure attachment. She felt genuinely secure in her marriage. Her partner was more avoidant and didn’t have the full investment she did, but she was deeply attached.

When that attachment gets threatened by discovering lies, it doesn’t just hurt in the present moment. It triggers early abandonment wounds from your past. Maybe you had parents who let you down or past relationships where people disappointed you. Your nervous system remembers all of that, and on some level, you’re protecting yourself from not only the pain of the current lies but the echo of past pain.

This is why it’s easy to stay in denial. Part of you wants to hold onto the belief that “this can’t be true” because accepting it means facing all that pain.

But then there’s the other side: the evidence. In my client’s case, the texts, the media she found, the phone calls she saw, the credit card records, whatever evidence she discovered. The neurobiological attachment saying “don’t let go” is in direct conflict with the factual evidence of lies.

It’s a difficult thing for your brain to negotiate. You’re attached at a deep, neurobiological level, but the evidence of deception is sitting right in front of you.

Hope vs. Self-Abandonment

The third major conflict I see is between hope and self-abandonment.

Part of you hopes this person will stop lying. Part of you hopes things can get better. And I want you to know: I’m a person who says things can get better. I’ve seen couples where there has been lying, where that person changes. The lying does get better. That happens.

But here’s the complexity: The person who was lied to has got to find that out over time. They need to see if this person is really taking a closer look at themselves and making some changes so that they won’t lie in the future.

In the meantime, you’re going through this internal battle between wanting hope and not wanting to abandon yourself. You don’t want to treat yourself like everything was okay when it wasn’t. You don’t want to act like the lies didn’t happen. You don’t want to treat yourself like you don’t matter.

This is incredibly difficult for many people, even in the face of their partner making some real good changes. They feel like, “I’m abandoning myself. I’m treating myself like everything was okay and it wasn’t. I’m treating myself like it didn’t happen. I’m treating myself like I don’t matter.”

When someone lies to us, even if they start to get better, it’s really hard to trust it because you feel like you’re abandoning yourself. You feel like you’re letting them get away with it. It makes you feel like if you treat things like it’s all okay, you’re abandoning yourself.

So you’ve got love versus reality, attachment versus evidence, and hope versus self-abandonment, all happening simultaneously. There’s a lot of cognitive dissonance in loving someone who lies to you and trying to recover from all that.

What This Looks Like in Real Time

Let me give you a sense of what I hear in my office when someone is experiencing this cognitive dissonance after discovering lies:

“I know what he did was terrible. I saw the texts. But I still love him.”

“She says she’s done lying, and I see some differences, but how do I know this is real?”

“Some days I’m so angry about the lies I can barely look at him. Other days I remember why I fell in love with him.”

“I feel crazy. How can I still love someone who lied to me for so long?”

“My friends think I’m stupid for staying with someone who lied, but they don’t understand how good it was before.”

“I want to believe the lies are over, but every time I start to trust, I feel like I’m being naive again.”

Do any of these sound familiar? If so, you’re right in the middle of cognitive dissonance.

The Path Through Cognitive Dissonance

The good news, and there is good news here, is that there are ways to navigate this. First of all, be kind to yourself. There’s a practice here.

When you’re feeling that cognitive dissonance, you want to be kind to yourself. If you want to think about it as a silver lining, it’s your opportunity to treat yourself very well no matter what happens with your relationship. Your confusion doesn’t make you weak or gullible. It makes you human. It makes you someone who trusted deeply and is now trying to integrate a painful reality.

The second thing is to be patient with yourself. You have that cognitive dissonance. Be patient. Your brain needs time to process two conflicting truths. Some days you’ll feel clear. Other days you’ll feel confused again. That’s normal.

Third, do your research with your partner. See if they’re making real changes or just superficial changes. Are they just in crisis and trying to hold onto what they had before with you? Or are they really trying to shift and change from the inside out?

What were the underlying factors that led to his or her lying? Are those dissolving? That does happen. Like I said, I’m hopeful because I’ve seen this happen, but it doesn’t always happen.

When I work with couples dealing with this, I’m looking for evidence of real change: Are they showing evidence of healing? Is there transparency now where there were secrets before? Is there consistency over time? Are they willing to be uncomfortable and vulnerable? Are they really atoning for what they did?

Fourth, face reality while keeping hope alive when it’s appropriate. Whether it’s love versus reality, yeah, ultimately you need to face reality. But part of the reality is to check out: is this partner who lied to me getting better? Are they showing evidence of that?

So there’s the evidence of what the person did and how they lied, but is there also the evidence of them healing?

Hope versus self-abandonment. There’s nothing wrong with hope, as long as you’re not in denial and it’s not self-abandonment. When you see some real changes from the inside out, where behavior’s changing, the person’s really atoning for what they did, and you’re starting to see some real shifts—these are some of the things I look at when I’m working with people and their cognitive dissonance.

Self-abandonment is when you’re not conscious and you’re clinging to a partner who lied to you without seeing if anything has changed. But it isn’t self-abandonment when you’re really taking a step back, when you’re doing the work, but you’re seeing that your partner’s doing the work, and that you hope again and you let hope rule based on evidence.

It’s all important to take your time. See what’s really going on. But throughout the whole process, be kind to yourself.

The Role of Attachment Patterns

I mentioned earlier that attachment patterns play a role in cognitive dissonance. Let me expand on that because it’s important for understanding yourself.

If you formed a secure attachment in your relationship, you felt safe depending on your partner. You could regulate your emotions relatively well. When that gets shattered by discovering lies, it’s not just the deception you’re grieving. You’re grieving the sense of safety you had.

Your partner’s lies trigger early abandonment wounds. Who wants to have that? So it’s easy to stay in denial and hold onto the belief this can’t be true because on some level, you’re protecting yourself from not only the pain of the current lies but the pain of past disappointments with other people who let you down.

If you came into the relationship with anxious attachment patterns (maybe from childhood experiences), the lies confirm your worst fears about not being able to trust or not being enough. That makes the cognitive dissonance even more intense because you’re fighting against old wounds being ripped open again.

Understanding your attachment pattern doesn’t solve the problem, but it helps you understand why you’re responding the way you are. It helps you recognize: I’m attached. I don’t want to give up that attachment. It’s not just about not wanting to give up the idea—there’s also attachment at a neurobiological level.

What About When The Lying Continues?

I want to be realistic with you. Sometimes the person who lied doesn’t change. Sometimes they make superficial adjustments but continue lying in other ways. Sometimes they’re just scared of losing what they had, but they’re not actually doing the internal work required to become an honest person.

If that’s what you’re seeing after giving it time, then your cognitive dissonance is trying to tell you something: The love you felt was real, but this relationship can’t continue if the lies continue.

That doesn’t make your love invalid. It doesn’t mean the good moments weren’t real. It means you’re facing an incredibly painful truth: Sometimes love isn’t enough if the other person isn’t capable of or willing to stop lying.

Your job isn’t to force yourself to stop loving someone. Your job is to take care of yourself, even if that means leaving a relationship where you still have loving feelings but where lies continue.

Moving Forward With Yourself

Whether you stay in your relationship or leave, whether your partner stops lying or doesn’t, you’re going to need to work through this cognitive dissonance.

That means:

Allowing yourself to hold both truths. You loved them deeply. They lied to you. Both are true.

Recognizing that your confusion makes sense given the circumstances. You experienced one reality while they were living another.

Taking all the time you need to process this. There’s no timeline for reconciling conflicting realities.

Finding support, whether that’s through therapy, support groups, or trusted friends who won’t pressure you to make decisions before you’re ready.

Practicing self-compassion when you feel stupid or naive. You’re none of those things. You trusted someone you loved. That’s what we’re supposed to do in relationships.

Remember what I said at the beginning: The confusion you feel isn’t weakness. It’s evidence of your capacity to trust and love. The fact that you’re struggling to reconcile these conflicting truths means you’re someone who formed a real attachment, who gave yourself authentically to a relationship.

That’s not something to be ashamed of. That’s something that speaks to your humanity and your heart.

Understanding Why You Have Cognitive Dissonance

Let me bring this together. Understand why you have cognitive dissonance for the reasons I’ve been talking about here today.

You have cognitive dissonance because:

You experienced real love while being lied to. Both happened simultaneously, even though they seem incompatible.

You formed a real attachment while the other person was keeping secrets. Your nervous system bonded with someone who wasn’t showing you their full reality.

You have hope for a relationship without lies while also not wanting to abandon yourself by pretending the lies didn’t matter.

These are completely normal, human responses to discovering that someone you love has been lying to you. The cognitive dissonance shows you’re grappling with a genuinely complex situation, not that there’s something wrong with you.

A Note on Time and Healing

I’ve been working with couples dealing with lies and infidelity for many years now. One thing I’ve learned: Cognitive dissonance doesn’t resolve quickly. It takes months, sometimes longer, for your heart and mind to align again after discovering significant lies.

During that time, you’ll have moments of clarity followed by moments of confusion. You’ll have days where you feel strong and days where you doubt everything. You’ll go back and forth between anger and love, between wanting to fix things and wanting to leave.

That’s all part of the process. Be patient with yourself as you move through it.

And know this: On the other side of cognitive dissonance, whether you stay or go, is a clearer sense of reality. You’ll eventually integrate these conflicting truths into a more complete picture. It won’t be the picture you had before, but it will be one you can stand on solidly because it’s based on truth rather than lies.

About Working Through This:

I’ve been helping couples and individuals work through the aftermath of lies and deception for over three decades. What I’ve seen repeatedly is that people are stronger and more resilient than they think.

The cognitive dissonance you’re experiencing is painful, but it’s also a sign that you’re not willing to ignore reality or abandon yourself.

If you’re going through this right now, please be gentle with yourself. Take your time. Do the research on whether your partner has genuinely stopped lying. Face reality while maintaining hope based on evidence, not denial.

And remember: Whatever you’re feeling makes sense. You’re not crazy. You’re not weak. You’re someone who loved deeply and trusted fully and is now trying to navigate one of the most painful experiences a person can have—discovering that the person you loved has been lying to you.

That takes courage.

Feeling like you might be the victim of verbal abuse and/or gaslighting?

GET YOUR CHECKLIST HERE!

Trust Your Gut Recognizing Gaslighting in Your Relationship

by Leave a Comment

When Your Gut Knows the Truth But Your Partner Says You’re Wrong

Understanding Gaslighting, Reclaiming Your Intuition, and Finding Your Way Back to Yourself

You know something is wrong. Your body tells you. That tight feeling in your chest, the knot in your stomach, that voice in the back of your head saying this isn’t right.

But every time you try to bring it up, your partner turns it around. Suddenly you’re the problem. You’re “too sensitive” or “overreacting” or “imagining things.”

And here’s the thing that breaks my heart: after enough of this, you start to believe them.

The Quick Version

Gaslighting is when your partner consistently makes you doubt your own perceptions, memories, and gut instincts. It’s a form of emotional abuse—sometimes conscious and strategic, sometimes unconscious and self-protective. Either way, the damage is the same: you lose trust in yourself, which is the foundation of self-esteem and healthy relationships.

What Most People Don’t Realize

First, people who want relationships to work are more vulnerable to gaslighting. If you deeply value family, commitment, and connection, you’re more likely to question yourself rather than question your partner. That’s not weakness—it’s a strength being exploited.

Second, the person gaslighting often doesn’t see what they’re doing. In many cases, it’s an automatic defense mechanism rooted in their own unprocessed pain, shame, or trauma. They genuinely believe their version of events because facing the truth would be too painful.

Third, and this is the part that matters most: recovery means learning to trust your gut again. Not just leaving a bad situation, but actually rebuilding that relationship with your own intuition that got damaged along the way.

How Gaslighting Actually Works

Let me be clear about what gaslighting looks like in real life, because sometimes people think it has to be dramatic or obvious. It usually isn’t.

Your partner comes home late. You feel something’s off. When you ask about it, they don’t just explain—they attack. “Why are you always so suspicious? You’re so controlling. No wonder I don’t want to come home.” Now you’re apologizing for asking a simple question.

Or maybe you’re upset about something they said. Instead of hearing you out, they rewrite history: “I never said that. You’re making things up again.” And you start wondering if maybe you did misremember, even though you know you didn’t.

Over time, you learn to walk on eggshells. You describe it to me like walking through a minefield—one wrong step and everything blows up. You become invisible, making yourself smaller and smaller, just trying to avoid the next explosion.

Projective Identification: The Psychology Behind the Pattern

There’s a concept in psychology called projective identification, and understanding it can be really helpful. Here’s how it works: when someone can’t tolerate certain feelings in themselves—shame, inadequacy, fear—they project those feelings onto you. But it goes further than that. You actually start feeling what they can’t feel. You take on their emotional baggage.

So if your partner feels deep down that they’re not good enough, but they can’t face that, they might make you feel not good enough. Their shame becomes your shame. Their inadequacy becomes your inadequacy. It’s like an emotional transfer they don’t even know they’re doing.

This is why victims of gaslighting so often say, “I don’t even know what’s mine and what’s theirs anymore.” That confusion is the projective identification at work.

A Story from My Practice

Let me tell you about a couple I worked with many years ago—names changed, of course, but the dynamics were so clear.

The husband comes in for our first session and immediately goes on the attack. I was probably 20 years younger than I am now—he was probably my age at the time. He looks at me and says something along the lines of, “What does some young punk therapist know about marriage? Go to hell.” That was my greeting. First session.

Now, I’m human. I felt intimidated. But something about that intimidation felt off to me—not quite mine. So I said to his wife, “Wow, I feel really intimidated right now. Do you feel this way around him?”

She looked at me and said, “All the time. So do a lot of other people.”

I saw the smirk on his face. He was proud of this. So I turned to him and explained projective identification—that when someone makes everyone around them feel intimidated, often they’re unconsciously passing along a feeling they can’t tolerate in themselves.

He gave me grief about “fancy words” but I pressed on: “Who the hell intimidated you?”

And then, underneath all that aggression, something shifted. “Oh, so this is where I’m supposed to tell you about my father and how he abused me pretty much from the day I was born.”

There it was.

What Happened Next

This man was gaslighting his wife constantly. He made everyone around him feel stupid, inadequate, like they were walking through a minefield. But it wasn’t really about them—it was his own feelings of unworthiness, his own damaged self-esteem from a critical, abusive father. He acted out on other people what he couldn’t face in himself.

I don’t believe, deep down, he was a malicious man. Some people who gaslight are, but he wasn’t. He just had no other way to cope with his pain.

We worked together, and he was willing—with the right help—to see what he was doing. To recognize it as a defense mechanism. To understand how he was impacting the people he loved.

About eight or ten years later, I ran into his wife by chance. She told me, “Todd, what you did was so helpful. He would never admit it or give you credit—you know that—but he’s like a teddy bear now.”

His friendships got better. His marriage got dramatically better. Everything changed when he finally faced what he’d been running from.

Signs You May Be Experiencing Gaslighting

I want to be thoughtful here because every situation is different. But if you’re experiencing several of these patterns, it’s worth paying attention.

You often think “What’s wrong with me?” after conversations with your partner. You regularly wonder if you’re overreacting or being too sensitive. You find yourself apologizing even when you didn’t do anything wrong.

You’ve started covering up for your partner—lying to friends, family, even your children—because you want them to see your partner in a good light. You feel like you’re walking on eggshells, always bracing for the next explosion.

You feel like you need to be invisible to stay safe. When something goes wrong, it somehow always becomes your fault. You’ve become isolated from people who used to be close to you.

And maybe the biggest sign: you’ve stopped trusting your own gut. That inner voice that used to guide you has gotten quieter and quieter.

The Real Cost of Staying in a Gaslighting Relationship

The price you pay for keeping a relationship stabilized in that kind of toxic stability is enormous. I’m talking about your emotional wellbeing, your physical health, and—if you have children—their wellbeing too.

Because here’s what I’ve learned after 35 years of doing this work: the most important thing you can do for yourself and your children is to be a person with self-esteem. And the most essential part of self-esteem is listening to yourself—listening to your own heart and your own gut.

When you’re in a gaslighting relationship, you lose that. You become disconnected from your own intuition. And without that connection, you’re not really you anymore.

I’ve worked with countless people—men, women, all genders—who were victims of gaslighting. When they finally get out, either by leaving or by the relationship healing, they always say the same thing: “My God, it never was me. It never was me.”

They describe what it’s like to finally feel safe. To just express themselves without feeling like they’re in a minefield. To say something without bracing for it to blow up in their face.

The Path Forward: Whether You Stay or Go

Let me be honest with you: some gaslighting relationships can heal, and some can’t. The difference usually comes down to whether the person doing the gaslighting is willing to look at themselves honestly and take responsibility for their behavior.

When Healing Is Possible

In the relationships I’ve seen heal, two things had to happen. First, the victim of the gaslighting had to recognize what was happening and stop trying to make everything nice when it wasn’t nice. They had to disengage from the habit of smoothing things over and keeping the peace at any cost.

Second, the person doing the gaslighting had to face whatever they were running from. Their shame, their childhood wounds, their own feelings of inadequacy—whatever it was driving the behavior. That’s painful work. Not everyone is willing to do it.

But when both partners are willing, real change is possible. The man from my story is proof of that.

When You Need to Leave

Some relationships can’t be healed from the inside. When the gaslighting person refuses to take any responsibility, when they’re not willing to look at themselves, when every attempt to address the problem becomes another attack on you—sometimes leaving is the only way to heal.

And that’s okay. Leaving isn’t failure. Sometimes leaving is the bravest, healthiest thing you can do.

The First Step, No Matter What

Whether you end up staying or leaving, the first step is the same: find someone you can talk to. Even if—especially if—your partner has isolated you, which many people who gaslight do.

It might be a friend, a family member, or a professional therapist like myself. Someone who can help you get perspective and reconnect with your intuition and your gut.

You may have been brainwashed to think you need to keep everything private. That’s not necessarily true. It isn’t true when you’re dealing with someone who’s hurting you.

Reconnecting with Your Gut: The Real Work of Recovery

Recovery from gaslighting isn’t just about changing your circumstances. It’s about rebuilding trust with yourself. That inner compass that got damaged—it can heal.

Start by noticing when you dismiss your own feelings. When you feel something is off but immediately tell yourself you’re probably wrong, pause. Ask yourself: Is this my genuine intuition speaking, or is this the voice of someone who taught me not to trust myself?

Practice giving weight to your own perceptions. If you remember something a certain way, honor that memory. You’re not crazy. You’re not making things up. Your gut knows things before your mind catches up.

And be patient with yourself. This kind of healing takes time. You didn’t lose trust in yourself overnight, and you won’t rebuild it overnight either.

Trust Your Gut

Here’s what I want you to take away from all of this: your gut is not wrong. If something feels wrong, something probably is wrong.

Gaslighting is common. It’s painful. It’s confusing. But you can get free from it—whether that means your relationship heals or you find the strength to leave.

If this resonates with you, or if you know someone going through this, reach out. Talk to someone. Get the support you deserve.

You are not the problem. You never were.

Thanks for reading. This is Todd Creager, making the world safe for love.

Frequently Asked Questions About Gaslighting

What’s the difference between normal disagreements and gaslighting?

In healthy disagreements, both people can acknowledge each other’s perspective even when they don’t agree. With gaslighting, your reality itself gets denied. It’s not “I see it differently”—it’s “That never happened” or “You’re crazy for thinking that.” The pattern over time erodes your confidence in your own perceptions.

Can someone gaslight without meaning to?

Yes, absolutely. Sometimes gaslighting is conscious and strategic—the person knows exactly what they’re doing. But often it’s unconscious and self-protective. The person genuinely can’t face certain truths about themselves, so they rewrite reality in a way that protects their self-image. The impact on you is the same either way, but understanding this can be helpful in deciding whether the relationship can heal.

How long does it take to recover from a gaslighting relationship?

There’s no standard timeline. I’ve seen people make significant progress in months; others take years to fully rebuild trust with themselves. Factors include how long the gaslighting went on, whether you have support, and whether you’re still in the relationship. The key is being patient with yourself and getting professional help if you need it.

What if I’m worried I might be the one gaslighting?

The fact that you’re asking this question is actually a good sign. People who gaslight consistently rarely wonder if they’re the problem—that self-reflection is what they’re avoiding. That said, all of us can have moments of defensiveness where we deny or minimize things. If you’re concerned about this pattern in yourself, working with a therapist can help you develop more self-awareness and healthier ways of handling conflict.

About the Author

Todd Creager, LCSW, LMFT has spent over 35 years helping couples and individuals heal from the pain of betrayal, addiction, trauma, and relationship dysfunction. He specializes in infidelity recovery and helping partners rebuild trust and intimacy. His approach combines clinical expertise with genuine compassion, creating a safe space where people can face difficult truths and do the hard work of healing.

Feeling like you might be the victim of verbal abuse and/or gaslighting?

GET YOUR CHECKLIST HERE!

Why Cheating Partners Use Gaslighting to Hide The Truth

by Leave a Comment

When Infidelity Meets Gaslighting: Why Your Gut Keeps Telling You Something’s Wrong (And Why They Keep Saying It’s Not)

Here’s what throws most people: they think the pain of discovering infidelity is the worst part. After 30+ years working with couples, I can tell you that’s rarely true.

The worst part?

It’s usually the months—sometimes years—before discovery, when you knew something was off but kept getting told you were imagining it.

TL;DR: Unfaithful partners often use gaslighting tactics to avoid facing consequences and their own shame. Common strategies include denying obvious behavioral changes, minimizing or rewriting events (the “drip method”), reversing blame onto you, and using anger as a distraction.

If you constantly find yourself asking “Am I overreacting?” or “What’s wrong with me?” around your partner, you may be experiencing gaslighting alongside infidelity.

But here’s what most people miss:

→ Gaslighting during affairs causes its own trauma symptoms before you even discover the betrayal

→ Most unfaithful partners aren’t consciously evil—they’re in self-protective mode (which doesn’t make it less harmful)

→ The manipulation isn’t just about hiding the affair; it’s about avoiding the shame of being caught “like a little kid”

Let me be clear about scope here:

I’m focusing on the more common scenario where gaslighting emerges from self-protection rather than malicious intent.

Yes, sometimes gaslighting is intentional and calculating. But in my practice, I see far more people who are unconsciously employing these tactics because facing reality feels unbearable. That distinction matters for recovery, though both cause real harm to you.

The Mechanics of Denial: When Obvious Changes Become “Your Problem”

Your partner’s behavior has shifted. They’re staying later at work. They’ve suddenly changed their phone password after 15 years together. They’re less interested in sex with you, or weirdly, they’re suddenly more interested. The emotional temperature in your home has changed—you can feel it.

You bring it up. And then you hear: “You’re making this up. You’re overreacting. Why are you always so suspicious? My God, we’ve been married 20 years—don’t you trust me?”

This is denying the obvious, and it’s one of the first tactics unfaithful partners use. Here’s the reality check most therapists won’t tell you: the person doing this has extremely high motivation to keep things exactly as they are. They don’t want their life to blow up. They don’t want to lose their family, their reputation, their comfortable setup. And they definitely don’t want to face the shame that comes with being exposed.

So they deny. Even when the evidence is stacking up. Even when your gut is screaming at you.

What this actually does to you: You start questioning your own perception. You think “Maybe I am being paranoid.” You wonder if you need to work on your trust issues. You might even start researching whether you have an anxiety disorder. Meanwhile, the gaslighting is creating its own trauma symptoms—disorientation, self-doubt, a constant feeling of “what’s wrong with me?”

If you’re asking yourself that question repeatedly around your partner, pay attention. That’s your first warning sign.

In practice: I’ve worked with betrayed partners who sought individual therapy before discovering the affair, convinced they had a mental health problem. Their therapists sometimes reinforced this because the therapist didn’t have the full picture. The betrayed partner did have anxiety and instability—but it was a rational response to being manipulated, not a preexisting condition.

The Drip Method: How Truth Gets Parceled Out to Minimize Damage

Let’s say they’ve been caught, or partially caught. Now comes the minimizing and rewriting of events.

“Look, I didn’t have sex with them, so what’s the big deal? I was just flirting.”

Or maybe they admit to one encounter: “I had a weak night. I drank too much. It happened once. I’m so sorry.”

Then you find the texts. Months of texts. Warming each other up for three months before that “one weak night.” Maybe they only had physical contact once, but there was significant emotional connection and planning. Or maybe—and this is extremely common—there were multiple physical encounters they’re not mentioning.

This is what we call the drip method in couples therapy. They give you just enough truth to seem like they’re being honest, while withholding the parts that make them look worse. Sometimes they’ll reframe their role entirely: “She really came on strong with me. I’m a rescuer—I just couldn’t say no.”

Then you discover texts where they were doing plenty of their own pursuing. They weren’t a passive victim of someone’s aggressive pursuit. They were an active, willing participant.

Why this matters: Each time you discover another piece they withheld, you experience the trauma of discovery again. It’s not one betrayal—it becomes multiple betrayals. The lying about the lying creates its own damage, separate from the affair itself.

The resource reality: If you’re in couples therapy and your partner is drip-feeding information, I tell clients to set a deadline. “You have one week to tell me everything. After that, each new revelation I discover on my own significantly reduces the chance we can recover from this.” Most people need consequences to break through the self-protection.

Reversing Blame: When Your Legitimate Concerns Become Your “Issues”

This one does real psychological damage. Your intuition kicks in—you know something’s wrong. You raise concerns. And suddenly, you’re the problem.

“You’re crazy. You’re insecure. You’re imagining things.”

Or they go deeper into your history: “You grew up with a mother who cheated on your father. Now you think everyone cheats. You grew up in a family where nobody trusted each other, so you can’t trust me.”

I’ve had clients where the unfaithful partner suggested the betrayed partner “get some therapy” for their trust issues. While actively cheating. The audacity is stunning, but remember—this is self-protection at work. They can’t face what they’re doing, so they make it about your supposed deficiencies.

Another version: “You kept pushing me away. You rejected me sexually over and over. What was I supposed to do?”

What they leave out: maybe you were pulling away because they stopped being emotionally present. They stopped listening. They stopped showing up for you in ways that make you feel safe enough to be sexually open. So they created the distance, then used that distance to justify betraying you, then blamed you for the distance.

When this crosses into danger territory: If you find yourself changing your behavior to avoid your partner’s accusations—if you’re walking on eggshells or suppressing valid concerns because you don’t want to seem “paranoid”—that’s a sign the gaslighting is working. Your emotional safety is being compromised.

What recovery requires: The unfaithful partner has to stop making you responsible for their choices. Full stop. They can acknowledge that problems existed in the relationship. They can own that they felt rejected or disconnected. But they have to own that cheating was their choice, made by them, for their own reasons. Until they can do that, recovery isn’t possible.

Anger as Distraction: The Strategic Explosion

Some unfaithful partners have figured out that anger shuts down conversation really effectively—especially if you’re someone who responds to anger with fear or withdrawal.

You bring up your concerns. They explode. “I can’t believe you’re accusing me of this! After everything I do for this family! I work my ass off and this is how you treat me?”

Suddenly you’re backing down, apologizing for bringing it up, just trying to avoid their wrath. The topic gets dropped. Your intuitive accusations get silenced. And they’ve successfully distracted from the real issue.

This isn’t always calculated. Sometimes it’s an automatic defensive response. But calculated or not, it’s still a manipulation that keeps you from getting answers you deserve.

The pattern to watch for: If every time you raise certain topics your partner becomes explosively angry, and you find yourself dropping those topics to keep the peace, that’s a red flag. Healthy relationships can handle difficult conversations without one partner using emotional volatility to control the dialogue.

What You Need to Know About Recovery (The Part Most Articles Skip)

Here’s what I see after working with hundreds of couples dealing with healing from infidelity and gaslighting:

Recovery is possible, but only if the gaslighting stops. And I mean completely stops. The person who betrayed has to move from self-protection mode into full accountability. That’s a painful transition—it means facing their shame, their choices, their role in hurting you. Many people can’t make that shift without professional help.

Your symptoms are real, but they’re rational responses to an irrational situation. You’re not crazy. You’re not overreacting. Your nervous system is responding appropriately to a threat. When someone you love is lying to you and making you doubt your reality, anxiety and instability make perfect sense.

The gaslighting often reveals deeper issues that led to the affair. People who can’t face their shame about cheating usually can’t face other uncomfortable truths about themselves. The inability to be accountable in one area tends to show up in other areas too. That’s what needs addressing in therapy.

You’ll know they’re serious about change when they stop defending and start being curious. When they stop explaining why you’re wrong to be upset and start asking what you need to feel safe again. When they stop minimizing and start being transparent, even when the truth makes them look bad.

If You’re Reading This and Recognizing Your Situation

Step out of the self-blame. If you’ve been asking yourself “What’s wrong with me?” or “Am I overreacting?” repeatedly, the problem isn’t you. Your instincts are working fine—they’re being deliberately or unconsciously undermined.

You’re not paranoid for noticing changes. You’re not insecure for wanting honesty. You’re not demanding for expecting your partner to face reality with you instead of making you question yours.

The path forward requires both people developing what I call emotional muscles—the capacity to stay present with pain, to face uncomfortable truths, to be curious about each other’s experience without immediately defending. The unfaithful partner needs to build the muscle to tolerate their shame without deflecting it onto you. You need support to rebuild trust in your own perceptions.

Professional help matters here. These patterns run deep, and untangling gaslighting from infidelity from legitimate relationship issues requires skilled guidance. You can’t do this alone, and you shouldn’t have to.

This is Todd Creager, making the world safe for love.

About the Author: Todd Creager has worked with couples navigating infidelity recovery for over 30 years. His approach emphasizes creating safety for both partners while maintaining accountability, with particular expertise in helping betrayed partners rebuild trust in their own perceptions after gaslighting. These insights come from direct clinical experience with couples at various stages of recovery, from immediate crisis through long-term rebuilding.

Methodology Note: The examples throughout this article come from composite cases—patterns observed repeatedly across multiple clients with identifying details altered to protect confidentiality. The tactics described represent the most common gaslighting strategies observed in practice when infidelity is present, documented across hundreds of couple sessions.

The Infidelity First Aid Kit

Go From Hurting to Happy Today...

When you click the button below, you’ll gain access to my exclusive Healing Infidelity From The Inside Out Guide.

It’s a powerful resource that will support you every step of the way, providing practical guidance and actionable steps toward finding peace within yourself.

healing infidelity from the inside out mock up
CLICK HERE TO GET STARTED NOW

Why You Shut Down During Arguments (And It’s Not Because You Don’t Care)

by Leave a Comment

This post is about something I see almost every week in my therapy office.

A couple sits on my couch, and one person goes quiet. Not the angry quiet—the disappearing kind. Their chest sinks, their voice gets small, and their partner thinks they’ve checked out. But here’s what’s really happening: their nervous system just hit the shame button, and they’re not avoiding the conversation—they’re drowning in it.

TL;DR: When you shut down during conflict, it’s usually not apathy or stonewalling—it’s a shame response. Your body is trying to protect you from feeling like a bad, wrong person. This article shows you how to recognize when shame takes over and how to stay present for yourself and your partner without collapsing.

But here’s what most people miss:

→ Shame shutdown looks like “not caring” to your partner, but it’s actually a sign you care so much that your nervous system can’t handle the perceived threat of being “bad”

→ Over-apologizing is often a shame response, not real accountability—and it doesn’t actually help repair

→ You can’t talk your way out of a shame spiral; you have to work with your body first

I’ve spent over 30 years working with couples, and I can tell you that shame-driven shutdown is one of the most misunderstood reasons we disconnect.

It gets mistaken for indifference, avoidance, or not trying. But I’m going to show you what’s really going on and how to work with it.

What Shame Actually Does to Your Nervous System

When shame hits, you’re not making a choice to shut down. Your body is doing what it learned to do, probably when you were young. Maybe you had a parent who shamed you, or you got the message that your feelings were too much, or you learned that being visible when you messed up was dangerous.

In my practice, I use EMDR (Eye Movement Desensitization and Reprocessing) to help people heal from the original shame wounds. But before we get there, you need to understand what’s happening in the moment.

Your nervous system has three basic responses to threat: fight, flight, or freeze. Shame triggers that freeze response—what we call the shutdown reaction. Your chest literally collapses. Blood flow to your prefrontal cortex (the thinking part of your brain) decreases. You feel small, young, and wrong.

I worked with a woman named Cheryl—names changed for privacy—who would go completely silent whenever her husband Jerry expressed disappointment. Not regular quiet. Gone. Jerry would feel abandoned, which made him push harder, which made Cheryl shut down more. Classic cycle.

Here’s what was happening: Cheryl’s mother had shamed her growing up. Any mistake meant you were a bad person. So when Jerry was upset, Cheryl’s 6-year-old self took over. That part of her believed she was fundamentally wrong, and the only option was to disappear.

The difference between guilt and shame matters here. Guilt says “I did something bad.” Shame says “I am bad.” Guilt can actually be useful—it helps you recognize when you need to repair something. But shame? Shame makes you unavailable because you’re not arguing about what happened; you’re trying to survive the feeling that you’re inherently wrong.

How to Know When Shame Has Taken Over

Pay attention to your body. Shame has a specific signature, and once you recognize it, you can start working with it instead of being hijacked by it.

In sessions, I ask people to notice:

→ Where does your chest go? (Usually it collapses inward)

→ What happens to your voice? (Gets quiet or disappears)

→ How big do you feel? (Small, young, like a child)

→ What’s the thought? (Usually something all-or-nothing: “I mess everything up” or “It’s all my fault”)

One client told me, “Every time we argue, I feel like I’m 6 years old and I just want to hide in my room.” That’s exactly it. You’re not actually 6, but that’s the age that shows up when shame takes over.

The language of shame is black and white. You’ll hear yourself think:

→ “I always do this”

→ “I’m the reason we’re not okay”

→ “I mess everything up”

→ “I can’t do anything right”

That “all or nothing” thinking is a red flag. Your adult self knows that relationships are nuanced. But shame doesn’t do nuance. It deals in absolutes.

Why Your Partner Thinks You Don’t Care (And What’s Really Happening)

This is where it gets tricky. From the outside, shame shutdown looks like:

→ Not caring

→ Giving up

→ Avoiding responsibility

→ Not being present

So your partner feels abandoned. They think you’re not trying, or you’re checked out, or you don’t value the relationship enough to engage.

But from the inside, you’re not checked out—you’re overwhelmed. You care so much that your system can’t handle the possibility of being seen as wrong or bad. The shame is so big that your nervous system shuts you down to protect you.

I’ve seen couples where the betrayed partner thinks the person who cheated is “stonewalling” when they go quiet. But often, what I’m seeing is shame collapse. The person who betrayed is flooded with “I’m a terrible person” and their body literally can’t stay present with that feeling and their partner’s pain at the same time.

This doesn’t excuse the behavior. But understanding it changes how we work with it.

The Moment That Changed Everything for Cheryl

We worked on helping Cheryl recognize the exact moment shame kicked in. Not after—right when it started. She learned to notice that chest collapse, that voice disappearing, that young feeling.

One time, Jerry came home frustrated about something minor—I think dishes or plans that got mixed up. Cheryl felt the familiar pull to collapse. But this time, instead of spiraling, she paused.

She placed her hand on her heart—something we’d practiced in session—and whispered to herself, “You’re safe now.” Just that. She felt her feet on the ground. She took three breaths. And she imagined her adult self stepping forward to sit next to that 6-year-old part.

The young part was still there, still scared. But Cheryl wasn’t fused with it anymore. She could be present for that part while also being present for Jerry.

She walked over and sat beside him. Didn’t explain. Didn’t apologize. Just sat close and breathed.

Jerry told me later, “That was the first time I felt like she stayed. Like she didn’t disappear into shame.”

What Actually Repairs Connection (Hint: It’s Not What You Think)

Most people think they need to apologize their way back to connection. But over-apologizing from a shame state doesn’t work. It actually keeps you small.

“I’m sorry, I’m sorry, I’m so sorry” from a collapsed chest isn’t repair. It’s appeasement. Your partner can feel the difference.

Real repair comes from presence. Not explanation. Not making yourself smaller. Just staying.

Your partner doesn’t want the shame-ridden version of you. They want you whole, grounded, and available. They want to know you can stay with them and stay with yourself at the same time.

Here’s what I tell clients: You don’t have to have the perfect words. You don’t have to explain everything. You just have to stay in the room—emotionally and physically.

The Practice That Changes Shame Shutdown

When you notice shame coming up, try this four-step process. I’ve used this with hundreds of people, and it works when you actually practice it (not just when you’re already in the middle of a meltdown):

1. Name it Say to yourself, “This is shame. This isn’t the truth about who I am.”

Just naming it creates a little space. You’re not the shame; you’re noticing the shame. That’s your adult self coming online.

2. Notice it in your body Where do you feel it? Chest? Throat? Stomach? Don’t try to change it. Just notice. “My chest feels tight and small.” “My throat feels closed.” “I want to curl up.”

3. Regulate This is where you work with your nervous system directly:

→ Put your hand on your heart or your belly

→ Feel your feet on the ground

→ Take three breaths where your exhale is longer than your inhale (this activates your parasympathetic nervous system)

→ Look around the room and name what you see (this brings you into the present)

4. Reconnect Once you’re a little more regulated, you can reconnect. Sometimes that’s sitting close to your partner. Sometimes it’s making eye contact. Sometimes it’s just saying, “I need a minute, but I’m here.”

The version of you that can do this—that can notice shame, work with it, and stay present—that’s the version your relationship needs.

What to Do When Your Partner Is the One Shutting Down

If you’re the partner watching someone collapse into shame, this is painful. You feel alone. You might get angry or push harder to get them to respond. That’s normal.

But here’s what helps: Recognize that their shutdown isn’t about not caring. It’s about caring so much that their system gets overwhelmed.

You can say something like, “I can see this is hard for you. I’m not going anywhere. Take the time you need.” Give them space to regulate without abandoning them or making them wrong for the response.

Some people need a few minutes. Some need an hour. You can ask, “What do you need right now?” But don’t interrogate. Don’t make them explain why they’re shutting down while they’re in it. That just piles shame on top of shame.

When they come back, acknowledge that they came back. “Thank you for staying with this” or “I’m glad you’re here” goes a long way.

The Long-Term Work: Healing the Original Shame

What I’ve described above is about managing shame in the moment. But the deeper work is about healing the original wounds that created the shame response in the first place.

This is where EMDR comes in. In my practice, I help people process the early experiences that taught them they were bad, wrong, or too much. When you heal those wounds, the shame response doesn’t get triggered as easily.

I’ve seen people who couldn’t stay in a room during conflict learn to stay present, even when things are hard. Not because they’re forcing themselves, but because their nervous system isn’t interpreting disappointment or frustration as a threat to their fundamental worth.

This takes time. It takes professional support. But it’s possible, and I’ve watched thousands of people do it.

Your Relationship Needs You Whole, Not Small

I want you to remember this: connection doesn’t come from erasing yourself. It comes from showing up as fully as you can, even when it’s hard.

When shame tells you to disappear, your relationship suffers. Not because your partner needs you to be perfect, but because they need you to be present.

You don’t have to have it all figured out. You don’t have to never feel shame. But you can learn to recognize when it’s taking over and bring yourself back.

That’s the work that changes relationships. Not perfect communication. Not never messing up. Just the ability to stay—with yourself and with your partner—even when it’s uncomfortable.

If you’re reading this and recognizing yourself, know that you’re not alone. Shame-driven shutdown is one of the most common patterns I see. And it’s workable. You can learn to stay present. Your relationship can heal.

About the Author

I’m Todd Creager, a licensed clinical social worker and marriage and family therapist. I’ve been working with couples for over 30 years, helping them heal from infidelity, rebuild connection, and break free from patterns that keep them stuck. I specialize in using EMDR to help people heal from shame and trauma, and I’ve worked with thousands of individuals and couples who thought their relationships were beyond repair. Most of them were wrong about that.

The insights in this article come from decades of sitting with people in their hardest moments and watching what actually works to help them reconnect. If you’re struggling with shame in your relationship, there’s help available. You don’t have to figure this out alone.

Watch the video and get personal insights from Todd on why you’re shutting down during conflict

When Silence Becomes Punishment: Why Withdrawal Hurts More Than Words

by Leave a Comment

When Silence Becomes Punishment: Why Withdrawal Hurts More Than Words

Sometimes the most painful thing in a relationship isn’t what gets said. It’s what doesn’t get said. The cold silence. The turned back. The partner who’s physically there but emotionally gone.

You know what I’m talking about.

You’ve been hurt, so you pull back. You get cool. You don’t respond right away. Maybe you tell yourself it’s not intentional, that you just need space. But here’s what most people don’t realize: that quiet withdrawal?

It’s often a cry for closeness. A way of saying “I’m hurting” without knowing how to say it directly.

What you need to know right now: Silent withdrawal is usually self-protection, not revenge. But to your partner, it feels like punishment.

The good news? You can repair connection without saying a word—and sometimes that’s more powerful than any conversation.

But here’s what most people miss:

→ Staying physically present (even when you’re still upset) sends a completely different message than leaving the room

→ Your partner can’t fight for you if you’ve disappeared—emotionally or physically

→ The body repairs faster than words sometimes, and that’s okay

I’m Todd Creager. For over 40 years, I’ve worked with couples who are stuck in these silent standoffs. What I’ve learned is that most partners don’t want to punish—they want to feel safe again.

And there are ways to signal “I’m still here” without having to explain, defend, or solve anything in that moment.

What’s Really Happening When You Withdraw

Here’s the pattern I see constantly in my practice. One partner says or does something that hurts. Maybe they were dismissive. Maybe they got defensive when you tried to share something vulnerable. Maybe they humiliated you in front of others.

Your first instinct? Protect yourself. So you withdraw. You become unavailable. You give off the vibe: “You don’t get access to me until I feel better.”

I had a client tell me once: “I didn’t slam doors or scream. I just made him feel the way I felt—small and invisible.”

What she wanted, desperately, was for him to fight for her. To notice. To come after her and make it right. But all he did was pull further away until she tried something completely different.

The thing is, she wasn’t trying to be mean. Neither are you when you do this. You’re trying to survive the pain. But withdrawal creates a terrible cycle: You pull away to protect yourself. Your partner feels punished and pulls away too. Now you’re both alone, and nobody knows how to get back.

The Real Story: Ken and Terry

Let me tell you about Ken and Terry because their story shows up in some version in almost every couple I work with.

Whenever Terry brought up something emotional, Ken would do what a lot of partners do. He’d shoot holes in what she was saying. Try to give his reasons why she wasn’t correct. He’d get defensive, basically.

Terry eventually got so tired of being minimized that she just stopped. She stopped trying to connect. She stopped bringing things up. She became what I call “politely distant.”

When they came to see me, Terry said, “I just don’t try anymore.” And Ken said, “I feel all alone in this relationship.”

Ken didn’t quite understand what was happening. There were a lot of things he did well in the relationship—like a lot of partners, he wasn’t all bad. He just wasn’t aware of the pain his defensiveness created. And Terry wasn’t so tuned into the pain Ken felt when she pushed him away.

See, her pushing away was self-protection. His defensiveness was self-protection too. Two people trying to protect themselves, both ending up hurt.

The Moment Everything Changed

After we worked together for a bit, something happened. They had another fight. Terry caught herself at the exact moment she wanted to punish Ken by withdrawing.

Instead of icing him out completely, she did something brave. She sat on the couch near him. Back turned—because she was still struggling, still hurt—but closer. She didn’t say a word. She just didn’t leave.

Later she told me it was the hardest thing she’d ever done. Just sitting there, still upset, still not ready to talk, but present.

That night, Ken reached out. They had their first honest, soft moment in weeks, maybe months.

Why Physical Presence Matters More Than You Think

We’ve been taught that conflict needs to be solved through talking. That if you’re not communicating verbally, you’re not fixing anything.

But sometimes connection starts in the body first.

The silent cold shoulder feels like control. Silent presence feels like repair.

I’m going to say that again because it’s important: The silent cold shoulder feels like control, but silent presence feels like repair.

When you can stay in the room—not to punish, but to witness—you tell your partner something crucial: “I’m still here. I’m still open.” That’s where healing begins.

Your nervous system speaks to your partner’s nervous system. When you leave the room or turn away completely, their nervous system reads: “Threat. Abandonment. Danger.” When you stay present, even silently, their nervous system gets a different message: “Still safe. Still connected. We’ll get through this.”

What This Looks Like in Real Life

You don’t have to be perfect at this. You don’t have to fake being okay when you’re not. Here’s what I mean by “silent presence”:

Scenario 1: After a fight in the kitchen

→ Old pattern: Storm off to the bedroom, close the door, don’t come out for hours

→ New pattern: Move to the living room, sit where your partner can see you, let yourself calm down there

Scenario 2: When your partner says something dismissive

→ Old pattern: Give them the cold shoulder for days, minimal responses, make them feel your displeasure

→ New pattern: Take space if you need it, but stay in proximity. Sit in the same room reading. Be near them during dinner even if you’re quiet.

Scenario 3: When you’re hurt but can’t find words

→ Old pattern: Shut down completely, refuse touch or eye contact, leave them guessing

→ New pattern: Let your body stay soft even when your words aren’t ready. A hand on their shoulder. Sitting close on the couch. Small signals that say “I’m upset, but I’m not gone.”

Why This Works When Talking Fails

I’ve seen couples talk themselves in circles for hours. They explain, defend, counter-argue, explain again. Both people leave exhausted and more disconnected than before.

Here’s what I’ve learned from 40+ years of working with couples: Your body can say “I’m committed to us” faster than your mouth can sometimes.

When you’re hurt, your thinking brain isn’t working right anyway. You’re flooded. Your partner is flooded. More words usually means more misunderstanding.

But if you can stay near each other? If you can let your body communicate “I’m not abandoning you even though I’m upset”? You’re doing repair work without needing perfect words.

The Common Mistakes People Make

Mistake 1: Confusing presence with pretending you’re okay

Staying present doesn’t mean acting like nothing happened. Terry stayed on the couch with her back turned. She was clearly still upset. But she was there.

Mistake 2: Using physical presence as a manipulation

Some people stay in the room but make sure their partner feels their anger. Heavy sighs. Eye rolls. That’s not presence—that’s proximity punishment. Your partner can tell the difference.

Mistake 3: Expecting instant results

Terry told me sitting on that couch was the hardest thing she’d ever done. It won’t feel natural at first. Your instinct is to leave, to protect, to punish a little. That’s normal. You’re rewiring decades of patterns.

Mistake 4: Thinking this replaces all verbal communication

This isn’t about never talking. You’ll still need conversations. But those conversations go better when you’ve stayed connected through the worst moments.

What Your Partner Experiences When You Stay

I ask betrayed partners and hurt partners all the time: “What does it feel like when your partner withdraws?”

They say things like:

→ “Like I don’t matter”

→ “Like I’m being erased”

→ “Like they’ve already left the relationship mentally”

→ “Terrifying—I don’t know if they’re coming back”

Then I ask: “What does it feel like when they stay present, even when upset?”

Completely different answers:

→ “Like we’re going to be okay”

→ “Like they’re still fighting for us”

→ “Like there’s hope”

→ “Safe—even though we’re struggling”

Your partner isn’t reading your mind. They’re reading your body, your proximity, your availability. When you stay, even silently, you’re saying something important.

How to Start Practicing Silent Presence

Next time you want to pull away, ask yourself: “What do I really want right now?”

If the honest answer is “I want to punish them” or “I want them to feel what I feel,” that’s information. That’s hurt talking. You can acknowledge that feeling without acting on it.

If the honest answer is “I want to feel safe” or “I need space to calm down,” then try this:

Step 1: Take the space you need, but keep your partner in sight. Move to another part of the room instead of another floor.

Step 2: Let your body relax as much as you can. Uncross your arms. Soften your shoulders. You’re still upset—that’s okay—but your body can signal “I’m not dangerous to you right now.”

Step 3: When you’re ready (even if it’s just 1%), do something small. Sit near them like Terry did with Ken. Make eye contact for a second. Touch their hand as you walk by.

You’re not saying “everything’s fine.” You’re saying “I’m still here.”

What About When Your Partner Is the One Withdrawing?

This is painful. You’re on the receiving end of the silent treatment, and it feels terrible.

Here’s what not to do: Chase them down demanding they talk. Force proximity. Get angry about their anger.

Here’s what can help: Give them space, but stay nearby. Say something like “I can see you’re upset. I’m going to be in the living room when you’re ready.” Then actually be there.

Don’t disappear into your phone. Don’t leave the house. Be genuinely available.

Sometimes the person who’s withdrawing needs to see that you’re not going anywhere. That their silence isn’t driving you away. That’s what Ken did for Terry that night—he was there when she was ready.

The Pattern That Changes Everything

I’ve watched this pattern transform relationships:

Old cycle: Fight → Withdraw → Partner withdraws → Both feel abandoned → Resentment builds → Next fight is worse

New cycle: Fight → Feel the urge to withdraw → Choose presence instead → Partner feels safe → Small repair moment → Next fight is easier

You don’t fix everything in one night. But you stop making things worse. And you start building a different habit—a habit of staying instead of leaving.

When Silent Presence Isn’t Enough

Look, I teach verbal repair tools too. Sometimes you need words. Sometimes you need to apologize clearly, or hear your partner’s pain, or work through something complex.

But what I see couples overlook constantly is that the nonverbal repair tools can be more important. They create the safety that makes verbal repair possible.

If you’ve been in a pattern of withdrawal and punishment for months or years, sitting on that couch with your back turned might be 90% of the work in that moment. The conversation can come later, when you’re both regulated.

Why This Feels So Hard

Staying present when you’re hurt goes against your survival instinct. Your body wants to flee or fight. Silent presence is neither—it’s something more difficult. It’s staying vulnerable when every cell in your body is screaming to protect yourself.

That’s why Terry said it was the hardest thing she’d ever done.

But here’s what I’ve learned: The hard thing is also the thing that works. The easy thing—withdrawing, shutting down, giving the cold shoulder—feels like self-care in the moment. But it destroys connection over time.

The hard thing—staying present, staying soft, staying available—feels scary and vulnerable. But it builds the relationship you actually want.

What Happens Next

You’re not going to get this perfect. You’ll have fights where you still withdraw. Where you still give the cold shoulder. That’s part of being human.

But if you can catch yourself even once a month and choose presence instead? You’re changing the pattern. You’re teaching your nervous system and your partner’s nervous system that conflict doesn’t mean abandonment.

That one moment on the couch changed everything for Ken and Terry. Not because it solved their communication issues overnight. But because it showed both of them that connection was still possible, even in pain.

The Real Question

So the next time you feel that urge to pull away, to get cool, to make your partner feel your hurt through your absence, ask yourself:

“What do I really want right now?”

If the answer is “I want us to be okay,” then try something different. Try staying. Try letting your body say “I’m still here” when your words can’t.

Sit near them. Let your presence speak. Don’t leave the room. Don’t leave the relationship, even for a moment.

Because sometimes the most powerful thing you can say is nothing at all—as long as you’re still there to not say it.

About Todd Creager: For over 40 years, I’ve helped couples identify the subtle disconnect patterns that keep love at arm’s length.

I guide them back to intimacy using both verbal and nonverbal repair tools—because sometimes the body knows how to heal before the words come.

If you’re struggling with withdrawal patterns in your relationship, you’re not alone, and there are ways back to connection that don’t require perfect communication. They just require presence.

What if your next argument could bring you closer instead of driving you apart?


Learn how in Todd Creager’s Loving & Connecting Masterclass.
Lifetime access. Real results.

Say Yes to a Better Relationship

Why You Freeze During Conflict (And How to Stop)

by Leave a Comment

When Your Body Shuts Down During Conflict: Why You Freeze and How to Stay Present Without Saying a Word

You’re in the middle of a difficult conversation with your partner. Their voice rises slightly, maybe there’s frustration or disappointment in their tone. And then something happens inside you—your mind goes blank, your body feels heavy, and you can’t access words even if you wanted to. You’re still sitting there, but you’ve gone somewhere else entirely.

If this sounds familiar, you’re not broken. You’re experiencing what I call the freeze response, and I’ve watched it play out in my office for over 40 years of working with couples. What looks like indifference or rejection to your partner is actually your nervous system trying to keep you safe from emotional overwhelm.

Here’s what you need to know right now: Freezing isn’t a character flaw or a relationship death sentence. It’s a survival mechanism. But here’s what most people miss—you don’t need to force yourself to talk your way out of it, and your partner doesn’t need to get louder to pull you back. There’s a completely different way through this that has nothing to do with finding the right words.

The bigger issue? Most couples don’t understand what’s really happening when one person goes blank during conflict. They think it’s about not caring enough to engage, when it’s actually about caring so much that the intensity becomes unbearable. That misunderstanding creates a painful cycle where one partner pursues harder and the other retreats deeper.

In this article, I’m going to walk you through what freezing actually is (it’s not what you think), why it happens to some people and not others, and most importantly, how to stay present in your body even when your words disappear. I’m also going to show partners of people who freeze how to respond in ways that help rather than make things worse.

This isn’t about fixing yourself or your partner. It’s about understanding how your nervous systems work and learning to work with them instead of against them.

What’s Actually Happening When You Freeze

Let me tell you about a client I’ll call Martine. She described freezing as “like my soul leaves the room. I’m here, but I’m not.” I’ve heard some version of this from many clients over the years. That absence—that’s what their partners feel most acutely.

Her husband Larry would get expressive when he was frustrated or disappointed. Not yelling, not aggressive, just more animated. And every single time, Martine would shut down. Her eyes would go distant, her body would still, her voice would simply stop. And the more she retreated, the more desperate Larry became to reach her. He’d talk more, ask more questions, try harder to connect. Which only pushed her further away.

This is the pattern I see again and again. The person who freezes isn’t choosing withdrawal. Their nervous system has made the choice for them.

When you freeze, your body is responding to perceived threat the same way it would if you were facing physical danger. Except the danger isn’t physical—it’s emotional intensity that feels too big to handle. Your system essentially says “I can’t fight this, I can’t run from it, so I’m going to shut down and wait for it to pass.”

Here’s what’s happening physiologically: Your heart rate might actually slow down (different from the fight-or-flight response where it speeds up). Blood flow redirects away from your extremities. Your thinking brain goes offline. You might feel numb or disconnected from your body. Time might feel strange—either moving very slowly or in a blur.

None of this is conscious. You’re not deciding to check out. Your body is trying to protect you from what it perceives as overwhelming emotional flooding.

Why Some People Freeze and Others Don’t

The freeze response usually has roots in your history. Maybe you grew up in a home where conflict was scary—loud voices, unpredictability, or worse. Maybe you learned early that speaking up made things worse, not better. Maybe you were punished for expressing emotions, so you learned to make yourself very small and very quiet.

When you’re young and truly powerless in a situation, freezing can be adaptive. It helps you survive. The problem is that your nervous system doesn’t always update its threat assessment as you grow. So even in adult relationships where you’re safe and have choices, that old wiring can kick in.

I’ve worked with clients who had no obvious trauma but still freeze. Sometimes it’s about temperament—some people are naturally more sensitive to emotional intensity. Their threshold for overwhelm is simply lower, and that’s not a failing. It’s just how their system is calibrated.

What matters more than why you freeze is recognizing that it’s happening and learning to work with it.

The Real Cost of Freezing (And It’s Not What You Think)

People often think the problem with freezing is that you can’t resolve the conflict in that moment. That’s true, but it’s not the real damage.

The real cost is that your partner experiences your freeze as absence. As rejection. As proof that you don’t care enough to stay engaged. They can’t see your nervous system shutting down to protect you. They can only see you disappearing right in front of them.

And here’s the painful irony—you’re often freezing precisely because you care so much. Because the relationship matters so deeply that the possibility of rupture feels unbearable. Because you don’t want to say the wrong thing or make it worse. So you say nothing at all.

I tell couples this all the time: the opposite of connection isn’t conflict. It’s absence. You can have conflict and still feel connected if both people stay emotionally present. But when one person goes absent, even if they’re physically in the room, that’s when the real disconnection happens.

What Doesn’t Work (Stop Doing These Things)

If you’re the person who freezes, here’s what won’t help:

Forcing yourself to keep talking when you’ve gone blank. That usually comes out wrong or feels fake, and your partner can sense it.

Beating yourself up for freezing. That just adds shame on top of overwhelm, which makes you more likely to freeze next time.

Promising you’ll do better next time without changing anything about how you respond to your nervous system.

If you’re the partner of someone who freezes, here’s what makes it worse:

Getting louder or more insistent. I know you’re trying to reach them, but intensity is exactly what triggered the shutdown. More intensity won’t bring them back.

Interpreting their freeze as not caring. I understand that’s how it feels, but that interpretation keeps you both stuck.

Demanding they explain themselves in the moment. Their thinking brain is offline. They literally can’t access explanations when they’re frozen.

How to Stay Present When Words Won’t Come

Now here’s what actually works. I’m going to tell you what I taught Martin, and what changed everything for her and Larry.

I asked Martin to try something different the next time she felt herself starting to freeze. Instead of disappearing completely, she was to do these specific things:

Press her feet firmly into the floor. This is grounding. When you freeze, you often go numb and lose connection with your body. Feeling the solid floor under your feet brings you back into physical sensation.

Hold something warm—a cup of tea, a mug of coffee, even just warm water. The temperature gives your nervous system something to focus on besides the emotional intensity. You’re giving it a different kind of input.

Place one hand on your heart. This is both grounding and self-soothing. You’re literally giving yourself the comfort your system is seeking.

Look at your partner. Even if you can’t speak, maintain eye contact. Let them see that you’re trying to stay present.

Martine did exactly this. She felt herself starting to shut down during a conversation with Larry. She pressed her feet into the floor, grabbed her tea, put her hand on her heart, and kept her eyes on him. She didn’t say a single word.

And Larry noticed. He told me later, “That was the first time I felt like you stayed even when you couldn’t talk.”

That’s the breakthrough. You don’t have to perform connection through words. You just have to allow connection through presence.

The Three-Minute Practice That Rewires Your Freeze Response

Here’s what I teach people who freeze: you’re not going to talk your way out of this pattern. You’re going to feel your way out.

Between conversations with your partner, practice this on your own:

Sit quietly and think about a moment when you typically freeze. Don’t try to solve anything. Just notice what happens in your body. Where do you feel it? Does your chest get tight? Does your throat close? Do your hands go cold?

Then do the grounding practices I described above. Feet on floor. Something warm to hold. Hand on heart. Breathe slowly—in for four counts, out for six counts. That longer exhale tells your nervous system it’s safe to relax.

Do this for just three minutes. You’re teaching your body that you can feel activation without completely shutting down. You’re building what I call your emotional muscle—your capacity to stay present with intensity.

The goal isn’t to never freeze again. That’s unrealistic. The goal is to catch yourself earlier in the process and have tools to stay grounded instead of going completely offline.

What Your Partner Can Do (This Part Is For Them)

If your partner freezes during conflict, your instinct is probably to reach harder for them. I get it. Their absence is painful, and you want them back.

But here’s what actually helps: Create more safety, not more intensity.

Lower your voice. Soften your body language. Slow down your speech. You’re signaling to their nervous system that there’s no threat here.

Say something like: “I can see you’re having a hard time right now. I’m not going anywhere. Take the time you need.”

Give them physical space if they need it, but stay emotionally available. You’re showing them they won’t be abandoned if they need to regulate their nervous system.

Notice and acknowledge when they’re trying to stay present, even if they can’t speak. “I can see you’re working hard to stay here with me. Thank you.” That kind of recognition matters more than you might think.

Don’t take their freeze personally. I know that’s hard. But their shutdown isn’t about you or how much they care. It’s about their nervous system being overwhelmed.

Beyond the Freeze: Building Long-Term Capacity

Over time, the goal is to increase your window of tolerance—the amount of emotional intensity you can handle before your nervous system hits the eject button.

This happens through repeated experiences of staying present with uncomfortable feelings and discovering you’re okay. That you have choices. That you’re not trapped.

Sometimes this work needs professional support. If you have a history of trauma, if freezing is deeply ingrained, if you and your partner can’t break the pattern on your own—that’s when couples therapy or individual work can be crucial. There’s no shame in that. Some nervous system patterns need more specialized help to shift.

What I’ve seen in 40 years of this work is that people absolutely can learn to stay present during difficult conversations. The freeze response doesn’t have to define your relationship. But it takes practice, patience, and a willingness to work with your body instead of against it.

Your Nervous System Isn’t Your Enemy

I want you to hear this: You’re not broken if you freeze. You’re not weak. You’re not failing at relationships.

Your freeze response is your nervous system trying to take care of you. It’s just using an old strategy that doesn’t serve you anymore. You developed this response for good reasons—it helped you survive something. The question now is whether it’s still helping or whether it’s time to develop new options.

The beautiful thing about nervous systems is they can learn. They can adapt. You can teach your body that it’s safe to stay present, even when things get intense. You can rewire those old patterns.

But you can’t think your way out of a freeze response. You have to feel your way out. You have to work with your body, not just your mind.

That’s why the practices I’ve shared here—grounding, staying physically present even when words won’t come, building capacity gradually—these aren’t just techniques. They’re ways of partnering with your nervous system instead of fighting it.

When You Know You’re Not Broken, Just Frozen

If you take nothing else from this article, take this: The next time you feel yourself starting to freeze during a difficult conversation, remember you have more options than you think.

You can press your feet into the floor and feel the ground supporting you. You can hold something warm and let that sensation anchor you. You can put your hand on your heart and remind yourself that you’re okay. You can look at your partner and let your eyes say what your mouth can’t.

You don’t have to force words. You don’t have to fake being okay. You just have to stay in your body and let your presence speak.

Because connection doesn’t require perfect communication. It just requires showing up, even in the messy, frozen, wordless moments. That’s when real intimacy happens—when you can be fully present with someone without having to perform being fine.

Your partner doesn’t need you to have all the right words. They just need to feel that you’re still there with them, even when things get hard.

And that? That’s completely possible, starting today.

About the Author: Todd Creager has spent over 40 years helping couples repair relationships through emotional safety and deep reconnection. His approach focuses on working with nervous system responses and building capacity for presence during conflict, rather than forcing communication before partners are ready. He works with individuals dealing with trauma, couples recovering from infidelity, and partners learning to connect more authentically.

Methodology Note: The approaches described in this article are based on over four decades of clinical experience working with couples who struggle with shutdown responses during conflict. The techniques integrate somatic (body-based) practices with attachment theory and nervous system regulation principles. Individual results vary based on trauma history, relationship dynamics, and consistency of practice.

Watch The Video Where Todd Explains How to Stop Shutting Down During Arguments

What if your next argument could bring you closer instead of driving you apart?


Learn how in Todd Creager’s Loving & Connecting Masterclass.
Lifetime access. Real results.

Say Yes to a Better Relationship

Why Defending Yourself Is Killing Your Relationship (And What to Do Instead)

by Leave a Comment

If you’ve ever walked away from an argument with your partner feeling exhausted and unheard—even though you were just trying to explain your side—you’re not alone.

I’ve worked with hundreds of couples over the years, and I can tell you this: defensiveness is one of the biggest connection killers I see in my practice. But here’s what catches most people off guard: when you’re defending yourself, you’re not being difficult. You’re actually showing how much you care about being understood.

TL;DR: Defensiveness isn’t resistance—it’s protection.

When you explain yourself during conflict, you think you’re clarifying, but your partner hears rejection. The solution isn’t more talking. It’s presence. Three non-verbal reconnection techniques can stop the defend-disconnect cycle and create the safety needed for real communication.

What Most People Miss:

→ Your defense feels like rejection to your partner, no matter how valid your point is

→ The more you explain, the more distant your partner gets (not closer)

→ Creating safety happens through presence, not through being understood first

→ Both partners are usually trying to help the situation—they’re just making it worse

I’m going to walk you through why this happens, what’s really going on beneath the surface, and give you a specific example from my practice that changed how one couple communicates entirely.

The Hidden Truth About Defensiveness

When you defend yourself in a relationship conflict, you’re making being understood your goal. And that sounds reasonable, right? You want your partner to see things accurately, to know your intentions, to understand that what they’re saying isn’t quite fair or isn’t quite right.

The problem is this: while you’re defending, you’re not connecting.

I see this play out the same way with couple after couple in my office. One partner expresses something—maybe it’s a complaint, maybe it’s hurt, maybe it’s frustration. The other partner immediately feels misunderstood and jumps in to explain. “No, that’s not what happened” or “You’re not seeing it from my perspective” or “If you just understood that I was trying to…”

And in that moment, connection dies.

Your partner doesn’t hear your explanation as clarification. They hear it as dismissal of their experience. They feel diminished. Their reality is being challenged when all they wanted was to be heard. So what do they do? They double down. They get more intense. They repeat themselves with more emotion because now they feel rejected on top of whatever they were already upset about.

And then what do you do? You defend more because clearly they’re still not getting it. You’re trying to be helpful. You’re trying to make things better. If they could just see it your way, they wouldn’t be so upset with you.

See the cycle?

In my experience working with couples for over three decades, I’ve found that defensiveness isn’t an attack—it’s protection. And when both partners understand that, something starts to shift. But even though we can understand it intellectually, protection still creates disconnection, not connection.

What Really Happened with Rob and Jody

Let me tell you about Rob and Jody. I’ve been helping them move from constant miscommunication into deep understanding—not just spoken understanding, but the kind of unspoken understanding where you feel safe with each other.

They came to me doing exactly what I just described. Jody would bring something up. Rob would feel it was unfair or inaccurate, so he’d immediately explain himself.

He felt misunderstood, and he thought if he could just clarify, she’d see that she was perceiving things wrong.

But Jody didn’t stop and say, “Oh, okay, I see your point.” Why? Because she had a point too. She was trying to get her point heard. So now you’ve got two people bickering. I call it like each person has their own tennis balls and they’re both throwing balls in the air, but nobody’s really catching anything.

What couples really need to learn is how to play catch—where one person throws and the other person catches. In other words, one person is present for the other person.

Rob and Jody weren’t trying to fight. They were really trying to clarify. But Jody didn’t hear clarification. She heard rejection. So she’d get more intense, maybe angrier, because she didn’t feel heard. And Rob would get even more frustrated that she couldn’t see how unfair her perception was.

No one felt heard.

Here’s the moment that changed everything for them: Rob told me, “Every time I defend myself, I thought I was helping. But she told me she felt like I didn’t care about her experience at all.” That surprised him because he surely did care. But it comes off the opposite way when you’re defending.

That hit him hard.

He was trying to make things better. People who defend are often trying to make things better—they never do, but they’re trying. Rob thought if Jody could just see it his way, she wouldn’t be so upset with him.

The Pause That Changed Their Marriage

So we tried something new. The next time conflict came up (and we worked on this with both of them, not just Rob), Jody brought something up that definitely triggered him. Rob felt that urge to explain himself.

But this time, he took a pause. He took a breath. Actually, several breaths. And then he reached his hand out to her.

Notice: no talking. No defense. Just presence.

Jody looked a little shocked. And then something happened that doesn’t happen when people are defending themselves—she softened. She actually opened up more than she had ever told him before about that particular subject.

That moment changed everything.

We think the way to fix disconnection is to talk more. But when you drop the need to be right or to be understood or to defend yourself, you create space for something deeper. Safety. Softness. Repair.

When you slow down and reach out in some nonverbal way, when you’ve dropped your urge or your impulse to defend, something happens to the other person. It registers with them.

Because really, your partner doesn’t need your defense. Your partner needs your presence.

Jody learned to do this for Rob too. Every time she felt the urge to defend herself, she’d take a breath or two or whatever she needed, and then she’d reach out and touch him in some way—touch his leg, hold his hand. They practiced this in sessions. They did it between sessions.

And Rob, who typically wasn’t someone who shared a lot emotionally, started sharing more. Why? Because they were creating a place of safety.

Why This Works (The Science Behind Presence)

When you defend yourself during conflict, you’re activating your partner’s threat response. Their nervous system is registering: “My experience doesn’t matter here. I’m not safe to be vulnerable.”

Based on my work with couples dealing with infidelity, trauma, and complex relational patterns, I’ve seen how the body holds these responses. When one partner goes into explanation mode, the other partner’s body tenses. Their breathing becomes shallow. They’re preparing for battle, not connection.

But when you pause and reach out physically, you’re sending a completely different signal. You’re saying with your body: “I’m here. You matter. I’m not going anywhere.” That drops the other person’s defenses because they’re not being rejected anymore.

What research on attachment and nervous system regulation tells us: Physical touch and presence activate the parasympathetic nervous system—the part that helps us calm down and feel safe. Words activate the thinking brain, which during conflict is already spinning and trying to prove a point.

This isn’t about who’s right or wrong. It’s about creating the conditions where you can actually hear each other.

Three Ways to Break the Defensiveness Cycle

1. The Pause and Breathe

When you feel that urge to explain yourself, that’s your cue. That urgency you feel? That’s your signal to stop, not to speak. Take at least three slow breaths. I tell couples to breathe in for four counts, hold for four, breathe out for six. That’s enough to start regulating your nervous system.

During those breaths, you’re not planning what to say. You’re not building your case. You’re just breathing.

Common pitfall I see: People take one quick breath and then jump back into explanation mode. That doesn’t work. Your body needs time to shift out of protection mode.

2. Reach Out Nonverbally

After you’ve taken those breaths, reach out to your partner in some physical way. This might be:

→ Reaching for their hand

→ Placing your hand on their leg

→ Moving closer to them

→ Making soft eye contact

The key is that you’re making a bid for connection, not defense. You’re saying, “I want to be close to you” without saying anything at all.

What happens next: Your partner might be shocked at first, like Jody was. They’re expecting defense, so presence catches them off guard. Give them a moment to register what’s happening.

3. Stay Present While They Share

This is the hardest part. Once your partner softens and starts sharing more (which they usually will), you might hear things that trigger your defensiveness again. You might hear perceptions that feel inaccurate or unfair.

Stay present anyway. Keep breathing. Keep your hand on theirs. You can address misunderstandings later, but right now, you’re creating safety. And safety is what allows real communication to happen.

Reality check from 30+ years of practice: This doesn’t mean you never get to share your perspective. It means you prioritize connection first. When your partner feels heard and safe, they become capable of hearing you too. When they’re in defense mode because you’ve been defending, they can’t hear anything except rejection.

When Defensiveness Makes Sense (And Still Doesn’t Help)

I want to acknowledge something important: sometimes what your partner is saying genuinely isn’t accurate. Sometimes their perception is skewed by their own past trauma or their own pain. Sometimes they’re making assumptions that aren’t fair.

And in those moments, of course you want to clarify. Of course you want to be understood. Your desire to defend is completely understandable.

But here’s what I’ve learned in working with couples dealing with infidelity recovery, trauma, and deep relational pain: being understood in that moment is less important than creating safety. Once safety exists, understanding can happen. But if you sacrifice safety to be understood, you get neither.

I work with partners in pain all the time—people dealing with betrayal, people recovering from infidelity, people with complex trauma histories. In those situations, emotions are heightened and perceptions can be distorted by pain. The betrayed partner might perceive things through a lens of hurt that makes everything feel like rejection.

And the person who betrayed might feel constantly misunderstood, like nothing they do is seen accurately.

In both cases, defensiveness feels justified. But it still doesn’t work.

What to Do When Your Partner Gets Defensive

Everything I’ve said applies to you too when your partner is the one defending. If you bring something up and your partner immediately starts explaining themselves, you probably feel dismissed. You might get more intense, more emotional, more insistent that they hear you.

Instead, try this: “I can see you want me to understand your perspective. I do want to hear that. But right now, I need you to hear me first. Can you just listen for a moment?”

If they keep defending, you can say: “When you explain yourself right now, I feel like my experience doesn’t matter. I’m not saying you’re wrong. I just need you to hear me first.”

And if they still can’t stop defending, that might be a sign that professional help would be useful. Some couples need a therapist to help them break these patterns because they’re too entrenched to change on their own.

What Safety Actually Looks Like

When couples tell me they want to feel “safe” in their relationship, they often mean they want to be able to share vulnerable things without being shut down. They want to be able to bring up difficult topics without starting World War III.

Safety isn’t the absence of conflict. Safety is the presence of connection even during conflict.

In safe relationships:

→ You can say something your partner doesn’t like without them attacking or defending

→ You can be upset without your partner trying to fix it or explain it away

→ You can have different perceptions without one person being “right” and one being “wrong”

→ You can pause when things get heated and come back without resentment

When Rob stopped defending and reached out to Jody, he created safety. Not because he agreed with her perception, but because he prioritized connection over being understood.

That’s what safety looks like.

The Long-Term Shift

Rob and Jody didn’t become perfect at this overnight. They still slip into defensiveness sometimes. But now they catch themselves faster. Now they have a tool that actually works.

What I’ve noticed in my practice is that couples who learn to prioritize presence over defense end up communicating better overall. Why? Because they’re building emotional muscles—the ability to stay present for each other even when it’s uncomfortable.

That’s what creates the deeper, more authentic connection that couples come to therapy seeking.

Based on my work with hundreds of couples: The ones who make it through infidelity, trauma, and major life crises are the ones who learn to be curious about each other instead of defensive. They develop the capacity to sit with pain—their own and their partner’s—without trying to escape it or explain it away.

That’s not easy. It requires practice. But it’s possible.

When to Get Professional Help

Some situations are too complex to handle on your own:

→ If there’s been infidelity and the defensiveness is tied to lies or ongoing betrayal

→ If one or both partners have trauma histories that make vulnerability terrifying

→ If defensiveness has escalated into contempt, criticism, or emotional withdrawal

→ If you’ve tried these techniques and can’t seem to make them stick

Working with a therapist who understands couples dynamics, infidelity recovery, and trauma can help you navigate these deeper waters. Sometimes you need someone to help you see your blind spots and hold space for both of you.

Your Next Step

The next time you feel the need to defend yourself in a conversation with your partner, try this:

Pause. Soften your body. Reach out in some nonverbal way.

In that moment, when you shift from trying to be understood to trying to connect, the entire dynamic can change.

Your partner doesn’t need your defense. Your partner needs your presence.

And when you give them that, you create the space where real understanding becomes possible.

About This Approach

The reconnection techniques described here are based on attachment theory, nervous system regulation, and trauma-informed couples therapy.

They’re particularly effective for:

→ Couples stuck in pursue-withdraw patterns

→ Partners recovering from infidelity

→ Individuals with trauma histories affecting their relationships

→ Anyone struggling with emotional reactivity during conflict

These methods work because they address the nervous system first, before trying to address the content of the disagreement.

When both partners feel safe, they become capable of hearing each other and working through differences constructively.

Methodology note: The case example of Rob and Jody represents a composite of multiple couples I’ve worked with over three decades of practice.

Names and identifying details have been changed to protect client confidentiality while illustrating the patterns I consistently observe in my clinical work.

What if your next argument could bring you closer instead of driving you apart?


Learn how in Todd Creager’s Loving & Connecting Masterclass.
Lifetime access. Real results.

Say Yes to a Better Relationship

Do You Want to Be Right or Do You Want to Be Connected?

by Leave a Comment

You know what I see week after week in my therapy practice? Couples sitting across from each other, both absolutely convinced they’re right. And they are—sort of. They’re right from their perspective. But here’s what they’re missing: being right is costing them their relationship.

TL;DR: Most communication problems aren’t about who’s correct—they’re about the anxiety of not being validated. When couples race to prove they’re right, they stop listening. The solution isn’t better arguments; it’s developing the emotional muscle to prioritize understanding over validation.

But here’s what most people miss:

→ The need to be right functions like an addiction—it gives you a temporary hit of validation but damages long-term connection

→ Different personality types aren’t obstacles to overcome; they represent complementary values that both matter

→ Your partner feeling heard by you is more valuable than them agreeing with you

I’ve spent over four decades working with couples navigating everything from infidelity recovery to passion renewal.

And I can tell you this: the smartest, most accomplished people often struggle the most with this issue. Why? Because being right has served them well in other areas of life. But in relationships, it’s poison.

Why Couples Get Stuck in the Need to Be Right

Years ago, I took a training that introduced me to something called BLM—not Black Lives Matter, but “Be Like Me.” The instructor kept pointing out how we all walk around with this unconscious expectation: You’re supposed to be like me. You’re supposed to see things the way I see them.

But that’s not how humans work.

Take Sam and Barbara, a couple I’ve been working with. Sam’s successful in his career, very structured, follows a code of ethics and discipline. Barbara has her master’s degree, stayed home with their two kids, and approaches life with more flexibility—what I call “loosey goosey” energy.

They came to me saying they had communication problems. What they actually had was a Cold War. Years of it. Barbara felt Sam didn’t value her opinions. Sam insisted he just didn’t agree with her.

See the problem? Neither one felt understood. And when you don’t feel understood, you dig in harder. You explain more. You present your case more forcefully. You need to win.

The Addiction to Being Right in Relationships

When someone agrees with us, we feel validated. Maybe it means we’ll get what we want. There’s a neurological payoff—it feels good to be right.

But here’s the reality: in most conflicts, both people have valid perspectives based on their personality, their experiences, their values. Sam’s structure and discipline matter. Barbara’s flexibility and spontaneity matter. These aren’t competing values that need a winner—they’re complementary approaches that could strengthen their relationship.

The problem wasn’t their differences. The problem was their anxiety about not being validated, which led them to act in ways that made the other person feel unheard.

How to Stop Fighting About Who’s Right in Your Relationship

A colleague of mine wrote a book called “Do You Wanna Be Right or Do You Wanna Be Married?” That title says it all.

Sam and Barbara are learning to shift their goal. Instead of racing to convince each other who’s right, they’re racing toward something else: who can help the other person feel understood first.

That’s the opposite of what most couples do.

This shift requires developing emotional muscle. Just like you need physical strength to lift heavy furniture without getting hurt, you need emotional strength to handle life’s challenges with grace.

You can’t just decide one day, “Okay, I’m going to be a better listener.” You have to practice. You have to build that muscle through repetition, even when—especially when—you strongly disagree with what you’re hearing.

Practical Steps to Choose Connection Over Being Right

Here’s what I work on with couples:

1. Recognize the addiction pattern. Notice when you feel that urgent need to correct, explain, or convince. That’s the craving for validation kicking in.

2. Shift your intent. Your new goal isn’t agreement—it’s understanding. Can you get where they’re coming from, even if you think they’re completely wrong?

3. Build the muscle gradually. Start with less emotionally charged topics. Practice letting your partner feel heard without immediately countering with your perspective.

4. Value complementary differences. When you see different approaches—structure versus flexibility, caution versus spontaneity—ask yourself: “What’s valuable about their perspective that I’m missing?”

Sam and Barbara are doing this work now. It’s not easy. They still have moments where the old pattern kicks in—that need to prove themselves right. But they’re catching it faster. They’re choosing connection over correctness more often.

What Better Communication Actually Looks Like

Let’s say Sam thinks they should have a strict bedtime routine for the kids—same time every night, no exceptions. Barbara thinks some flexibility is fine—if the kids are having fun on a weekend, why not let them stay up?

Old pattern: Sam explains why structure is crucial for child development. Barbara counters with why rigid rules create anxiety. They both marshal more evidence. Nobody listens. Everyone feels dismissed.

New pattern: Sam shares why consistency feels important to him—maybe it comes from his own chaotic childhood. Barbara shares why she values spontaneity—maybe her parents were too controlling. They’re not debating parenting philosophy anymore. They’re understanding each other’s emotional reality.

From there, they can actually problem-solve. Maybe weeknights have structure, weekends have flexibility. But more importantly, they both feel heard. They both feel valued.

Building Emotional Muscle for Relationship Communication

Think about what happens when you try to lift something heavy without proper strength. You hurt yourself. You might drop what you’re carrying.

Same with emotional challenges. If you haven’t built the muscle to tolerate hearing perspectives that contradict yours, if you can’t sit with the discomfort of not being validated immediately, you’ll keep dropping the emotional weight of your relationship conflicts.

Building this muscle means:

→ Staying present when you disagree instead of rehearsing your rebuttal

→ Asking questions to understand rather than to poke holes in their logic

→ Reflecting back what you heard before offering your perspective

→ Noticing when your anxiety about being wrong is driving your behavior

It’s repetition, just like at the gym. The first few times feel awkward and uncomfortable. But over time, it becomes your new default.

Why Feeling Understood Matters More Than Being Right

Here’s something I’ve seen in my four decades of practice: couples who learn to give up the need to be right don’t just communicate better. They reconnect at a deeper level.

Because when you feel truly understood by your partner—not agreed with, but understood—something profound happens. You feel safe. You feel valued. The emotional armor comes down.

And from that place, you can handle disagreements without them threatening the foundation of your relationship. You can appreciate your differences instead of battling over them.

Sam and Barbara are starting to experience this. They’re becoming what they always wanted: a couple that communicates well together. Not because they agree more—they still disagree plenty—but because they’ve stopped making agreement the goal.

They’re choosing connection over correctness. And their relationship is stronger for it.

Moving From Conflict to Connection in Your Relationship

What I’ve shared with you about Sam and Barbara comes from real sessions, real struggles, real breakthroughs. The patterns I see in their relationship show up in countless couples—different personalities, same fundamental challenge of prioritizing validation over understanding.

This approach to couples work draws on personality type frameworks, attachment theory, and decades of observing what actually helps couples move from conflict to connection. It’s not about applying a formula—every couple is unique. But the principle of developing emotional muscle to prioritize understanding? That’s universal.

If you’re recognizing these patterns in your own relationship, know that change is possible. It takes practice. It takes building new habits. But couples do this work successfully all the time.

The question isn’t whether you’re right or your partner is right. The question is: do you want to be right, or do you want to be connected?

Todd Creager has been helping couples and individuals heal from trauma and rekindle passion for over four decades. His approach combines deep empathy with practical strategies for building stronger emotional connections.

Watch The Video where Todd Explains Why Being Right is Ruining Your Relationship

What if your next argument could bring you closer instead of driving you apart?


Learn how in Todd Creager’s Loving & Connecting Masterclass.
Lifetime access. Real results.

Say Yes to a Better Relationship

Why Bickering Becomes Your Default (And How to Break the Cycle)

by Leave a Comment

When Bickering Becomes Your Relationship’s Default Setting: What Nobody Tells You About Breaking the Cycle

You know that moment when you realize you’ve had the same argument for the third time this week? Not even about anything important—just that familiar dance where one person brings something up, the other gets defensive, and within minutes you’re both exhausted and further apart than when you started.

Here’s what I’ve seen after working with hundreds of couples: most relationship advice tells you to “communicate better” or “really listen to each other.” But that’s like telling someone who’s drowning to “just swim harder.” When you’re already in reactive mode, those tools are about as useful as a chocolate teapot.

TL;DR: Constant bickering isn’t a communication problem—it’s a nervous system problem. Most couples are trying to solve the wrong issue. They think they need better words when they actually need to slow down their reactivity first. The pattern isn’t: bad communication → disconnection. It’s: dysregulation → reactive communication → more dysregulation → deeper disconnection.

What Most People Miss:

→ Your brain can’t process your partner’s perspective when you’re in defensive mode—it’s literally a neurological impossibility, not a character flaw

→ The content of your arguments matters far less than the speed at which you’re having them

→ Trying to “fix” the relationship through more talking when you’re both activated is like throwing gasoline on a fire and expecting it to help

Why “Just Communicate Better” Is Terrible Advice

I worked with Rick and Diane for about six months. Twenty-five years married, three kids, successful careers. They came in doing what I call the “bicker-escalate-disconnect” loop. Diane would bring up feeling disconnected. Rick would immediately defend himself—”Look what I provide! I’m doing my best!” Diane would feel unheard. Rick would feel unappreciated. Both would shut down.

Sound familiar?

Here’s the thing that took them weeks to understand: they weren’t having a communication problem. They were having a regulation problem.

When Diane approached Rick with a complaint, his nervous system heard: “You’re failing. You’re not enough.” Within seconds—and I mean seconds—his body was flooded with cortisol and adrenaline. His brain literally couldn’t access the parts responsible for empathy, perspective-taking, or curiosity. He was in survival mode.

Same thing happened to Diane when Rick got defensive. Her nervous system interpreted his defensiveness as: “Your feelings don’t matter. You’re too much.” And off to the races they’d go.

Most couples therapy focuses on teaching you communication techniques while you’re dysregulated. That’s backwards. You can’t use sophisticated tools when your brain is in fight-or-flight mode. It’s like trying to perform surgery while riding a rollercoaster.

The Speed Problem Nobody Talks About

After analyzing patterns with couples for over two decades, I’ve noticed something: the couples who bicker constantly aren’t arguing about different things than couples who don’t—they’re arguing at different speeds.

Think about it. When Diane said “I don’t feel close to you,” Rick had maybe half a second before his defensive response kicked in. That’s not enough time for his nervous system to settle, for him to get curious, for him to access the part of his brain that could hear her pain instead of just hearing criticism.

The arguments weren’t happening because they disagreed. The arguments were happening because neither of them could slow down enough to notice what was actually happening inside themselves before they reacted to each other.

This is where most relationship advice goes wrong. It tells you what to say differently. But it doesn’t address the state you’re in when you’re saying it.

I’ll give you a real example from Rick and Diane’s process. About two months in, Diane started to feel that familiar frustration building. But instead of immediately going to Rick with her complaint, she paused. She got curious about what was happening in her body. Tight chest. Throat constricting. That old story playing: “He’ll never prioritize me.”

That pause—maybe thirty seconds—changed everything. Because when she did approach Rick, she wasn’t coming from that activated, desperate place. She was coming from a more grounded space. And Rick could feel the difference. His nervous system didn’t immediately interpret her as a threat.

What’s Really Happening When You Bicker

Most couples think they’re arguing about dishes, money, sex, parenting, or time. And sure, those are the topics. But here’s what’s actually happening underneath:

You’re each trying to protect yourself from feeling something that feels unbearable. For Rick, it was feeling like a failure. For Diane, it was feeling invisible and unimportant. Every bickering match was both of them trying to avoid those core feelings while simultaneously triggering exactly those feelings in each other.

This is the part that most people find hard to accept: when you’re judging your partner, you’re revealing more about your own pain than about their behavior.

When Diane judged Rick as “caring more about work than me,” she was really saying: “I’m terrified I don’t matter.” When Rick judged Diane as “never satisfied,” he was really saying: “I’m terrified I’m not enough.”

But you can’t hear that nuance when you’re moving at argument speed. You’re just defending, attacking, or shutting down.

Why Disconnection Feels Easier (And Why That’s the Trap)

Rick and Diane had developed what a lot of couples develop: conflict fatigue. They’d had so many unrewarding conversations that just talking about emotional stuff felt pointless. So they’d disconnect. Live parallel lives. Be polite roommates who occasionally had sex out of obligation.

And honestly? For a while, that feels better than the constant fighting. It’s quieter. Less chaotic. You can convince yourself you’re being “mature” by not bringing things up.

But here’s the problem: disconnection doesn’t heal anything. It just postpones the pain. And while you’re disconnected, resentment builds. Distance grows. And the gap between you becomes harder and harder to bridge.

I see couples who’ve been disconnected for so long that they’ve forgotten they ever felt connected. They look at each other across my office like strangers, both thinking: “Is it even worth trying?”

The answer is usually yes. But not by doing more of what hasn’t worked.

The Real Answer Isn’t What You Think

Rick and Diane didn’t save their relationship by learning better communication techniques. They saved it by learning to slow down their nervous systems first.

We worked on what I call the Stop Technique—though that’s somewhat of a misnomer because it’s not really about stopping. It’s about creating space between stimulus and response. It’s about noticing what’s happening in your body before you react to your partner.

Sounds simple, right? It’s not. Or rather, it’s simple but not easy.

Because slowing down feels counterintuitive when you’re upset. Your body wants to react NOW. Your brain is screaming: “Defend yourself! Make them understand! Fix this immediately!”

But that urgency is exactly what keeps you stuck.

Rick and Diane practiced—and I mean actually practiced, like homework—slowing down their reactivity. At first for just a few minutes a day. Not when they were in the middle of an argument (that’s too hard). But in calm moments, practicing noticing their internal state. Practicing getting curious about their own reactions before trying to manage their partner’s behavior.

Here’s what started to shift: when Diane felt that familiar frustration building, she could recognize it earlier. She could feel her body tensing up, notice that old story starting to play. And instead of immediately bringing it to Rick from that activated place, she could take a few breaths. Get grounded. Figure out what she actually needed instead of just what she was mad about.

Same with Rick. When Diane brought something up, he could notice his defensiveness rising before it took over completely. He could feel his chest tightening, hear that voice saying “You’re not enough.” And instead of immediately defending himself, he could pause. Just for a moment. Long enough to remember: “Her pain isn’t proof of my failure.”

What Changed (And What Didn’t)

Here’s what didn’t change: Rick still worked a lot. Diane still wanted more connection. Their circumstances stayed pretty much the same.

Here’s what did change: how they were with each other in those circumstances.

Rick didn’t suddenly start working 20 fewer hours a week. But when he was with Diane, he was actually with her. Not halfway out the door mentally. Not defending his choices. Just present.

Diane didn’t lower her standards or decide she was asking for too much. But she stopped approaching Rick from that desperate, activated place that made him immediately defensive. She learned to ask for what she needed from a grounded place, which made it about a thousand times easier for Rick to actually hear her.

And the bickering? Pretty much stopped. Not because they never disagreed, but because when they did, they could slow down enough to actually work through it instead of just reacting to each other.

Why This Works When Everything Else Hasn’t

After working with couples for decades, I can tell you: the ones who make it aren’t the ones who never fight or disagree. They’re the ones who learn to regulate themselves first before trying to regulate each other.

Most relationship advice puts the cart before the horse. It tells you to validate your partner’s feelings, use “I” statements, really listen, show empathy. All good things. But impossible to do when your nervous system is flooded.

You have to slow down first. Get your own nervous system settled. Only then can you access the parts of your brain that can be curious, empathetic, and flexible.

This isn’t about becoming some enlightened being who never gets triggered. Rick and Diane still get activated sometimes. I still get activated with my own partner. We’re human. But the difference is in what you do with that activation. Do you let it drive the bus? Or do you notice it, acknowledge it, and choose to respond from a more grounded place?

That’s the skill. And it’s a skill anyone can learn, even if you’ve been stuck in the bicker-escalate-disconnect pattern for years.

What Actually Reconnects You (Without More Talking)

Here’s something that surprises people: the best reconnection often happens without words.

When Rick and Diane were both activated, talking made things worse. Every word was just more ammunition. But when they’d slow down together—maybe just sit quietly for a few minutes, or take a walk without trying to solve anything, or even just breathe in the same room—their nervous systems would start to sync up again.

You can reconnect through presence before you can reconnect through words. Your body knows this even if your mind doesn’t trust it yet.

Some of the most powerful sessions with Rick and Diane involved very little talking. They’d practice just being in the same space, noticing their own reactions, breathing, settling. Not trying to fix anything. Not explaining or defending. Just… being.

That probably sounds too simple to work. But simple doesn’t mean ineffective.

Moving Forward (Without the Usual Bullshit About “Communication”)

If you’re stuck in the bicker-escalate-disconnect pattern, you probably don’t need another article telling you to “really listen” or “use active listening techniques.” You need permission to stop trying to communicate your way out of a dysregulated nervous system.

You need to learn to slow down first. To notice what’s happening in your body before you react to your partner. To get curious about your own pain instead of just managing your partner’s behavior.

This isn’t about becoming perfect at self-regulation. It’s about getting just good enough at it that you can interrupt the old patterns before they completely take over.

Rick and Diane aren’t perfect at this. They still slip into old patterns sometimes. But now they can catch themselves earlier. They can notice when they’re speeding up and choose to slow down instead. And that makes all the difference.

Your relationship can feel good again. But probably not by doing more of what hasn’t worked. Not by talking more, solving more, or explaining more. By slowing down first, then connecting from that more grounded place.

That’s where the real work is. And it takes less time than you think—but maybe more awareness than you’re used to bringing to your daily interactions.

Todd Creager has worked with couples navigating infidelity, trauma, and disconnection for over two decades. He specializes in somatic and body-centered approaches that address the nervous system patterns underlying relationship struggles. His work focuses on helping couples move beyond reactive communication patterns to create genuine connection and safety.

What if your next argument could bring you closer instead of driving you apart?


Learn how in Todd Creager’s Loving & Connecting Masterclass.
Lifetime access. Real results.

Say Yes to a Better Relationship

Why Your Communication Problem Isn’t Actually About Communication

by Leave a Comment

about something I see almost daily in my practice, and it’s probably not what you think.

Couples come to me saying they have a “communication problem.” And technically, they’re right—they aren’t talking, or when they do talk, it goes sideways fast. But here’s what most people miss: the communication breakdown is almost never the real problem. It’s a symptom of something deeper that’s happening beneath the surface.

Let me explain why:

→ Most relationship communication issues stem from nervous system dysregulation, not lack of talking skills

→ Partners often have opposing regulation strategies (shutdown vs. fight) rooted in childhood coping mechanisms

→ Real solutions focus on learning new ways to regulate your nervous system while staying connected

→ You don’t necessarily need to talk more—you need to regulate better

But Here’s What Most People Miss:

→ Telling someone to “communicate better” is like telling someone having a panic attack to “just calm down”—their nervous system is already hijacked

→ Your partner’s “annoying” response pattern (shutting down, getting loud) was once a survival strategy that worked

→ Self-criticism about your patterns actually makes the dysregulation worse, not better

What We’re Covering: This piece walks through the real mechanics of why couples get stuck in communication loops, what’s actually happening in your body during these moments, and—most importantly—what you can do about it that doesn’t involve just “talking more.”

I’m drawing from decades of work with couples in pain, and I’ll show you why the conventional advice often misses the mark.

The Couple That Couldn’t Talk (But It Wasn’t About Talking)

Let me tell you about Helen and Nance. When they first came to see me, they looked exhausted. Helen had this tight-lipped frustration—the kind that comes from years of hitting a brick wall. Nance sat slumped, already bracing for what was coming.

Their presenting problem? “We can’t communicate.”

They weren’t wrong. Nance would shut down whenever Helen tried to discuss anything difficult. Sometimes he’d freeze completely. Other times he’d quietly leave the room. Helen’s response? She’d get louder, follow him, voice rising: “Why can’t you talk to me? Why can’t you talk to me?”

Nance would eventually muster: “Because you’re so aggressive. I feel attacked.”

Helen: “I don’t want to be that way!”

Round and round they’d go.

By the time they reached my office, they’d both given up. The house was quiet—but it was the hollow quiet of disconnection, not peace.

Now, most traditional therapy would focus on communication skills. Active listening techniques. “I” statements. Maybe some scripts for difficult conversations.

All of that can be useful. But with Helen and Nance, it would’ve been like handing a manual on advanced driving techniques to someone whose car won’t start. We needed to look under the hood first.

What’s Really Happening: Your Nervous System Is Running the Show

Here’s the piece that changes everything once you understand it: Both Helen and Nance were regulating their central nervous systems the only way they knew how.

That’s it. That’s the hidden issue.

Nance grew up in a house where his dad yelled at his mom. A lot. It scared him as a kid. His mom, meanwhile, was critical—always finding what was wrong, never satisfied. What was Nance supposed to do as a child? He couldn’t fix it. He couldn’t stop it. So he learned to go to his room, read books, play video games, and shut out the chaos. He learned to ignore the criticism from his mom and the coldness from his dad.

And here’s the thing—it worked. That strategy helped him survive. It helped him cope with pain he couldn’t do anything about. I’d bet money that at some point early on, maybe he tried expressing himself. Maybe he reached out. And it didn’t go well. So his nervous system learned: shutdown equals safety.

Helen’s story was different but equally powerful. Her dad worked constantly. Her mom ran everything and seemed to accept this distant marriage as just “the way things are.” Helen had a close relationship with her mom but almost none with her dad. She watched her mother’s loneliness and made herself a promise: I will never have the kind of marriage my mother had. I will never be that lonely in my relationship.

Fast forward to Helen and Nance’s marriage. What happens when disconnection threatens?

Nance’s nervous system, shaped by years of childhood conditioning, says: “Danger. Shut down. Go internal. That’s how we stay safe.” Immobilization defense.

Helen’s nervous system, equally conditioned by her childhood, says: “Danger. Do NOT let this turn into my parents’ marriage. Fight for connection. Get louder.” Mobilization defense.

You see the problem? Nance shuts down, which triggers Helen’s deepest fear of ending up like her mom. Helen gets louder, which triggers Nance’s childhood experience of his dad yelling and his mom criticizing. Nance shuts down harder. Helen pushes harder. Both are dysregulating each other while desperately trying to regulate themselves.

Neither one is choosing this consciously. Neither one is being “difficult.” They’re both running deeply ingrained nervous system programs designed to keep them safe.

The Sympathetic and Immobilization Defense Patterns

Let me get a bit more technical here because understanding this changes how you approach the whole thing.

When we perceive threat—and for many couples, conflict or disconnection is perceived as threat—our autonomic nervous system takes over. You’ve probably heard of fight-or-flight. That’s your sympathetic nervous system kicking into gear. But there’s also freeze, which is more of an immobilization response.

Helen’s Pattern – Mobilization Defense: Her sympathetic nervous system activates. Heart rate goes up. Voice gets louder. She’s in fight mode (not so much flight). From her perspective, she’s fighting for the relationship. She’s trying to get her husband to engage in a way she never got with her dad. In her body, silence equals abandonment equals mom’s loneliness. So her system mobilizes to prevent that outcome.

Nance’s Pattern – Immobilization Defense: His system goes into shutdown mode. Heart rate might actually slow. He freezes. Words become impossible. From his perspective, he’s trying to avoid the criticism and yelling he experienced as a kid. In his body, engaging during conflict equals pain. So his system immobilizes to prevent that outcome.

Both are trying to regulate. Both are trying to protect themselves. And both strategies, ironically, dysregulate their partner.

What Most Therapists Miss: Conventional communication advice assumes both people are in a regulated state where they can access their prefrontal cortex—the part of the brain that does rational thinking, empathy, and communication. But when you’re in fight-or-flight or freeze, you literally don’t have full access to those capabilities. Your nervous system has hijacked the show.

Telling Nance to “just talk” when he’s in shutdown is like telling someone who’s frozen in a trauma response to “just move.” Telling Helen to “calm down and lower your voice” when her system is mobilized to fight for connection is equally futile.

Why Beating Yourself Up Makes It Worse

Here’s something I tell every couple I work with, and it’s something Helen and Nance needed to hear:

When we’re dealing with each other in ways that don’t work, it’s usually because we don’t know any other way.

Read that again.

The self-criticism many people heap on themselves—”Why do I keep doing this? What’s wrong with me? I should be better than this”—comes from a false belief that you should have known better.

No. What you’re doing made perfect sense at some point in your life. It was adaptive. It worked. Your nervous system learned it well because it kept you safe.

The problem isn’t that you’re broken or stupid or bad at relationships.

The problem is that your childhood coping strategy is still running the show in your adult relationship, and it’s not working anymore in this new context.

Beating yourself up actually makes the dysregulation worse. Shame and self-criticism activate stress responses in the body. So now you’re not just dealing with the original trigger—you’re also dealing with the shame spiral on top of it. Your nervous system has even more to cope with.

Learning New Ways to Regulate (While Staying Connected)

So here’s the good news, and this is what I’m most passionate about: We can learn new ways to regulate our nervous systems.

You are not doomed to repeat these patterns forever. Your nervous system is adaptable. We can learn new tricks.

The goal isn’t to eliminate your stress responses—you’re a human being, and some level of activation is normal and healthy. The goal is to expand your window of tolerance so you can stay present with your partner even when things get difficult.

For someone like Nance (the shutdown pattern): The work is learning that he doesn’t have to shut down completely to stay regulated. There are other ways to manage his discomfort without disconnecting entirely. This might look like:

→ Learning to notice the early signs that shutdown is coming (body awareness)

→ Practicing staying present for just 30 seconds longer than feels comfortable

→ Developing language to name what’s happening: “I’m noticing I want to leave right now, but I’m going to try to stay”

→ Understanding that his shutdown, while protective for him, dysregulates Helen

For someone like Helen (the fight pattern): The work is learning that she can stay regulated without escalating. There are ways to pursue connection that don’t involve raising her voice or pushing harder. This might look like:

→ Recognizing when her system is starting to mobilize (racing heart, rising voice)

→ Pausing to take a few breaths before continuing

→ Naming her fear directly: “I’m scared we’re disconnecting” instead of “Why won’t you talk to me?”

→ Understanding that her pursuit, while coming from good intentions, dysregulates Nance

The Gold Medal: Co-Regulation Here’s what becomes possible once both partners learn new regulation strategies: you can actually start to help regulate each other’s nervous system.

When Helen can stay calm, her calm nervous system sends a signal to Nance’s nervous system: “It’s safe here. You don’t have to shut down.” When Nance can stay present without shutting down, his presence sends a signal to Helen’s nervous system: “I’m not leaving. You don’t have to fight for connection.”

This is called co-regulation, and it’s one of the most beautiful things that happens in healthy relationships. Your nervous systems start working together instead of against each other.

And then—voila—there’s communication. Real communication. Not forced scripts or techniques, but actual connection happening because both nervous systems are regulated enough to allow it.

Three Common Mistakes Couples Make

Mistake #1: Thinking More Talking Will Fix It

I can’t tell you how many couples come in saying they need to “communicate more” or “talk things through better.” Sometimes, yes, you need better communication skills. But often what you actually need is better regulation skills. Talking when you’re dysregulated just means you’re having a dysregulated conversation—which usually makes things worse, not better.

Mistake #2: Trying to Logic Your Way Out

When your nervous system is activated, your prefrontal cortex (the logical, rational part of your brain) is offline. Trying to reason with yourself or your partner in that moment is like trying to run a computer program when the power’s out. First, you need to get the power back on—which means regulation.

Mistake #3: Blaming Your Partner’s Pattern

It’s so easy to see your partner’s pattern as “the problem.” If only Nance would talk more. If only Helen would stop yelling. But both patterns are symptoms of the same underlying issue: nervous system dysregulation rooted in childhood adaptation. Neither person is the villain. You’re both stuck in a dance where each person’s dysregulation triggers the other’s.

What Actually Helps: Practical Steps

Based on working with hundreds of couples over decades, here’s what actually makes a difference:

Step 1: Develop Awareness of Your Own Pattern You can’t change what you’re not aware of. Start noticing:

→ What does it feel like in your body when you start to go into your pattern?

→ What triggers tend to activate it?

→ What are the early warning signs before you’re fully dysregulated?

Keep a simple log for a week. Just notice. No judgment. “I noticed I started to shut down when…” or “I noticed my voice got louder when…”

Step 2: Learn to Self-Regulate This is the skill that most people never learned growing up. Simple practices include:

→ Box breathing (4 counts in, 4 hold, 4 out, 4 hold)

→ Placing your hand on your heart or stomach

→ Going for a short walk

→ Splashing cold water on your face

→ Progressive muscle relaxation

Find what works for your nervous system. Some people need to move (walk, stretch). Some people need to ground (breathing, body awareness). Experiment.

Step 3: Practice Staying Present Just a Little Longer

Don’t try to completely override your pattern overnight. That’s too big a leap. Instead, if you normally shut down after 30 seconds of conflict, try staying for 45 seconds. If you normally escalate within 2 minutes, try staying regulated for 2 minutes and 15 seconds.

Small increments. You’re building new neural pathways. That takes repetition and time.

Step 4: Communicate About Your Pattern (When You’re Regulated)

Have a conversation with your partner when you’re both calm. Not during conflict. Talk about your patterns.

“When I feel criticized, my instinct is to shut down. I learned this as a kid. I’m working on it, but I need you to know it’s not about you—it’s my nervous system trying to protect me.”

“When I feel disconnection starting, my instinct is to pursue harder and get louder. I learned this from watching my parents. I’m working on it, but I need you to know I’m actually scared, not angry.”

This kind of vulnerability, shared from a regulated state, builds understanding and compassion.

Step 5: Create Repair Rituals

You will dysregulate. You will fall back into old patterns sometimes. That’s normal. That’s being human. What matters is repair.

Develop a simple ritual for after things go sideways:

→ “Can we try that again?”

→ A specific hand gesture that means “I need a break but I’m coming back”

→ A brief hug or physical connection before talking

→ A shared phrase like “We got stuck in the pattern, didn’t we?”

Repair is more important than perfection.

When Professional Help Makes Sense

Look, I’m a therapist, so you might think I’m biased here. But there are specific situations where professional help isn’t just useful—it’s crucial:

When to Consider Therapy:

→ You’ve been stuck in the same pattern for months or years with no improvement

→ One or both partners experienced significant childhood trauma

→ There’s been infidelity, addiction, or other major betrayals

→ Either partner has mental health issues (depression, anxiety, PTSD) that complicate the dynamic

→ You’ve tried self-help approaches and they’re not creating change

→ The relationship is affecting your physical health, work, or parenting

A skilled couples therapist who understands nervous system regulation can:

→ Help you identify your specific patterns more clearly than you might on your own

→ Provide real-time coaching during difficult conversations

→ Offer tailored regulation strategies based on your unique nervous systems

→ Address underlying trauma that’s fueling the patterns

→ Hold hope for you when you can’t hold it for yourselves

What to Look For in a Therapist:

→ Specialization in couples therapy (not just individual therapy)

→ Training in attachment theory, nervous system regulation, or trauma-informed care

→ Understanding that both partners are in pain, not that one is “the problem”

→ Focus on the relationship dynamic, not just individual communication skills

→ Ability to create a safe space for both partners

The Evolution Helen and Nance Experienced

Let me tell you how things turned out for Helen and Nance, because their story illustrates what’s possible.

They developed what I call “emotional muscle”—the ability to stay present with discomfort without immediately reaching for their old coping strategies. Nance learned he could feel anxious and stay in the conversation. Helen learned she could feel scared of disconnection and not escalate in response.

They practiced. A lot. It wasn’t linear. Some weeks were better than others. But gradually, something shifted.

Nance started saying things like, “I notice I want to leave right now, but I’m going to sit with this for another minute.” Helen started saying things like, “I’m feeling that panic again—the one where I think you’re checking out—but I’m going to take a breath instead of raising my voice.”

They learned to name what was happening in their bodies. They learned to understand each other’s patterns with compassion instead of blame. They learned, gradually, to co-regulate—to help soothe each other’s nervous systems instead of triggering them.

Most importantly: They learned they didn’t have to be victims of their families of origin. Nance could evolve beyond his childhood shutdown strategy. Helen could evolve beyond her childhood pursuit pattern.

They found that beating themselves up was not only unhelpful—it was inaccurate. They weren’t failing at something they should have known. They were learning something new. Big difference.

Why “Just Talk More” Isn’t the Answer

This might sound counterintuitive coming from a therapist, but talking isn’t everything. In fact, sometimes talking is exactly the wrong prescription.

If you’re dysregulated, talking will likely be dysregulated talking—which means more misunderstanding, more hurt, more disconnection. You need regulation first, connection second, communication third.

Here’s what I tell couples: You need to be able to be present with each other in ways that don’t involve words. You need to rebuild safety in your nervous systems around each other. Sometimes that happens through:

→ Being in the same room doing separate things peacefully

  • Physical touch without talking (hand-holding, hugging)
  • Parallel activities (cooking together, walking together)
  • Eye contact and presence
  • Small gestures that signal “I’m here” and “You matter”

These non-verbal forms of connection can actually be more regulating than conversation, especially when you’re learning new patterns.

Once your nervous systems feel safe together again, communication becomes easier. Natural, even. You don’t have to force it or script it. It flows because the underlying foundation—regulation and co-regulation—is there.

Moving Forward

If you’re reading this and recognizing your own pattern—or your partner’s—take a breath. Seriously. Right now. Take a breath.

What you’re experiencing isn’t a character flaw. It’s not evidence that your relationship is doomed. It’s not proof that you or your partner are broken.

It’s evidence that you’re human beings with nervous systems shaped by your experiences, doing your best to stay safe in relationships.

The patterns you developed made sense. They served you once. They protected you.

And now, with awareness and practice and probably some patience and maybe some professional support, you can learn new patterns. You can expand your window of tolerance. You can develop the emotional muscle to stay present with each other even when it’s uncomfortable.

Helen and Nance did it. Hundreds of other couples I’ve worked with have done it. You can do it too.

This is what I’m passionate about—helping couples understand that communication problems are usually regulation problems in disguise, and that there’s a path forward that doesn’t require you to somehow become a different person or erase your past.

You just need to learn some new tricks. Your nervous system is ready. The question is: are you?

About the Author: Todd Creager has spent decades working with couples navigating infidelity, disconnection, and communication breakdowns. His approach focuses on understanding the deeper nervous system dynamics that drive relationship patterns, helping partners move from dysregulation and pain toward co-regulation and authentic connection. He specializes in helping couples who feel stuck in patterns that seem impossible to change.

Methodology Note: The insights in this article are drawn from direct clinical experience with hundreds of couples over multiple decades, integrated with current research on nervous system regulation, attachment theory, and trauma-informed care. The case examples are composites designed to illustrate common patterns while protecting client confidentiality. The emphasis on nervous system regulation as foundational to communication is based on both practical observation in therapy sessions and emerging neuroscience research on how autonomic nervous system states affect relational capacity.

Making the world safe for love.

What if your next argument could bring you closer instead of driving you apart?


Learn how in Todd Creager’s Loving & Connecting Masterclass.
Lifetime access. Real results.

Say Yes to a Better Relationship

Why Feeling Like a “Bad Person” After Betrayal Keeps You Stuck (And What Actually Helps)

by Leave a Comment

Here’s something I see all the time in my practice: the person who betrayed their partner comes in drowning in shame, convinced they’re fundamentally broken.

They’re so busy hating themselves that they can’t do the actual work of healing. That’s the paradox—the worse you feel about yourself, the less capable you become of making real changes.

Quick Overview: Guilt says “I did something bad.” Shame says “I am bad.” You need guilt as a signal that change is required, but shame? Shame keeps you paralyzed.

This article walks you through how to work with these feelings instead of getting consumed by them, based on what I’ve seen help hundreds of couples recover from infidelity.

But here’s what most people miss:

→ Calling yourself a “bad person” actually lets you off the hook from understanding why the betrayal happened

→ Your partner needs you functional and healing, not destroyed by self-condemnation

→ The betrayal came from a part of you trying to solve a problem badly—you need to understand that part, not just punish yourself for it

Who this is for: If you betrayed your partner and you’re struggling with crushing guilt and shame, this is for you. This is also valuable for betrayed partners trying to understand what’s happening with the person who hurt them.

Understanding the Difference Between Guilt and Shame (And Why It Matters for Your Recovery)

Let me be clear about something first. I’ve been accused of being too nice to people who cheat. That’s not true at all.

What you did was an interpersonal crime.

You stole from your partner—you stole their ability to make decisions based on true information.

Think about it this way: you drive up to an intersection and you need accurate information to decide what to do.

Can I turn left safely? Should I wait? You get this information through your senses, and then you make good decisions.

When you betrayed your partner, you deprived them of making decisions based on what was actually true.

That’s theft. That’s serious.

But—and this is where people get confused—just because you did something that lacks moral fiber doesn’t mean you are a bad person through and through.

Shame tells you you’re rotten at the core. In my 30+ years working with couples, I’ve found that shame is one of the biggest obstacles to actual healing.

Why? Because when you believe you’re fundamentally bad, you stop being curious.

You stop asking the important questions.

Guilt, on the other hand, is like the indicator light in your car. Your gas tank is low—pay attention, get off the road, fill up. That’s useful. Guilt says “I need to look at this. I need to make changes.” Once you’ve gotten the message and you’re doing the work, holding onto guilt becomes counterproductive.

The tricky part is this: many people who betrayed want their partner to just get over it quickly because they can’t tolerate the guilt.

They minimize what happened because their own discomfort is overwhelming them.

That’s not fair to your partner. Your partner has their own healing process, and it’s not on your schedule.

The Parts Work Approach: Why You’re Not Simply a “Cheater”

One of the most helpful frameworks I use comes from understanding that we all have different parts. There’s probably a part of you that would never, ever think about betraying your partner.

That part values loyalty, honesty, connection. But there was this other part that did betray.

And here’s what’s interesting—that part betrayed not only your partner, but it also betrayed the loyal part of you.

So what is that part about?

In almost every case I’ve worked with, the part that led to betrayal was trying to solve a problem. It just solved it in a terrible way.

Maybe you grew up in a family where your feelings were ignored, where nobody helped you tune into what you needed.

You learned early on to deal with pain by yourself. Fast forward to your adult relationship, and when you’re struggling, you don’t have the conscious option of going to your partner and saying “This is what I feel. This is what I need.”

That’s not really available to you as a choice—not because you’re bad, but because you never developed that emotional muscle.

So instead, this part of you found another way to cope. A way that involved secrecy and betrayal.

I’m not excusing it. What I am saying is that becoming a student of yourself—understanding what made you vulnerable to making this choice—is way more useful than just calling yourself a bad person and stopping there.

How to Forgive Yourself Without Minimizing What You Did

This is where people get stuck. They think forgiving themselves means they’re saying “it wasn’t that bad.” That’s not what it means.

Here’s the distinction: don’t forgive yourself if you’re not doing the work.

If you’re just sitting around waiting for time to pass, if you haven’t gotten curious about that part of you that betrayed, if you’re not actively building new emotional skills—then no, there’s nothing to forgive yet.

But if you are doing the work? If you’re in therapy, if you’re learning to understand yourself, if you’re developing the capacity to turn toward your partner with your struggles instead of away—then holding onto self-condemnation becomes pointless. It’s not helping you or your partner.

Forgiving yourself means letting go of the holding on. It means you stop making yourself small and broken. Your partner needs you to be strong enough to help them heal. They need you functional, not destroyed.

And here’s something people don’t talk about enough: when you stay stuck in shame, you’re actually making your partner the custodian of your feelings. You’re asking them to regulate your emotions for you by reassuring you that you’re not terrible. That’s not their job right now. They’ve got their own healing to do.

Living With What You’ve Done: The Scar Metaphor

One question I hear a lot: “Is it possible to live with what I’ve done?”

Yes. Absolutely yes.

Life isn’t simple and it’s not always tidy. It’s complex and it can be messy. What you did was hard for your partner and hard for you. A lot of people who cheat tell me it was a terrible time even while they were doing it. They hated having the secret, but they did it anyway.

I have a small scar on my hand. I have another one on my neck from skin cancer. You know what? I’m still beautiful. Scars don’t make me less beautiful.

You have a scar now. Your relationship has a scar. But it doesn’t take away from the beauty. We need to wrap our arms around that reality. Yes, there’s complexity in life. Yes, things aren’t always clean. But learning and repairing—that’s more important than having some perfect, unscarred relationship.

Almost all couples have scars. Maybe not the scar of infidelity, but something that happened through conflict or through immaturity that caused hurt. What matters is learning how to repair.

Can You Feel Like a Good Person Again?

Short answer: yes, if you do the work.

You are a person who had unconscious parts that hijacked you. As you repair yourself and repair your relationship, as you do the internal work and the relational work, why wouldn’t you feel like a good person?

We are fluid. We can move through life and make better choices now than we used to. That’s the whole point—not staying stuck in inertia, not staying the same, but growing.

The stronger your commitment to growth, the more likely this becomes your reality. When people make a partial commitment—when they’re sort of doing the work but not really all in—that’s when I see them slip back into old patterns.

What to Do If You Start Spiraling Into Self-Destruction

Sometimes people hit a skid. They start acting out. They feel guilty, then ashamed, then they do something else they regret, and they slide further down. I’ve seen this happen when someone hasn’t made that full commitment to healing.

If that’s happening to you: stop. Reach out. Don’t do this on your own.

Find someone like me who has extensive experience with infidelity recovery. Join a support group. Some people go to 12-step programs like Sex Addicts Anonymous or Sexaholics Anonymous and get sponsors. They jump right in.

This is not something to mess around with. You’re not alone and you don’t have to do this alone.

Yes, people relapse. It can happen. But when it does, the response isn’t to spiral further—it’s to reach out immediately for help.

The Real Work: Building New Emotional Muscles

Here’s what I want you to understand: this isn’t about being perfect from now on. It’s about developing the capacity to stay present with difficult feelings instead of running from them.

It’s about learning to go to your partner when you’re struggling instead of turning away. It’s about building what I call emotional muscles—the ability to tolerate discomfort, to be curious about what’s happening inside you, to ask for what you need directly.

This takes time. It takes practice. And yes, it often takes professional help because these patterns are deep.

But I’ve seen hundreds of couples come back from betrayal. I’ve watched relationships become deeper and more authentic after infidelity than they were before. Not because betrayal is good—it’s not. But because the crisis forced both people to show up differently, to be more honest, to stop sleepwalking through their connection.

That’s possible for you too. Not through hating yourself. Not through staying stuck in shame. But through getting curious, doing the work, and giving yourself permission to become a better version of yourself.

You can heal from this. Your relationship can heal from this. But it starts with understanding that you’re not simply “bad”—you’re human, you made a terrible choice, and now you have the opportunity to understand why and to change.

About the Author: Todd Creager is a licensed marriage and family therapist with over 30 years of experience specializing in couples therapy and infidelity recovery.

His approach combines compassion with accountability, helping both partners navigate the complex path from betrayal to healing. His work emphasizes that recovery is not just possible but can lead to deeper, more authentic relationships than existed before the betrayal.

Methodology Note: The insights in this article come from direct clinical experience with hundreds of couples recovering from infidelity, combined with Internal Family Systems (IFS) therapy principles and attachment-based approaches to relationship healing. Every situation is unique, and this article offers general principles rather than one-size-fits-all solutions. If you’re struggling with betrayal—whether you’re the person who betrayed or the betrayed partner—professional support is often essential for navigating the healing process.

Watch the Video Where Todd Explains Why Feeling Like A Bad Person After Betrayal is Keeping You Stuck

Recommended Resources

The Infidelity First Aid Kit

Go From Hurting to Happy Today...

When you click the button below, you’ll gain access to my exclusive Healing Infidelity From The Inside Out Guide.

It’s a powerful resource that will support you every step of the way, providing practical guidance and actionable steps toward finding peace within yourself.

healing infidelity from the inside out mock up
CLICK HERE TO GET STARTED NOW

Rebuilding Your Identity After Betraying Your Partner

by Leave a Comment

When Two Worlds Collide: Rebuilding Your Identity After Betraying Your Partner

Getting caught after betraying your partner isn’t just a crisis for them—it fundamentally changes how you see yourself.

Those separate lives you’ve been living suddenly crash together, leaving you disoriented and wondering:

Who am I now?

The hard truth most people miss: Recovery isn’t just about stopping the cheating behaviors.

It requires becoming curious about all parts of yourself—even the parts that betrayed—and discovering new ways to meet your needs without secrecy or betrayal.

The Identity Earthquake After Discovery

When your infidelity is discovered, you experience what I call an identity earthquake.

For weeks, months, or maybe even years, you’ve maintained two separate lives—the committed partner everyone sees and the secret self hidden from view. The compartmentalization that made this possible suddenly collapses.

This is profoundly disorienting.

While cheating, you might not have noticed the growing identity crisis beneath the surface because you were too busy juggling these separate worlds.

But when discovery happens, the question hits you with full force:

Who am I now that I’ve betrayed my values and my partner?

I’ve worked with hundreds of people in this exact situation.

One client told me, “I always saw myself as a good husband and father. Now I don’t know who I am anymore.” Another said, “I never thought I’d be capable of this. I don’t recognize myself.”

This identity confusion is a natural response to having your compartmentalized worlds suddenly merge.

Who Am I Now That I’ve Betrayed My Values?

Unless you’re a total sociopath (and if you’re reading this with concern, you probably aren’t), you’ve betrayed something important to you.

Most of us value honesty, commitment, and integrity. When we cheat, we betray these core values.

So who are you now?

You are the person who can be interested and curious about all the parts of you. That’s who you are.

This means being curious about the part of you that betrayed your values and hurt your partner. It means being curious about the part that’s angry at yourself for what you did.

It might even include the part that would never want to cheat if that were the only part of you.

Why is this curiosity so important? Because when we ask “who am I now,” life is giving you an answer: you need to get to know yourself—all of yourself.

I remember working with a man who had betrayed his wife multiple times. When he first came to therapy, he wanted to disown the “bad part” of himself that had cheated.

But healing only began when he became curious about why that part existed and what needs it was trying to meet, however misguided its methods.

Can I Become Someone My Partner Can Trust Again?

This question connects directly to the first one.

If you’re becoming the person who’s curious about all parts of yourself—even the parts you’re ashamed of—then yes, you can become trustworthy again.

As you get interested in these different parts of you, you become more conscious. And with consciousness comes choice. New options become available that weren’t before.

Many people who betray are actually missing possible choices. For example, someone who grew up in a home where feelings had to go underground might never have learned how to be vulnerable with their partner. The choice to share feelings and get support wasn’t in their emotional repertoire.

As you become interested in even the wounded parts of yourself, you discover new ways to meet your needs without betrayal.

You find you have more choices in how to regulate yourself and meet your needs in ways that don’t violate your values or hurt others.

I worked with a woman who discovered her pattern of betrayal was connected to feeling invisible in her marriage.

She never learned how to express her needs directly. Through therapy, she developed the ability to communicate her needs, making the escape of affairs unnecessary.

Is Change Even Possible For Someone Like Me?

The answer is absolutely yes. We’re not changing the core of who you are. What we’re trying to do is help you discover the core of who you are.

Your infidelities came from different factors—sometimes factors you weren’t even conscious of. As you become more aware through this work, change becomes possible because we do things for reasons.

When we find other options and choices, those reasons fade away.

We don’t need secrets and betrayal when we have healthier ways to meet our needs.

I’ve guided numerous serial betrayers through this journey of self-discovery.

One man had cheated in every relationship since college. Through our work together, he realized his betrayal was linked to deep fears of being trapped—fears connected to childhood experiences of being controlled. As he found healthier ways to maintain his sense of autonomy, his need for secret escapes disappeared.

What Does Recovery Look Like For A Serial Betrayer?

Recovery isn’t just about not cheating anymore. That’s part of it, but there’s so much more.

When you’re recovering, you’re communicating more openly. You’re being vulnerable—sharing what you feel, need, and want. You’re less self-absorbed because you don’t need all those protections you used to have.

This makes you more available to your partner.

You become a better listener. You’re more interested in what they’re going through. There’s room for their needs because you’re not so caught up in your own secret world.

You also see the benefit of saying no to immediate gratifications so you can say yes to what you really want—a good, healthy committed relationship.

Recovery means living with more intention.

You’re actively creating a relationship you feel good about. You’re not just avoiding negative behaviors—you’re building something positive.

And you’re not doing what I call “micro-hiding.” You’re not hiding your feelings. You’re letting your partner know you.

I remember a client who described his recovery this way: “Before, I was always planning my next escape. Now, I’m planning our next adventure together. The energy I used to put into hiding, I now put into connecting.”

Do I Need Therapy, Support Groups, Or Both?

In my experience, therapy is almost a necessity. Maybe I’m underestimating—maybe it is a necessity.

Why? Because we all have defense mechanisms. Even with the best intentions, trying to do this work on your own is like performing surgery on yourself. You need someone skilled who can help you navigate this journey, develop curiosity about yourself, and understand more deeply what’s going on with you.

It’s very difficult—nearly impossible—to do this alone. You need a guide.

It’s like visiting a new country—having a tour guide helps. A therapist might not know your particular landscape, but they know the landscape of these dynamics.

They understand what might be behind certain choices and can help you appreciate the different parts of yourself while still challenging you to grow.

Support groups can also be valuable. They help you consolidate your intention and connect with others who have gone through similar experiences.

Some people benefit greatly from support groups. Others thrive without them. This is something you can explore based on what feels right for you.

I’ve seen some clients do best with both therapy and support groups.

The therapist provides that one-on-one focus, while the group offers community and perspective.

The Accelerated Journey To Your Core Self

Identity naturally changes over time. The crisis of infidelity discovery can actually accelerate this journey toward your core—who you really are, who you want to become.

I’ve witnessed this transformation countless times.

One client described it as “finally feeling whole instead of split in two.” Another said, “For the first time, I don’t have to pretend to be someone I’m not.”

This doesn’t happen overnight. It requires courage to face parts of yourself you’ve kept hidden—not just from others but from your own awareness.

It means accepting responsibility without drowning in shame. It means developing compassion for yourself while still holding yourself accountable.

Practical First Steps For Your Recovery Journey

If you’re beginning this process of rebuilding your identity after betraying your partner, here are some practical starting points:

→ Start practicing curiosity about all parts of yourself.

When you feel shame or the urge to disown the part that betrayed, gently redirect yourself toward curiosity.

What was this part trying to accomplish? What needs was it trying to meet?

→ Seek professional help.

Find a therapist experienced with infidelity recovery. This isn’t a luxury—it’s a necessity for navigating this complex emotional terrain.

→ Begin noticing “micro-hiding”.

Pay attention to the small ways you might still be hiding aspects of yourself—not just behaviors but feelings and thoughts too.

→ Practice new forms of vulnerability.

Start sharing your authentic feelings and needs, beginning with lower-risk topics and gradually building to more significant ones.

→ Be patient with the process.

Identity rebuilding takes time. There will be setbacks along the way, but each one offers new opportunities for insight and growth.

Discovery of infidelity represents a crisis point, but crisis also means opportunity.

This painful moment can become the catalyst for developing an identity that’s more integrated, authentic, and capable of true intimacy than before.

I’ve seen people transform their lives after betrayal—not by becoming someone new, but by finally becoming who they truly are.

The compartmentalized life is exhausting.

Integration brings not just healing but a profound sense of relief and freedom.

This journey isn’t easy, but it’s worth it.

The person you become—whole, integrated, conscious—is capable of connection and intimacy beyond what was possible before.

This article draws on my extensive experience working with couples recovering from infidelity.

While each person’s journey is unique, these patterns of identity reconstruction have proven consistent across the many cases I’ve guided through this process.

The Infidelity First Aid Kit

Go From Hurting to Happy Today...

When you click the button below, you’ll gain access to my exclusive Healing Infidelity From The Inside Out Guide.

It’s a powerful resource that will support you every step of the way, providing practical guidance and actionable steps toward finding peace within yourself.

healing infidelity from the inside out mock up
CLICK HERE TO GET STARTED NOW