Here’s something I see all the time in my practice: the person who betrayed their partner comes in drowning in shame, convinced they’re fundamentally broken.
They’re so busy hating themselves that they can’t do the actual work of healing. That’s the paradox—the worse you feel about yourself, the less capable you become of making real changes.
Quick Overview: Guilt says “I did something bad.” Shame says “I am bad.” You need guilt as a signal that change is required, but shame? Shame keeps you paralyzed.
This article walks you through how to work with these feelings instead of getting consumed by them, based on what I’ve seen help hundreds of couples recover from infidelity.
But here’s what most people miss:
→ Calling yourself a “bad person” actually lets you off the hook from understanding why the betrayal happened
→ Your partner needs you functional and healing, not destroyed by self-condemnation
→ The betrayal came from a part of you trying to solve a problem badly—you need to understand that part, not just punish yourself for it
Who this is for: If you betrayed your partner and you’re struggling with crushing guilt and shame, this is for you. This is also valuable for betrayed partners trying to understand what’s happening with the person who hurt them.
Understanding the Difference Between Guilt and Shame (And Why It Matters for Your Recovery)
Let me be clear about something first. I’ve been accused of being too nice to people who cheat. That’s not true at all.
What you did was an interpersonal crime.
You stole from your partner—you stole their ability to make decisions based on true information.
Think about it this way: you drive up to an intersection and you need accurate information to decide what to do.
Can I turn left safely? Should I wait? You get this information through your senses, and then you make good decisions.
When you betrayed your partner, you deprived them of making decisions based on what was actually true.
That’s theft. That’s serious.
But—and this is where people get confused—just because you did something that lacks moral fiber doesn’t mean you are a bad person through and through.
Shame tells you you’re rotten at the core. In my 30+ years working with couples, I’ve found that shame is one of the biggest obstacles to actual healing.
Why? Because when you believe you’re fundamentally bad, you stop being curious.
You stop asking the important questions.
Guilt, on the other hand, is like the indicator light in your car. Your gas tank is low—pay attention, get off the road, fill up. That’s useful. Guilt says “I need to look at this. I need to make changes.” Once you’ve gotten the message and you’re doing the work, holding onto guilt becomes counterproductive.
The tricky part is this: many people who betrayed want their partner to just get over it quickly because they can’t tolerate the guilt.
They minimize what happened because their own discomfort is overwhelming them.
That’s not fair to your partner. Your partner has their own healing process, and it’s not on your schedule.
The Parts Work Approach: Why You’re Not Simply a “Cheater”
One of the most helpful frameworks I use comes from understanding that we all have different parts. There’s probably a part of you that would never, ever think about betraying your partner.
That part values loyalty, honesty, connection. But there was this other part that did betray.
And here’s what’s interesting—that part betrayed not only your partner, but it also betrayed the loyal part of you.
So what is that part about?
In almost every case I’ve worked with, the part that led to betrayal was trying to solve a problem. It just solved it in a terrible way.
Maybe you grew up in a family where your feelings were ignored, where nobody helped you tune into what you needed.
You learned early on to deal with pain by yourself. Fast forward to your adult relationship, and when you’re struggling, you don’t have the conscious option of going to your partner and saying “This is what I feel. This is what I need.”
That’s not really available to you as a choice—not because you’re bad, but because you never developed that emotional muscle.
So instead, this part of you found another way to cope. A way that involved secrecy and betrayal.
I’m not excusing it. What I am saying is that becoming a student of yourself—understanding what made you vulnerable to making this choice—is way more useful than just calling yourself a bad person and stopping there.
How to Forgive Yourself Without Minimizing What You Did
This is where people get stuck. They think forgiving themselves means they’re saying “it wasn’t that bad.” That’s not what it means.
Here’s the distinction: don’t forgive yourself if you’re not doing the work.
If you’re just sitting around waiting for time to pass, if you haven’t gotten curious about that part of you that betrayed, if you’re not actively building new emotional skills—then no, there’s nothing to forgive yet.
But if you are doing the work? If you’re in therapy, if you’re learning to understand yourself, if you’re developing the capacity to turn toward your partner with your struggles instead of away—then holding onto self-condemnation becomes pointless. It’s not helping you or your partner.
Forgiving yourself means letting go of the holding on. It means you stop making yourself small and broken. Your partner needs you to be strong enough to help them heal. They need you functional, not destroyed.
And here’s something people don’t talk about enough: when you stay stuck in shame, you’re actually making your partner the custodian of your feelings. You’re asking them to regulate your emotions for you by reassuring you that you’re not terrible. That’s not their job right now. They’ve got their own healing to do.
Living With What You’ve Done: The Scar Metaphor
One question I hear a lot: “Is it possible to live with what I’ve done?”
Yes. Absolutely yes.
Life isn’t simple and it’s not always tidy. It’s complex and it can be messy. What you did was hard for your partner and hard for you. A lot of people who cheat tell me it was a terrible time even while they were doing it. They hated having the secret, but they did it anyway.
I have a small scar on my hand. I have another one on my neck from skin cancer. You know what? I’m still beautiful. Scars don’t make me less beautiful.
You have a scar now. Your relationship has a scar. But it doesn’t take away from the beauty. We need to wrap our arms around that reality. Yes, there’s complexity in life. Yes, things aren’t always clean. But learning and repairing—that’s more important than having some perfect, unscarred relationship.
Almost all couples have scars. Maybe not the scar of infidelity, but something that happened through conflict or through immaturity that caused hurt. What matters is learning how to repair.
Can You Feel Like a Good Person Again?
Short answer: yes, if you do the work.
You are a person who had unconscious parts that hijacked you. As you repair yourself and repair your relationship, as you do the internal work and the relational work, why wouldn’t you feel like a good person?
We are fluid. We can move through life and make better choices now than we used to. That’s the whole point—not staying stuck in inertia, not staying the same, but growing.
The stronger your commitment to growth, the more likely this becomes your reality. When people make a partial commitment—when they’re sort of doing the work but not really all in—that’s when I see them slip back into old patterns.
What to Do If You Start Spiraling Into Self-Destruction
Sometimes people hit a skid. They start acting out. They feel guilty, then ashamed, then they do something else they regret, and they slide further down. I’ve seen this happen when someone hasn’t made that full commitment to healing.
If that’s happening to you: stop. Reach out. Don’t do this on your own.
Find someone like me who has extensive experience with infidelity recovery. Join a support group. Some people go to 12-step programs like Sex Addicts Anonymous or Sexaholics Anonymous and get sponsors. They jump right in.
This is not something to mess around with. You’re not alone and you don’t have to do this alone.
Yes, people relapse. It can happen. But when it does, the response isn’t to spiral further—it’s to reach out immediately for help.
The Real Work: Building New Emotional Muscles
Here’s what I want you to understand: this isn’t about being perfect from now on. It’s about developing the capacity to stay present with difficult feelings instead of running from them.
It’s about learning to go to your partner when you’re struggling instead of turning away. It’s about building what I call emotional muscles—the ability to tolerate discomfort, to be curious about what’s happening inside you, to ask for what you need directly.
This takes time. It takes practice. And yes, it often takes professional help because these patterns are deep.
But I’ve seen hundreds of couples come back from betrayal. I’ve watched relationships become deeper and more authentic after infidelity than they were before. Not because betrayal is good—it’s not. But because the crisis forced both people to show up differently, to be more honest, to stop sleepwalking through their connection.
That’s possible for you too. Not through hating yourself. Not through staying stuck in shame. But through getting curious, doing the work, and giving yourself permission to become a better version of yourself.
You can heal from this. Your relationship can heal from this. But it starts with understanding that you’re not simply “bad”—you’re human, you made a terrible choice, and now you have the opportunity to understand why and to change.
About the Author: Todd Creager is a licensed marriage and family therapist with over 30 years of experience specializing in couples therapy and infidelity recovery.
His approach combines compassion with accountability, helping both partners navigate the complex path from betrayal to healing. His work emphasizes that recovery is not just possible but can lead to deeper, more authentic relationships than existed before the betrayal.
Methodology Note: The insights in this article come from direct clinical experience with hundreds of couples recovering from infidelity, combined with Internal Family Systems (IFS) therapy principles and attachment-based approaches to relationship healing. Every situation is unique, and this article offers general principles rather than one-size-fits-all solutions. If you’re struggling with betrayal—whether you’re the person who betrayed or the betrayed partner—professional support is often essential for navigating the healing process.
Watch the Video Where Todd Explains Why Feeling Like A Bad Person After Betrayal is Keeping You Stuck
Recommended Resources
Go From Hurting to Happy Today...
When you click the button below, you’ll gain access to my exclusive Healing Infidelity From The Inside Out Guide.
It’s a powerful resource that will support you every step of the way, providing practical guidance and actionable steps toward finding peace within yourself.



